Pesach Sheni: Part 1
Why Pesach Sheni is counted as its own separate mitzvah, and why the difference between Pesach Rishon and Pesach Sheni is the difference between a tzaddik and a baal teshuvah
Part of Days on the Jewish Calendar: Iyar · 17:57
On why the Rambam counts Pesach Sheni as a mitzvah in its own right despite it only ever applying to someone who missed Pesach Rishon, and how the halachic differences between the two -- chametz allowed versus forbidden, one day versus seven -- map onto the difference between the straight path of a tzaddik and the leap of a baal teshuvah.
Audio Transcript
not able to bring the 拽专讘谉 驻住讞 on Erev Pesach, so then a month later on the 14th day of Iyar, he was able to bring and was obligated to bring the 拽专讘谉 驻住讞 then, and that's called Pesach Sheni. The Rambam in his Sefer HaMitzvot, 诪爪讜讛 谞状讝, counts the mitzvah of Pesach Sheni in his 诪谞讬谉 讛诪爪讜讜转 as a separate mitzvah. And he gives the reason, because the halachah is like Rabbi that says that Pesach Sheni is a 专讙诇 讘驻谞讬 注爪诪讜. As we find in the Gemara 驻住讞讬诐 讚祝 爪状讙 注诪讜讚 讗壮, a machloket, an argument, whether Pesach Sheni is considered a separate Yom Tov by itself, or is it just a 转砖诇讜诪讬谉 or a 转拽谞转讗 讚专讗砖讜谉? Just to fulfill what he missed out by not bringing the first 拽专讘谉 驻住讞, or is it a tikkun for the first 拽专讘谉 驻住讞, as the difference in those opinions are. And Rabbi holds that it is a 专讙诇 讘驻谞讬 注爪诪讜, it is a separate Yom Tov. So the Rambam says since the halachah is like Rabbi, that it is a 专讙诇 讘驻谞讬 注爪诪讜, a separate Yom Tov, therefore we count it as a separate mitzvah. But we still have to understand, because even according to Rabbi that holds that it's a 专讙诇 讘驻谞讬 注爪诪讜, but when are you obligated to bring the Pesach Sheni? Only if you did not bring Pesach Rishon. Somebody who brought Pesach Rishon is not allowed to bring a Pesach Sheni. So it comes out that even according to Rabbi, after all, it is only a mitzvah that comes instead, in place of Pesach Rishon. So it should be lichorah the same mitzvah, that you have to be makriv a 拽专讘谉 驻住讞. Now, this one mitzvah is divided into two parts: you have to bring the 拽专讘谉 驻住讞 on Erev Pesach; if you didn't manage to bring this korban on Erev Pesach, you have to bring it on 驻住讞 砖谞讬. So lichorah, even if you hold it's a 专讙诇 讘驻谞讬 注爪诪讜, it's a separate Yom Tov, nevertheless, lichorah it should not be a separate mitzvah. So the Rifla, he explains that the Rambam means to say that since the Torah told us that it's a 专讙诇 讘驻谞讬 注爪诪讜, it's a separate Yom Tov, this itself teaches us that it is a 诪爪讜讛 讘驻谞讬 注爪诪讛, it's also a separate mitzvah. Being that it's a separate Yom Tov, even though it comes only to somebody who did not bring the 驻住讞 专讗砖讜谉, but nevertheless we look at it as a separate Yom Tov, so, too, we look at it as a separate mitzvah.
