Why Lead Was Fine for Repairing the Altar, But Not Every Metal
Why Lead Was Fine for Repairing the Altar, But Not Every Metal
Part of Beit Hamikdash · 15:21
A detailed class on the Beis Hamikdash's altar construction requirements, which defects in a stone were disqualifying, and which metals were acceptable for repairs.
Audio Transcript
side, there is a little window there. Oh, here you have a better picture, the other Look at the other page. The other page, you see, this is the 讻讘砖 讙讚讜诇, the regular 讻讘砖. This is the small 讻讘砖 coming to the 住讜讘讘. This is the small 讻讘砖 coming down to the 讬住讜讚. And on this place, there was a 专讘讜讘讛, there was this window that here you would throw in the 讞讟讗转 讛注讜祝 砖谞驻住诇讛. You mean from the ground you threw it in? No, on the ramp. Oh, you went on the ramp? Yeah, yeah, on the ramp. When it became pasul, they would take it to this place, they would go To that small ramp on this up to the 住讜讘讘, huh? Yeah, yeah. Like you stand there This to the left. No, that's that's Interesting, so they threw the birds in there? The the pasulah. Yeah, and how how do they get them out? Well, they threw it in, they put it in, and then it's big enough where you're going to crawl through there? No, not crawl, they put it in, they threw it in and then they would take it out Then he says, like 讜砖谞讬 砖诇讞谞讜转 讛讬讜 讘诪注专讘 讛讻讘砖, on the
诪注专讘 side of the 讻讘砖, there were two tables. 讗讞讚 砖诇 砖讬砖, 砖谞讜转谞讬诐 注诇讬讜 讗转 讛讗讘专讬诐, one was made of marble that you would put the pieces of meat that you needed from the 拽专讘谞讜转, 讜讗讞讚 砖诇 讻住祝 砖谞讜转谞讬诐 注诇讬讜 讻诇讬 砖专转, one is of silver that you would put on the 讻诇讬诐 there. So here you actually have pictures. Here you have one table where you put down, you know, the pieces of the 驻讙专讬诐, and here you have all these 讻诇讬诐 that you need that they would put it on. What was the What was the 讻诇讬诐 for? Huh? What was those 讻诇讬诐 for? Well, the knife to shachat and to take the 讻诇讬 to sprinkle the blood, all these things. They they poured the blood here, they took a hold here. Yeah, yeah. It's a little similar to this, it's a different picture, but that picture is right. Yeah, that's going to be those pictures, cuz see, this is the blood here. Yeah, but here you have also to show where they have to sprinkle the blood on the side of the 诪讝讘讞. That's that picture. I think they have that picture here later also. It's a poor conductor of heat, and they didn't want it to to the other so that the meat When you shachat, it's still warm. Yeah, but that's Why would you think it'd become tamei? Yeah, because it shouldn't be metal. It should that should be should be cold. To keep keep it fresh, like. They built in the same place? Yeah. Where are we holding here? 讻砖讘讜谞讬谉 讛诪讝讘讞,
when they build the 诪讝讘讞, 讘讜谞讬谉 讗讜转讜 讻讜诇讜 讗讟讜诐 讻诪讬谉 注诪讜讚. It was all solid, like a like a like a beam. 讜讗讬谉 讬砖 讘讜 讞诇诇 讻诇诇, there was no it wasn't hollow on the bottom, it's not like sometimes you you would make, like the 诪讝讘讞 in 讘讬转 讛诪- in 诪砖讻谉 was hollow, and then they filled it up with sand, but here it wasn't hollow, it was solid. 讗诇讗 诪讘讬讗, and how did they make it? 诪讘讬讗 讗讘谞讬诐 砖诇诪讜转 讙讚讜诇讜转 讜拽讟谞讜转, you bring all kinds of stones, and 砖诇诪讜转, it had to be 砖诇诪讜转, you remember from before, it cannot be with a 驻讙诐 and it cannot be also that it should be cut, so they have to be whole, but they got big stones, small stones, you put it together, 讜诪讘讬讗 住讬讚 讜讝驻转 讜拽讜谞讬讗, you would bring these these ingredients, plaster and other things that, you know, to to stick it together, 讜诪诪讞讛, you would melt it, 讜砖讜驻讱, you take and just mix it in with the stones. What does happen? So it's like when you have cement before I don't mean melt it, I mean it's Molten lead, you trip lead. before Like like cement before it hardens, what's it called? It's Cement. It's cement, it's liquid. I mean it's liquid, so this is liquid, yeah, and you would put it all into a big form. You make like a big frame, 讻诪讬讚讜转讬讜, in the measurement of the of the 诪讝讘讞. You'd make like out of wood a big frame, which and then you would pour all this in and it when it when it would harden, it would harden according to the measurements of the whatever you made, so you would build Then you can't you can't see the stones then. No, then you took off the wood. Oh, well you take off the wood, you see You see then you see the plaster. Yeah, it doesn't have to be. Huh? Whenever if they have to make a 诪讝讘讞. But I mean you could see If you build the 诪讝讘讞, that's how they do it. It says 讘讜谞讬谉, yeah. But in other words, you see the big stones, but you see the the mortar in between. Yeah, you see the mortar in between, yeah.
