Why Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai Warned of the Temple's Doom 40 Years Early
Why Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai Warned of the Temple's Doom 40 Years Early
Part of Beit Hamikdash · 14:44
Explores a verse hinting at an altar in Egypt, the ominous sign of the Temple doors opening by themselves, and the two confessions of the Kohen Gadol on Yom Kippur.
Audio Transcript
What the Eibershter said, and he brought this pasuk. Rabbi Meir says it was for avodah zarah. What does he do with this pasuk? Doesn't this pasuk say that there will be a 诪讝讘讞 to Hashem in 讗专抓 诪爪专讬诐? So the Gemara says, it comes for something else. Look at the Tanya, it comes for something that we learned in a 讘专讬讬转讗. What does it say in a 讘专讬讬转讗? It says in a 讘专讬讬转讗 like this: 诇讗讞专 诪驻诇转, 诪驻诇转讜 砖诇 住谞讞专讬讘, after Sancheriv had his 诪驻诇讛, yeah, 讞讝拽- Chizkiyah was the one that won, Chizkiyah came out, 讜诪爪讗 he found 讘谞讬 诪诇讻讬诐, children of the kings, princes, 砖讛讬讜 讬讜砖讘讬诐 讘拽专讜谞讜转 砖诇 讝讛讘. They were 讙讜讬诐, but he found them sitting in wagons of gold. 讛讚讬专诐 砖诇讗 讬注讘讚讜 注讘讜讚讛 讝专讛. So he forced them, he made them make a neder not to worship avodah zarah. 砖谞讗诪专 it says, 讘讬讜诐 讛讛讜讗 讬讛讬讛 讞诪砖 注专讬诐 讘讗专抓 诪爪专讬诐, there will be five cities in 讗专抓 诪爪专讬诐, 诪讚讘专讜转 砖驻转 讻谞注谉, speak the language of 讻谞注谉, 讜谞砖讘注讜转 诇讛' 爪讘讗讜转. They will swear to Hashem. So these are people that were 讙讜讬诐, but they spoke the language of 讻谞注谉 because they were in 讗专抓 讬砖专讗诇, and they they swore in Hashem's name. And these people 讛诇讻讜 诇讗诇讻住谞讚专讬讗 砖诇 诪爪专讬诐, went to 讗诇讻住谞讚专讬讗 诪爪专讬诐, 讜讘谞讜 诪讝讘讞, built a 诪讝讘讞, 讜讛注诇讜 注讜诇讜转 诇砖诐 砖诪讬诐. Since they promised not to do avodah zarah, so when they did the 诪讝讘讞 in 讗诇讻住谞讚专讬讗 they made it to Hashem. 砖谞讗诪专, and that's the 驻砖讟 in the pasuk, it says, 讘讬讜诐 讛讛讜讗 讬讛讬讛 诪讝讘讞 诇讛' 讘转讜讱 讗专抓 诪爪专讬诐. It says that it would be a in Mitzrayim there will be a mizbeach to Hashem. Then the pasuk also finishes, 注讬专 讛讛专住 讬讗诪专 诇讗讞转. To one of them it will be said this will be a city of destruction. 诪讗讬 注讬专 讛讛专住 讬讗诪专 诇讗讞转? What does that mean, that one city will be they will say destruction? 讻讚诪转专讙诐 Rav Yosef, as Rav Yosef said, 拽专转讗 讚讘讬转 砖诪砖 讚注转讬讚讗 诇诪讬讞专讘. The city of Beit Beit Shemesh, it's called Beit Shemesh, always says Beit Shemesh, yeah, 讘讬转, 转专讙讜诐 讗专诪讬 砖诇 讘讬转 砖诪砖, 讚注转讬讚讗 诇诪讬讞专讘, that will eventually get destroyed, 讬转讗诪专 讚讛讬讗 讞讚讗 诪谞讛讜谉. This is one of the five. That's what they're going to say. Now,