Now, since we know that everything that we have in halachah also has a deeper meaning, has a lesson to everybody in his avodat Hashem, and there is the hashkafah part of every mitzvah and every halachah, so this inyan that 驻住讞 砖谞讬 is a 专讙诇 讘驻谞讬 注爪诪讜, is a separate Yom Tov, and therefore it is considered like a separate mitzvah, also has a meaning the way the inyan of 驻住讞 砖谞讬 is explained according to the 驻谞讬诪讬讜转 讛驻砖讟, according to the way it is 注诇 驻讬 讛砖拽驻讛 and the lesson that lies in the mitzvah of 驻住讞 砖谞讬. To understand that, let's first look into the difference between 驻住讞 专讗砖讜谉 and 驻住讞 砖谞讬. The halachah is that 讛专讗砖讜谉 讗住讜专 讘讘诇 讬专讗讛 讜讘诇 讬诪爪讗 讜讛砖谞讬 讞诪抓 讜诪爪讛 注诪讜 讘讘讬转. That's what the Gemara says in the Mishnah in Pesachim 讚祝 爪状讛 注诪讜讚 讗壮, that 驻住讞 专讗砖讜谉 is at a time when you're not allowed to have chametz. You're not even allowed to own chametz in your house, and if a person does, he's over on the aveirah of 讘诇 讬专讗讛 讜讘诇 讬诪爪讗. But 驻住讞 砖谞讬 comes at a time when you're allowed to have chametz in the house. You're just not allowed to eat the 拽专讘谉 驻住讞 with chametz, but at that time you're allowed to have chametz in the house. Another difference between 驻住讞 专讗砖讜谉 and 驻住讞 砖谞讬 is that 讛专讗砖讜谉 谞讜讛讙 讻诇 砖讘注讛 讜讛砖谞讬 讬讜诐 讗讞讚, as it says in the Tosefta Pesachim, 驻专拽 讞壮, at the end of 讛诇讻讛 讙壮. Which means that 驻住讞 专讗砖讜谉 is for seven days, which really means that the issur of chametz that comes along with 驻住讞 专讗砖讜谉 is for seven days, and the 拽专讘谉 驻住讞 itself is connected to these seven days. Even though we know that the 拽专讘谉 驻住讞 is only eaten the first night of Pesach, but nevertheless, the Gemara says in 驻住讞讬诐 讚祝 爪状讜 注诪讜讚 讘壮 that 讗讜讻诇讬谉 注诇讬讜 诪爪讛 砖砖转 讬诪讬诐, that we eat on it, together with it, matzah for six days. So it comes out that we connect the 驻住讞 专讗砖讜谉 with the six or seven days of Pesach, but 驻住讞 砖谞讬 is only one day. What is the reason for this difference? So the reason is because the difference between 驻住讞 专讗砖讜谉 and 驻住讞 砖谞讬 is: 驻住讞 专讗砖讜谉 is the way the chiyuv is originally. A person who does everything properly according to the seder, he does everything in its time, brings the 拽专讘谉 驻住讞 on Erev Pesach. 驻住讞 砖谞讬 is 砖诇讗 注诇 讛住讚专, that a person who did not bring the korban in its time, he missed out on the original chiyuv, on the original obligation. So to him we say that even though normally the klal is 注讘专 讬讜诪讜 讘讟诇 拽专讘谞讜, the Gemara says in 讘专讻讜转 讚祝 讻状讜 注诪讜讚 讗壮, that when the day passes the korban is batal. If you missed out the day you had to bring the korban, you can't bring it again. By 驻住讞 砖谞讬 we say, nevertheless, you could bring the 拽专讘谉 驻住讞 later, which really means that the inyan of 驻住讞 砖谞讬 represents the concept of teshuvah. Or as the famous expression that 驻住讞 砖谞讬 shows, 注住 讗讬讝 谞讬砖讟讗 拽讬讬谉 驻讗专驻讗诇谉, that it's never too late. Which means that no matter how a person was, nevertheless he's able to change and it's never too late for him to do teshuvah. So it comes out that in general the difference between 驻住讞 专讗砖讜谉 and 驻住讞 砖谞讬 is the difference between a tzaddik and a baal teshuvah. A tzaddik is a person who serves Hashem in the 讚专讱 讛讬砖专, in the right normal way, as the pasuk says in Koheles, 拽讗驻讬讟诇 讝' 驻住讜拽 讻\"讟, 讗砖专 注砖讛 讛讗诇拽讬诐 讗转 讛讗讚诐 讬砖专, 讛砖诐 made the person straight. And a person who follows that path, he is a tzaddik. So he follows everything according to the yosher, to the straight way, the straight order of Torah. But a baal teshuvah is a person who went against the order of Torah. So Hashem gives him the possibility of fixing up, mending his ways, and being memale the chesaron, fulfilling the thing that he missed out. And that is the difference between 驻住讞 专讗砖讜谉 and 驻住讞 砖谞讬. 