There's no problem Lead is a metal. There's no problem to have this poured lead in here, to line with pitch and molten lead and pour it in there? I don't know what it means of this, whatever it is. I'm saying, it's no problem when it's a metal to be poured in? I don't know, it wasn't regular lead. If it If lead is a metal, then it wasn't, you couldn't have metal here. It's not metal. 讜讘讜谞讛 讜注讜诇讛. Yeah, they Because they took the stone, they have other to the 诪讝讘讞. 讜讘讜谞讛 讜注讜诇讛, you would build it up. 讜谞讜转谉 讘转讜讱 讛讘谞讬谉 讙讜祝 砖诇 注抓 讗讜 讗讘谉 讘拽专谉 讚专讜诪讬转 诪讝专讞讬转 砖诇讗 讬讛讗 诇讛 讬住讜讚. And when it comes to the 讬住讜讚, yeah, they would put in a piece of wood where they didn't want there should be the 讬住讜讚. And what do they do? So then when they poured this whole mixture and it hardens, and then they took away the piece of wood, became empty. So wherever like we learned yesterday at one place there was a the 讬住讜讚 only stuck out on two sides, and here a little bit and here a little bit, but these mainly two sides were empty. How did they make it empty? So they put the wood there. 讜讻谉 注砖讜 诇转讜讱 讻诇 拽专谉 讜拽专谉, here also, when they made the horns, they would make it like that. They would put a piece of wood here and a piece of wood here, so, and then, so when they made the, and then when they took the wood out, it became hollow, because we learned yesterday that the 拽专谞讜转 stuck out from the 诪讝讘讞, but they were hollow. They were an 讗诪讛 high, an 讗诪讛 of five 讟驻讞讬诐, a smaller 讗诪讛, but it was empty, it was hollow. How did it hollow? Because when they poured it, they put a piece of wood there, and then later they took it out. 讗讞专讬 注砖讜 讛讘谞讬谉, 讜讬住讬专 讛讙讜驻讬诐 砖讘转讜讱 讛讘谞讬谉, they would take off these pieces that they put inside, 讻讚讬 砖讬砖讗专 拽专谉 讚专讜诪讬转 诪讝专讞讬转 讘诇讗 讬住讜讚, so they took off the piece of wood which they put on the bottom, so that place where they had the wood was not become, did not become hard, and it was empty, 讜讬砖讗专讜 讛拽专谞讜转 讞诇讜诇讬谉, and the 拽专谞讜转, the corners, were left hollow. 讗专讘注 拽专谞讜转, now the Rambam says what's me'akev? What must be, and if not, it's pasul? 讗专讘注 拽专谞讜转 砖诇 诪讝讘讞, the four corners of the 诪讝讘讞, the four, okay, horns that we call them, to stick out. 讜讬住讜讚讜, and the 讬住讜讚. 讜专讬讘讜注讜, Had a top. Huh? The horn always had a top. Had a top? Yeah, had a top. Rebbe, so how did they make the, Well, why not? How do they get it out afterwards? How did they get the wood outside, out of the out of the, you want to know how they get the wood out of it? Could not the wood fall into the horn? So maybe they open, they opened up the top and they took it out, and then they put This should have said top. This should have said top. He's going by No, it wasn't solid. It was open from the top. It's open from the top. 拽专谞讜转 were hollow. So how did they make it hollow Open from the top. and the top was in fact covered? No, the top was not covered. Yeah, but we don't In the pictures it's not hollow. I mean, it's hollow, but the picture it has a top. In the pictures it has a top. It's open on the top. See? Here. Yeah, it has the pictures there. Okay, so that's how they made it. They made it with separate This is the 诪讝讘讞, there's more, I know. But here, see? This has a top, you see? Here it has. Here, here it is. And here you have also these parts. Yeah. No, that's not how they did it. That's not how they did it. This is just showing the pieces. That's not how they did it. Why? It was different pieces. No, it wasn't. It wasn't all attached, it was that that's each, that that's each No, it was when when they poured this whole thing, this was poured, too. But only around, and the middle was empty because they had a piece of wood there, and then they took out the piece of wood. How? Well, maybe they put the top on later. Oh, there was a top later? I think so, or maybe they didn't put the top lechatchilah, and they put it on later. Which one? 住诪\"讞. You don't know where the top, how the top fits in. 