how does it fit to the word 注讬专 讛讛专住? Or 讞专住, you could say 讞专住, because a 讛 and a 讞 could change. How so 注讬专 讞专住 or 注讬专 讛讛专住, you taytsh in 讘讬转, 注讬专 is like a house, and 讞专住 like a 砖诪砖. How does that so the Gemara asks, how does the word 讞专住 诇讬砖谞讗 讚砖诪砖讗 讛讜讗? How is it a lashon of sun? 砖谞讗诪专 it says, 讛讗讜诪专 诇讞专住 讜诇讗 讬讝专讞. The pasuk is saying, that 讚注专 讗讬讬讘注专砖讟注专 is going to say to the 讞专住 not to shine. What's the 讞专住? The sun! Won't shine, and 讜讘注讚 讻讜讻讘讬诐 讬讞转讜诐, and He's going to close up the 讻讜讻讘讬诐, the stars. But the bottom line we see that 讞专住 is, so that's what it says here: there were five cities in Eretz Mitzrayim, and Beit Shemesh was one of them. Beit Shemesh is Shimshon, in Hebrew is Shimshon, all these things, tick and Shimshon is right there. Taytsh Shimshon 砖诪砖. Ah! That's why he called Shimshon, because his name is after 砖诪砖, 讛讜讬' 诪讙谉 讗诇拽讬诐. No, everything that his name was Shimshon in the whole area. You should know. Huh? You should know. That's why I know. 讝讗讙讟 讚讬 Gemara weiter, 转谞讜 专讘谞谉, the Rabbanan
have learned, 讗专讘注讬诐 砖谞讛 拽讜讚诐 讞讜专讘谉 讛讘讬转, 40 years before the 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖 was destroyed, 诇讗 讛讬讛 讙讜专诇 注讜诇讛 讘讬诪讬谉. For 40 years, the goral on the korban, 诇注讝讗讝诇, on the korban, two 砖谞讬 砖注讬专讬诐, and it says it's a good siman if the one on the right side comes out to Hashem, it didn't happen. 讜诇讗 讛讬讛 诇砖讜谉 砖诇 讝讛讜专讬转 诪诇讘讬谉. Yeah, it was like sometimes yes, sometimes not. It didn't come out at all? This never, the last 40 years it didn't... It was always never on the... that he died 40 years before. Shimon Hatzadik was at the beginning. How could he have 40 years before the churban he died? 40 years, yeah. And the remaining years he was kohen gadol. Yeah, Anshei Knesset Hagedolah was in the time of 讙诇讜转 讘讘诇, into the first 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖, into the second 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖. Second 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖. Yeah, but the 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖 stood for 420 years. Yeah. So if it says, it means he lived very long. That's how it is. And he would have had to have been kohen gadol for a couple hundred years. No, he became kohen gadol later. And this this whole story with Chonio and Shimon, when did that happen? The last 40 years? No, I don't know, basically, I don't know. And the 诇砖讜谉 砖诇 讝讛讜专讬转, that piece of thing that they put on the in the horns that would turn white, that never happened. Those 40 years it normally didn't malbin. For 砖注讬专 讛诪砖转诇讞. Azazel was what they one they threw off the cliff. That's the one they put the red the red on. Yeah. They didn't put it on both, only on the one they threw off the cliff. But it it got white before it fell off, before he knocked down. Yeah, before it 诇讗 讛讬讛 谞专 诪注专讘讬 讚讜诇拽. And the 谞专 诪注专讘讬, which always burned, didn't burn, extra. 讜讛讬讜 讚诇转讜转 讛讛讬讻诇 谞驻转讞讜转 诪讗诇讬讛谉. The walls would open by themselves. This was a siman to show the walls are open open for all the people, all the enemies, to come in. The doors. The doors open by themselves. But it's a bad siman, like open to the public and allowing whoever is going to come in could come in.