驻住讞 专讗砖讜谉 represents the avodah of a tzaddik, that is the normal way, the regular way 注诇 驻讬 住讚专 of bringing the korban. And the inyan of korban shows that he gets close to Hashem, because korban comes from the lashon of kiruv, closeness, as it says in the Rabbeinu Bachya. So the inyan of bringing a korban in its proper time is a person who gets close to Hashem in a proper way, that is a tzaddik. And 驻住讞 砖谞讬 that comes to a person who missed out, that is the inyan of a baal teshuvah. And we take see that originally, when Hashem gave the mitzvah of 驻住讞 专讗砖讜谉 and later the mitzvah of 驻住讞 砖谞讬, it fits to these two inyanim. When Hashem gave the mitzvah of 驻住讞 专讗砖讜谉, it was when the Yidden were about to leave Mitzrayim. It was a time when the Jewish nation just was born, as we find in Yechezkel in 拽讗驻讬讟诇 讟\"讝, as he refers to Yetziat Mitzrayim as the birth of Klal Yisrael. When a child is born, he has no aveirot. He is in the level of a tzaddik. He has no past. On the other hand, they not only did not have any aveirot because the aveirot did not count, they were like children that were born, which is the inyan of sur meira, they didn't have any evil, but they in, in addition to that, had aseh tov. They had two mitzvot. They were mekayem the mitzvah of milah and the mitzvah of Pesach. So they were at that time similar to the matzav of being a tzaddik. And even al pi halachah, that time was the beginning of their gerut, of their conversion, of their becoming Jews, as the Gemara says in 讬讘诪讜转 讚祝 诪\"讜 and in 讻专讬转讜转 讚祝 讟'. And the halachah is that a 讙专 砖谞转讙讬讬专 讻拽讟谉 砖谞讜诇讚 讚诪讬. A convert who converts is like a child that's born, as the Gemara says in 讬讘诪讜转 讚祝 讻\"讘 注诪讜讚 讗'. When a child is born, he has no aveirot. And we even say to a ger, taken from Rut, 拽讗驻讬讟诇 讘' 驻住讜拽 讬\"讘, 讬砖诇诐 讛砖诐 驻注诇讱 讜转讛讬 诪砖讻讜专转讱 砖诇诪讛 讗砖专 讘讗转 诇讞住讜转 转讞转 讻谞驻讬讜, that you came to go under the wings of Hashem. And this we say to every ger, that means that every ger starts at that time being close to Hashem. So the Yidden at the time when they were commanded in the mitzvah of 驻住讞 专讗砖讜谉 were in the level of tzaddikim. On the other hand, 驻住讞 砖谞讬 came to those people who were 讟诪讗讬诐 诇谞驻砖 讗讚诐, who were tamei. Now tamei represents a level that a person is not a tzadik. And in tumah itself it was tumat met. And tumat met is the strictest of them all, as it says in the Mishnah in Keilim 驻专拽 讗' 诪砖谞讛 讚', which comes as a result of the inyan of 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转. We know that mitah, death, comes because of the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转, as the Gemara says in 砖讘转 讚祝 谞\"讛 注诪讜讚 讘', which is the source of all aveirot, as it says in many sefarim. So it comes out that the inyan of tumah, especially tumat met, represents the inyan of aveirah. So these people who were tamei, they were given the mitzvah of Pesach Sheni, that represents the inyan of teshuvah. So Hashem said to them you could do teshuvah, and that's the inyan of Pesach Sheni. And we takeh see the way they acted at that time, they acted as if they were doing teshuvah. Because they said, 讗谞讞谞讜 讟诪讗讬诐 诇谞驻砖 讗讚诐. They came to Moshe Rabbeinu and they said, we are tamei by touching a dead body. 诇诪讛 谞讙专注 诇讘诇转讬 讛拽专讬讘 讗转 拽专讘谉 讛砖诐 讘诪讜注讚讜 讘转讜讱 讘谞讬 讬砖专讗诇? Why should we lose out, not being able to makriv the korban of Hashem in its proper time? So this is mamash similar to teshuvah. This is like vidui. By teshuvah, you know, you have to regret the past, and you have to make up your mind to change the future, and you have to confess. So here they confessed. They said, 讗谞讞谞讜 讟诪讗讬诐 诇谞驻砖 讗讚诐. And they ask that they want to fix what was missing out, and they ask that they should bring the korban just like those people who brought the korban bemoado. So this is the inyan of teshuvah. So here we see the parallel between Pesach Rishon and Pesach Sheni to the inyan of a tzadik and a baal teshuvah.