住诪\"讞, yeah, here. Here it says here the vision was hollow on the top, even though they showed it closed. We just said that, that's what you said. No, that doesn't answer it. That's what we said. You said before. Here it says from Zevachim. I don't know if you want to look at Zevachim anymore, but Zechariah says they should be filled like bowls like the corners of the altar. The vision implies that under, like, within the altar's corners, can serve as receptacles. Receptacles. They can serve as receptacles, it had to be hollow on the top. But in the Mishkan, the part of the 诪讝讘讞, so this wasn't, that they were But in the Mishkan, the 拽专谞讜转 on the 诪讝讘讞 were part of the Here also it was part of the 诪讝讘讞. Here was also part of the 诪讝讘讞. Yeah, but again, it was part No, I'm saying maybe they didn't lechatchilah, when they made it, they didn't make the top, and they took out the wood, and then they made the top. This what he says what the way he did it, that's not me'akev, that's a prac- a practical thing to do, it's not an halachah you have to do this way. So I'm saying, so practically you probably didn't make the top, they took out the wood, and then they covered it. Put some wood there, but it's not mentioned. Then the 拽专谞讜转 were not really part of the 诪讝讘讞, because they were put on top. It was! No, when they built it, they built it with the 拽专谞讜转! When they put in the whole thing, they put it with the 拽专谞讜转, and the piece of wood inside! Then they took out probably the piece of wood, and they covered it. If it was covered. Or maybe it wasn't covered. Looks like it was covered. Who says it wasn't covered? Looks like it was covered. Think the picture's wrong. Could be. Not that I say the pictures are right, but the people who made the pictures, that's what, they think so, they did did they did investigations, did research, and they did whatever they did, that's why I trust them. I, if somebody made a mistake, sure somebody made a mistake. There's a lot of research. Yes, the other side, yeah, yeah, not the 诪专讗讜转, but this is the same the the of the Har HaBayit, yeah. Okay, let's let's try to finish this. It's also hard to draw, it's hard to draw this. 讗专讘注 拽专谞讜转 砖诇 诪讝讘讞, the four corners of, the horns of the 诪讝讘讞. 讜讬住讜讚讜, and the 讬住讜讚. 讜专讬讘讜注讜, and the fact that it has to be square, me'akvin. Just like in tefillin, if it's not square it's pasul, the 诪讝讘讞, if it's not square it's pasul. See the way they draw here, it shows it kinda alludes to to it being hollow on top. See the shadow over there? That's No, otherwise you wouldn't be able to see the square, I think that's why they did it, not because it was open. Sure, I think you can see it here. Uh well, I mean it's alright, okay. could say shaded. Okay. 讜讻诇
诪讝讘讞 砖讗讬谉 诇讜 拽专谉, 讬住讜讚, 讜讻讘砖, 讜专讬讘讜注, any 诪讝讘讞 that doesn't have the 拽专谉, and it doesn't have the 讬住讜讚, and doesn't have the 讻讘砖, the ramp, and the 专讬讘讜注, the square, 讛专讬 讛讜讗 驻住讜诇, 砖讛讗专讘注转谉 诪注讻讘讬谉. All four things are me'akev. 讗讘诇 诪讬讚转 讗讜专讻讜, but the size of the length, 讜诪讬讚转 专讜讞讘讜, or the size of the width, 讜诪讬讚转 拽讜诪转讜, or the height, 讗讬谞谉 诪注讻讘讬谉, is not me'akev. Let's say for some reason it became smaller, but as long as it was square, it doesn't matter. 讜讛讜讗 砖诇讗 讬驻讞转 诪讗诪讛 注诇 讗诪讛, as long as it has at least one 讗诪讛 by one 讗诪讛, 讜专讜诐 砖诇讜砖 讗诪讜转, the height of three 讗诪讜转, 讻砖讬注讜专 诪拽讜诐 讛诪注专讻讛 砖诇 诪讝讘讞 诪讚讘专, like the shiur of the 诪拽讜诐 讛诪注专讻讛 of the 诪讝讘讞 in the 诪讚讘专 was this size, and that's the minimum it has to be. But more than that, it doesn't have to be. But b'foal, even though Shlomo made the 诪讝讘讞 bigger, much bigger, but that was, but not me'akev. Vayter. 诪讝讘讞 砖谞驻讙诐 诪讘谞讬讬谞讜, if the 诪讝讘讞 has a 驻讙诐 in the building, and I'll explain what it means. 讗诐 谞驻讙诐 诪讘谞讬讬谞讜 讻讚讬 讟驻讞, if it's, a 驻讙诐 has a 驻讙讬诪讛 of a 讟驻讞, 驻住讜诇. 驻讞讜转 诪讟驻讞, 讻砖专. Less than a 讟驻讞, it's kasher. Ai, we said we, yes, we learned the other day that the stones of the 诪讝讘讞, even a 驻讙讬诪讛 like a, like a 讞诇祝 of the shechitah, a tiny, tiny 驻讙讬诪讛 is pasul, so he says, 讜讛讜讗 砖诇讗 讬讛讗 讘谞讬讻专 讗讘谉 驻讙讜诪讛. As long as there's no, you have There's two things. You have after you have the whole 诪讝讘讞, you have the whole mixture of this, what's it called, mo- mortar? Mortar. And you have the mixture. So when you looked at the 诪讝讘讞, what you saw was, you saw the plaster and they would actually plaster it, we learned, every year. If that got a 驻讙诐, then it's up to a 讟驻讞, it's still kasher. A