注讚 砖讙注专 讘讛谉 专讘谉 讬讜讞谞谉 讘谉 讝讻讗讬. Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai screamed at them. He lived at that time right before the churban, during the churban. 讜讗诪专 诇讜, and he said to him, 讛讬讻诇 讛讬讻诇. Told the 讛讬讻诇, 诪驻谞讬 诪讛 讗转讛 诪讘注讬转 讗转 注爪诪讱? Why are you scaring yourself? 讬讜讚注 讗谞讬 讘讱 砖住讜驻讱 注转讬讚 诇讛讬讞专讘. The end will be that you're going to be destroyed. 讜讻讘专 谞转谞讘讗 注诇讬讱 讝讻专讬讛 讘谉 注讚讜讗. Zechariah already said a a nevuah about you. Says, 驻转讞 诇讘谞讜谉 讚诇转讬讱 讜转讗讻诇 讗砖 讘讗专讝讬讱, that the 诇讘谞讜谉 should open its doors and the 诇讘谞讜谉 goes on the 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖, and let the fire burn up your wood. So, he said already, we know Huh? How? When? No, this was by the Churban. Zechariah. Oh, the Zechariah was before. But he was a 谞讘讬讗 towards the end. towards the end of No, even before that. It was in the beginning. Chagai, Zechariah, Malachi were the last three 谞讘讬讗讬诐 which were in the beginning of the 讘讬转 砖谞讬, the beginning of the 讘讬转 砖谞讬. He already said 谞讘讜讗讛 then. 400 years before, yeah. Because it says 谞讘讬讗讬诐 讗讞专讜谞讬诐. 讙' 谞讘讬讗讬诐 注诇讜 诪讘讘诇, the
three 谞讘讬讗讬诐 that came from Bavel, Chagai, Zechariah, Malachi. And they each one said gave over a 讚讬谉. One told them the the place of the of the 诪讝讘讞, one told them the size of the 诪讝讘讞, one told them the 讚讬谉 that you don't need a 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖 to burn, to bring a 拽专讘谉, whatever it is. But they were right in the beginning. Yeah, this was much before, much before. 讗诪专 专讘讬 讬爪讞拽 讘专 讟讘诇讬讬, Rabbi Yitzchak bar Tavlai said, 诇诪讛 谞拽专讗 砖诪讜 诇讘谞讜谉? Why is it called 诇讘谞讜谉 the 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖? 诇讘谞讜谉 comes the word white. 砖诪诇讘讬谉 注讜谞讜转讬讛谉 砖诇 讬砖专讗诇, it whitens the 注讘讬专讜转 of 讗讬讚谉. 讗诪专 专讘 讝讜讟专讗 讘专 讟讜讘讬讛, Rav Zutra bar Tuvia said, 诇诪讛 谞拽专讗 砖诪讜 讬注专? You know it's also called 讬注专. 讚讻转讬讘, it says, 讘讬转 讬注专 讛诇讘谞讜谉. 讬注专 means a forest. Why is it a 讬注专? Why is it like a forest? 诇讜诪专 诇讱, to tell you, 诪讛 讬注专 诪诇讘诇讘, just like a forest grows and sprouts, that's the word. Yeah. 讗祝 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖 诪诇讘诇讘, the 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖 also sprouted. Where do we see it? 讚讗诪专 专讘 讗讜砖注讬讗, Rav Oshaya an interesting thing, we learned that before. 讘砖注讛 砖讘谞讛 砖诇诪讛 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖,
when Shlomo built the 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖, 谞讟注 讘讜 讻诇 诪讬谞讬 诪讙讚讬诐 砖诇 讝讛讘, planted all kinds of fruit, golden fruit. 讜讛讬讜 诪讜爪讬讗讬谉 驻讬专讜转讬讛谉 讘讝诪谞讬讛谉. In the season when the fruit grew, it grew there too. 讜讻讬讜谉 砖讛专讜讞 诪谞砖讘转 讘讛谉, when the wind blew, 诪砖讬专讬谉 讗转 驻讬专讜转讬讛谉, it would knock down the fruit. and it was golden fruit. 砖谞讗诪专, it says, 讬专注砖 讻讘诇讘谞讜谉 驻专讬讜, that the 讬专注砖 the blast should knock it off. 