This is also a reason why the mitzvah of Pesach Sheni came only as an answer to a question of people. L'chorah, why wasn't this mitzvah given together with all the mitzvot, directly from Hashem without waiting for people to ask? But the answer is is because this is the inyan of teshuvah, and teshuvah usually comes as a result from the person himself. It is very seldom that a person does teshuvah because of some awakening from above from Hashem. Usually, teshuvah is the person himself realizes that the way he is is not the right way, and he wants to do teshuvah. So therefore, the mitzvah of Pesach Sheni also came as a result of what people themselves said. Concerning a tzadik and a baal teshuvah, we know that even though, on one hand, a tzadik is greater, because as we said before, he does everything yosher, everything straight, nevertheless, we know that 讘诪拽讜诐 砖讘注诇讬 转砖讜讘讛 注讜诪讚讬诐, 爪讚讬拽讬诐 讙诪讜专讬诐 讗讬谞诐 注讜诪讚讬诐, or according to the lashon of the 专诪讘状诐, 爪讚讬拽讬诐 讙诪讜专讬诐 讗讬谞诐 讬讻讜诇讬诐 诇注诪讜讚 砖诐. At the level of a baal teshuvah, a tzadik cannot reach. And then one of the reasons for that is, because by a tzadik, since a tzadik does everything straight, there is no way a tzadik can elevate those things which are forbidden. A tzadik is able to bring kedushah into the world only to a certain degree, only as far as you're allowed, but to elevate things which are forbidden, a tzadik is not able to. A baal teshuvah is able to elevate even that, because since 讝讚讜谞讜转 谞注砖讜 诇讜 讻讝讻讬讜转, if he does a proper teshuvah and his aveirot turn into mitzvot, as the Gemara says in 讬讜诪讗 讚祝 驻状讜 注诪讜讚 讘壮, so he is able to elevate even things which are forbidden. For instance, if a person ate 讞讝讬专, so then that 讞讝讬专 is evil, but when he does teshuvah and that eating of the 讞讝讬专 becomes a mitzvah, so he even elevates the chazir which is forbidden. A tzaddik can't do that. There is a concept of a 诪爪讜讛 讛讘讗讛 讘注讘讬专讛, you're not allowed to do a mitzvah if it comes through an aveirah, so there is no way of elevating things which are forbidden. A baal teshuvah could even bring kedushah into things which are forbidden. And that is the reason why normally teshuvah wouldn't help. As the Chazal say in Yalkut, Yalkut Shimoni on Tehillim 专诪讝 转砖住状讘, and it's also hinted in Yerushalmi Makkot 驻专拽 讘壮 讛诇讻讛 讜壮, that 砖讗诇讜 诇讞讻诪讛, they asked chochmah, and they asked nevuah, and they asked 转讜专讛, 讞讜讟讗 诪讛 注谞砖讜, what should happen to a person who sins? And none of the three answered let him do teshuvah. When 砖讗诇讜 诇讛拽讚讜砖 讘专讜讱 讛讜讗, when they asked Hashem, His answer was 讬注砖讛 转砖讜讘讛 讜讬转讻驻专 诇讜, let him do teshuvah and get a kaparah. Why didn't chochmah or nevuah or Torah answer that? Because to answer something like that, that you should be able to elevate the evil, that's something that's impossible. Only Hashem Himself is able to do that. And this is, by the way, the reason why they came with the complaint, 诇诪讛 谞讙专注, why we should lose out. As if they expected to lose out, and they came with the complaint, why should we lose out? The question is why did they imagine that they would lose out? Why did they have to give this introduction, 诇诪讛 谞讙专注, as if expecting to be 谞讙专注, to lose out? They should have come lechatchilah saying, we are tamei, and we would ask when we could bring the 拽专讘谉 驻住讞, since we can't bring it in the proper time. They started with 诇诪讛 谞讙专注, in other words, they were sure that normally you couldn't do it, and they came with the complaint, why not? Why did they think they can't? Because 注诇 驻讬 砖讻诇, normally teshuvah wouldn't help, because if you did an aveirah, that evil, you can't elevate that. That's why they thought that 谞讙专注, but they nevertheless complained, 诇诪讛 谞讙专注, and Hashem said, no, you have a chance to bring the Pesach Sheni, which means you have a chance to do teshuvah.