stone got a 驻讙诐, that's 驻住讜诇, 讗驻讬诇讜 讻讚讬 讻讚讬 爪驻讜专谉, even if it's like this. The stone is the real frame, so that Not the frame, the stone is what it was made of. So, not even the foundation? Yeah, the whole inside of the 诪讝讘讞. That's why they covered it, maybe to protect the stones? Possibly. Also That would be a big problem if if the stone got what they call That then then they have to, no. Take it out? No, you take it out and you put in That's what we learned, you could fix it. So if the stones are protected by plaster, then you don't see if it's chipped. Right, you don't. You only see You only see smooth plaster. But if it chipped, it could be. So as long as it didn't chip a more than a 讟驻讞, a 讟驻讞 or more, it's still kasher, but if it chipped more than a 讟驻讞, it's pasul. Mah she'ein kein if the stone for somehow, let's say it chipped a little bit and you see the stone behind the plaster, and it chipped a drop, then it's pasul. So it have to be removed and you have to put a different stone in. The mortar wasn't only in between the stones, it was covering this whole It was, yeah, that's so yeah, and they actually did it every Pesach we learned. Right before it, they would they would Yeah, every replaster it, yeah. If you say that the 拽专谉 was made of stone, and it shelled out That's all we got up to. No, in other words, no, the 拽专谉 was hollow. Yeah. So mister, what, can it be a stone that they made hollow? Yeah, how did No, and they held it in place and cemented around it, and did their plaster around it? But a stone doesn't have a How do you The whole 诪讝讘讞 was made of 讗讘谞讬诐. No, we said how it was made, they put it all together. Just stones. It's stones that they put around it. Not around, no. They mixed it lechatchilah with with cement, with whatever it is, and they put it into a frame, and and they build it and they put it in, when it hardened it became the 诪讝讘讞. The stones, how big are the stones? Small and big, all kinds, all kinds. So, they put whatever, small, whatever. It's natural. Good, good, good. So, then they take plaster and they plaster around it, and it all it all looks nice and and clean. Yeah. But the 拽专谉, how big was the 拽专谉? It's 讗诪讛, 讗诪讛. 讗诪讛? Yeah. A foot and a half. So, they take a stone this big, and they hollow out How do they hollow it out? With a chisel, not with a 讘专讝诇. 讘专讝诇? 讙讝讬转 is, no. Yeah, 讙讝讬转 no, 讙讝讬转 you know, you can't have a 讘专讝诇, you can't do that. What about that worm? That's a busy worm. By by 讘讬转 砖谞讬, there was no worm. By 讘讬转 砖诇讬砖讬... You take it out. No, his question was, how did they take the wood out? The frame, they take out the frame. If the top is open Oh, the top was open! Maybe the bottom was not open. Yeah, no, but if It could be open on the bottom. The bottom was hollow. The whole 诪讝讘讞 was solid too here. And they had to only pour it at once. Pour it at once? Yeah, yeah. Is that all of them, or just Why not? Maybe they poured half first and Still then, still not half. But if you pour it half, then you can get in. Not from half, from the top. No, but like you say, it wasn't it was two pours, at least according to this: \"Once it was filled, then four molds, each a cubit by cubit, one cubit high, were placed in each corner for the horns, and then you do the second pouring for the 拽专谞讜转.\" Huh? Once it was filled, then the four molds Once it was filled, the whole 诪讝讘讞 was filled, a box, and then they made the four horns. One pour, it's different in the 诪砖讻谉. The 诪砖讻谉 was made at once, together, at once. Right? The 诪砖讻谉 the 拽专谞讜转 came out But then it's a block of wood in the middle like a form. The 拽专谞讜转 came and they pulled it out. But it was hollow on the top, the pictures all show closed. They had to close it afterwards. Okay, that's what That doesn't, that sounds like two pieces. It probably had to be closed anyway because You always say one piece, maybe in the 诪砖讻谉 the karnot were part of the of the mizbeach.