讜诪讛谉 讛讬转讛 驻专谞住讛 诇讻讛讜谞讛. The Kohanim grabbed it, grabbed pieces of gold and they were able to sell it. He said money doesn't grow on trees. Huh? Yeah. Yeah. Oh, because my father always told me as a kid, he said, what do you think, they pick money off off trees? Yes, how do you blow your product? Exactly. That's what it's going to be like. 讜讻讬讜谉 砖谞讻谞住讜 注讜讘讚讬 讻讜讻讘讬诐 诇讛讬讻诇, when the goyim came to the 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖, 讬讘砖讜, it dried up. 砖谞讗诪专, it says, 讜驻专讞 诇讘谞讜谉 讗讜诪诇诇. And the growth, the the blossoming of 诇讘谞讜谉, it became 讗讜诪诇诇, means is is is tragic. 讜注转讬讚 讛拽讘\"讛 诇讛讞讝讬专讛 诇谞讜, in the future Hashem will give it back. 砖谞讗诪专, it says, 驻专讜讞 转驻专讞 讜转讙诇 讗祝 讙讬诇转 讜专谞谉 讻讘讜讚 讛诇讘谞讜谉 谞转谉 诇讛, and it'll grow again and the 讻讘讜讚 of the 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖 砖诇 诇讘谞讜谉 will come back. Zogt di Gemara vayter 转谞讜 专讘谞谉, 讚讬 专讘谞谉 haben gelernt 讗讬讚谉 should know. Know what to expect. And then, no, maybe they'll do teshuvah. You can change it. Sure, you can change it, yeah, cuz a bad nevuah, you change, you do teshuvah you can change. A good nevuah cannot be changed. The Eibershter gave over a good nevuah, as bad as you are it can't change. But the bad nevuah could change. That's what what Yirmiyahu Hanavi told Chananya ben Azur. Chananya ben Azur was a 谞讘讬讗 砖拽专. Yirmiyahu was saying nevuah that 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖 would be destroyed. It was already after they took away some things from the 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖, so he said that they'll take away everything, they'll destroy. And Chananya ben Azur was also known to be a 谞讘讬讗. He got up and he said nevuah that not only won't get destroyed, the 讻诇讬诐 that they took will be brought back. So Yirmiyahu said to him, \"You see, you could be proven wrong. I could never be proven wrong, cuz I said a bad nevuah. Even if it won't come true, they won't show that I'm wrong because the Eibershter could change His mind.\" And how? All can be teshuvah? No, how? Through teshuvah, whatever. \"But you said a good nevuah. If it doesn't come true, then you'll know that it's wrong.\" And that's what happened. They realized that he was a 谞讘讬讗 砖拽专. One second, when he was giving that nevuah, maybe that was, meaning it was authentic? No, how did it change? It was totally 砖拽专 when he was giving it? Yeah. We didn't know that, but they found out later. It was totally 砖拽专. Right, Yirmiyah told him, \"You're a you're a 谞讘讬讗 砖拽专.\" When it didn't come back? When it didn't come back after yeshiva? No, he said then. He said soon it's coming back. So, yeah, he said it's coming back soon. 讚讬 专讘谞谉 讛讗讘谉 讙注诇注专谞讟, 注砖专讛 驻注诪讬诐 诪讝讻讬专 讻讛谉 讙讚讜诇 讗转 讛砖诐 讘讜 讘讬讜诐. 10 times the Kohen Gadol mentions Hashem's name that day, Yom Kippur. 砖诇砖讛 讘讜讬讚讜讬 讛专讗砖讜谉, 砖诇砖讛 讘讜讬讚讜讬 讛砖谞讬, 砖诇砖讛 讘砖注讬专 讛诪砖转诇讞, three times the first confession, three times the second, three times by the 砖注讬专 讛诪砖转诇讞, 讜讗讞讚 讘讙讜专诇讜转, and one when he made the goral. 讜讻讘专 讗诪专, and when he would say, \"讗谞讗 讛砖诐\", 谞砖诪注 拽讜诇讜 讘讬专讬讞讜. If he'd say, \"讗谞讗 讛砖诐\", in Yericho they would hear his voice. Now how far Yericho is we'll see. 讗诪专 专讘讛 讘专 讘专 讞谞讛, 诪讬专讜砖诇讬诐 诇讬专讬讞讜 注砖专讛 驻专住讗讜转. 10 驻专住讗讜转. Wow. 爪讬专 讚诇转讜转 讛讬讻诇 谞砖诪注 讘砖诪讜谞讛 转讞讜诪讬 砖讘转. The