Now that we understand that the difference between Pesach Rishon and Pesach Sheni is the difference between the avodah of a tzaddik and the avodah of a baal teshuvah, we'll understand why by Pesach Rishon you're not allowed to have chametz in the house, while at the time of Pesach Sheni you are allowed. Why Pesach Rishon is seven days and Pesach Sheni is one day. Because chametz represents evil. Chametz always is used as a term for the yetzer hara. Chametz represents gaavah, etc. That's why it rises, just like a baal gaavah. So since chametz represents evil, a tzadik has no connection to evil. That's why at the time when you bring the Pesach Rishon, which represents the avodah of a tzadik, you can't have any chametz, because this shows the level of a person that he is not shayach to chametz. He doesn't even own any chametz in his house. But Pesach Sheni comes to a person who, on one hand, has chametz, which means he is a baal aveirah, nevertheless we say that you are able to do teshuvah on those aveirot. And to show that inyan, the mitzvah is that you're allowed to have chametz in the house, because this shows that even to a person who has chametz, nevertheless, he has the chance of doing teshuvah. While on Pesach Rishon you're not allowed to have chametz, because this is supposed to show that we're talking about a person who doesn't have any connection to chametz. And for that reason also, Pesach Rishon is seven days and Pesach Sheni is one day. Seven represents the seven middot a person has. It represents the 砖讘注转 讬诪讬 讛讛拽祝, as it says in the Teshuvot HaRashba, that there are seven days, this is a complete cycle. A tzadik is a person who goes from level to level, and he goes through all the different stages. So therefore, Pesach Rishon, which represents the avodah of a tzadik, has a connection to the different levels a person goes through. And that's why it's connected to the number seven, which represents all the seven levels. But Pesach Sheni, the inyan of teshuvah, now teshuvah, a baal teshuvah doesn't go through the different levels. A baal teshuvah changes himself from being a rasha to becoming a righteous person in one moment, in one change, in one jump, so to speak. And that's why it is one day, not because it is in a lower level than 驻住讞 专讗砖讜谉, on the contrary, being it's in such a high level, that's why it's only one day. Similar to the reason given in the Sefarim why Yom Kippur is only one day, because Yom Kippur is 讗讞转 讘砖谞讛, represents the depth of the neshamah of a Yid, this point that's there, which is beyond all levels, and that is represented in one. The number one expresses something that is beyond division, beyond parts, it is a very essential thing. And that's why originally miDeOraita, Shavuos is also one day. The day of Kabbalas HaTorah is such a day which has no parts to it, not like Pesach and 砖讘讜 and Sukkos that have seven days or eight days, or nine miDerabbanan. Because Shavuos is the day of Kabbalas HaTorah, this is the highest level, that's why it's only one. And the same is with Pesach Sheni. It's only one day, because this represents the inyan of teshuvah. And teshuvah is not something that a person goes through different levels till finally reaches a level, it is the changeover from one extreme to the other, and that is represented in the inyan that it's one day. And as we find in the Gemara in Avodah Zarah 讚祝 讬状讝 注诪讜讚 讗壮, it tells the story there of Rabbi Elazar ben Dordia who did teshuvah, and it says there, 讘讻讛 专讘讬 讜讗诪专, 讬砖 拽讜谞讛 注讜诇诪讜 讘讻诪讛 砖谞讬诐, 讜讬砖 拽讜谞讛 注讜诇诪讜 讘砖注讛 讗讞转. Rabbi cried and said, that for some people, in order to get their world, their Olam Haba, it takes them many years, and a baal teshuvah could be koneh his world 讘砖注讛 讗讞转, in one moment. Or as it says in Sefarim the peshat, the word shaah doesn't only mean a moment, shaah means a turn. Similar to the lashon of the pasuk where it says, 讜讗诇 讛讘诇 讜讗诇 诪谞讞转讜 诇讗 砖注讛, that with one turn, in one second, in one turn, you could be koneh olamo. Which is similar to what it says in the Zohar, in Zohar 讗壮 讚祝 拽讻状讟 注诪讜讚 讗壮, that teshuvah is 讘砖注转讗 讞讚讗 讜讘专讙注讗 讞讚讗. That teshuvah is in one moment, teshuvah is in one rega. And being that Pesach Sheni is the inyan of teshuvah, therefore it is one day, the inyan of one. Now we see that Pesach Rishon and Pesach Sheni are two separate avodot. Pesach Rishon represents the avodah of a tzadik, and Pesach Sheni represents the avodah of a baal teshuvah. And this is the reason why 驻住讞 砖谞讬 注诇 驻讬 讛诇讻讛 is considered a 专讙诇 讘驻谞讬 注爪诪讜, a separate Yom Tov for itself. And the Rambam counts Pesach Sheni as a 诪爪讜讛 讘驻谞讬 注爪诪讛, a separate mitzvah, and as we said before, that the reason he counts it as a separate mitzvah is because it's a separate Yom Tov. So in the hashkafah part of the mitzvah, we also see how they're two separate inyanim. The inyan of Pesach Rishon represents the inyan of tzadik, and the inyan of Pesach Sheni represents the idea that it's never too late, and you could always do teshuvah.