hinges, when they open the doors, made so much noise, you could hear it eight 转讞讜诪讬 砖讘转 away. And 转讞讜诐 砖讘转 is 2,000 诪讬诇. And this is eight times that much. 注讝讬诐 Yericho, the goats of 讬专讬讞讜, 诪转注讟砖讜转 诪专讬讞 讛拽讟讜专转, they would sneeze from the 专讬讞, the smell of the ketores of the Beit Hamikdash. 谞砖讬诐 砖讘讬专讬讞讜 讗讬谞谉 爪专讬讻讜转 诇讛转讘砖诐 诪专讬讞 讛拽讟讜专转, the women in Yericho, even in Yericho, did not have to put on makeup or not makeup, perfume, cuz the smell, good smell from the ketores. 讻诇讛 砖讘讬专讜砖诇讬诐 讗讬谞讛 爪专讬讻讛 诇讛转拽砖讟 诪专讬讞 讛拽讟讜专转, a 讻诇讛 in Yerushalayim didn't have to put on any perfume or anything because this was enough. 讗诪专 专讘讬 讬讜住讬 讘谉 讚讙诇讗讬, Rabbi Yosi ben Daglai said, 注讝讬诐 讛讬讜 诇讗讘讗 讘讛专讬 诪讻讜讜专, my father had goats in a place called 讛专讬 诪讻讜讜专, 讜讛讬讜 诪转注讟砖讜转 诪专讬讞 讛拽讟讜专转, and they used to sneeze from the smell of the ketores. 讗诪专 专讘讬 讞讬讬讗 讘专 讗讘讬谉, Chiya bar Avin said, 讗诪专 专讘讬 讬讛讜砖注 讘谉 拽专讞讛, Rabbi Yehoshua ben Korcha, 住讞 诇讬 讝拽谉 讗讞讚, so one man, old man told me, 驻注诐 讗讞转 讛诇讻转讬 诇砖讬诇讛, once I went to 砖讬诇讛, 讜讛专讞转讬 专讬讞 拽讟讜专转 诪讘讬谉 拽住诇讬讛. Shiloh, they used to be Mishkan Shiloh, they brought ketores there. So in his time, Rabbi Yehoshua ben Korcha's time, which was about, I would say, I don't know, a thousand years later, he still smelled the ketores in Shiloh. In the walls? I don't know if the walls. Ben Korcha was after both 讘转讬 诪拽讚砖? Yeah. Much later than that. Yes, that's 800 years or whatever, yeah. Wow. Now we'll go another shtikel. 讘讗 诇讜 讗爪诇 驻专 砖谞讬, and it's a whole story of how the avodah went. Finally he went to the second 驻专. And
there he had a second vidui. 驻专注讙讟 讚讬 讙诪专讗, 诪讗讬 砖谞讗 讘讜讬讚讜讬 讛专讗砖讜谉 讚诇讗 讗诪专 讜讘谞讬 讗讛专谉 注诐 拽讚讜砖讱, the first vidui he only said vidui on himself and confessed for my averot, he didn't say the averot also of the other kohanim? 诪讗讬 砖谞讗 讘讜讬讚讜讬 讛砖谞讬 讚讗诪专 讜讘谞讬 讗讛专谉 注诐 拽讚讜砖讱, and the second one he also included the others? 转谞讗 讚讘讬 专讘讬 讬砖诪注讗诇, so Rabbi Yishmael said, 讻讱 讛讜讗 诪讚转 讛讚讬谉 谞讬转谞转, this is the right way to do it. 诪讜讟讘 讬讘讗 讝讻讗讬 讜讬讻驻专 注诇 讛讞讬讬讘, it's better that somebody who's innocent should go and try to find a kaparah for someone that's guilty, 讜讗诇 讬讘讗 讞讬讬讘 讜讬讻驻专 注诇 讛讞讬讬讘, that's not let's not a guilty person come. So first, before he's trying to find a kaparah for them, he has to get himself clean. So first he got himself clean, and then he was able to ask for them. And the Yidden, then the Yidden after that? Huh? Then the rest of the Yidden. No way. Having the shiur afterwards? But that wasn't from a nes still, right? No, no. Oh, that was definitely a nes. Where are you