Zichronos book cover Zichronos is in print! Order your copy on Amazon
IMPORTANT ISSUES

Why Didn't Adam and Eve Need Rabbinic Safeguards?

Why Didn't Adam and Eve Need Rabbinic Safeguards?

Part of Important Issues

Explores the origin of the seven rabbinic mitzvos, why the generations closest to the Beis Hamikdash needed fewer protective fences, and the deeper purpose of elevating everyday physical acts like eating.

Audio Transcript
Beis Hamikdash Era and Torah Sufficiency

讘讝诪谉 砖讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖 讛讬讛 拽讬讬诐, the time of the Beis Hamikdash, when we had the 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖, 讚讬 讛讬讛 诇讘谞讬 讬砖专讗诇 讘讚讬谞讬 讛转讜专讛. It was enough for the Jews to follow the laws of the Torah. And they didn't have to have any extra laws that should be like fences that should stop them from transgressing the Torah. Whatever the Torah said, that was enough. 砖讻谉 诇讗 谞诪砖讻讜 讻诇 讻讱 诇转讗讜讜转 讙砖诪讬讜转, because they were not pulled so much to physical desires. 讜拽诇 讛讬讛 诇讛诐, it was easy for them, 砖转讛讗 讗讛讘转 讛砖诐 拽讘讜注讛 讘诇讘诐, that the love of Hashem should be set into their heart. 讚讘专 砖讛讘讬讗 诇讬讚讬 讛转诇讛讘讜转 讜讞讜诐 讘注讘讜讚转 讛砖诐. Since Hashem's love was in their heart, that brought them automatically to an excitement and warmth in serving of service of Hashem. And therefore, when they did exactly what the Torah said, that was enough for them. 讗讱 讚讜专 讗讞专 讚讜专, but as generations go, 谞转诪注讟讜 讛诇讘讘讜转. The hearts become less, smaller, it means that the feeling of the heart is not as strong. 讜讘谞讬 讬砖专讗诇 谞讻讜讜 讘讗砖 讝专讛 砖诇 转注谞讜讙讬 注讜诇诐 讛讝讛, and the Jews have been burnt with the, we call it a false, strange flame of this world, of the pleasures of this world. 讜讗讬谉 讘讻讜讞诐 诇注讘讜讚 讗转 讛砖诐 诪转讜讱 讗讛讘讛, and they cannot serve Hashem now out of love as they used to, 讗诇讗 注诇 讬讚讬 讚拽讚讜拽讬 住讜驻专讬诐 讜讞讜诪专讜转讬讛诐 注诇 讻诇 驻专讟讬讛诐. The only way they could do now is when we have the extra laws that were added by the Chachamim, and all these new strict laws that were given by the Chachamim with all the details. 讘讘讞讬谞转 住讜专 诪专注, certain things they added so we shall stay away from evil, 讻诇 讛讞讜诪专讜转 砖讘讙诪专讗 讜驻讜住拽讬诐, which includes all the extra laws that were added by the Chachamim that are mentioned in the Gemara and mentioned later on in the 驻讜住拽讬诐, 讜注砖讛 讟讜讘, and we also have a lot of extra things in the positive side, like 讚讘专讬 诪讜住专 砖讘讗讙讚讜转 讞讝状诇, we have the 诪讜住专 words, the 讛砖拽驻讛 words in the 讞讝状诇, in the 讙诪专讗, 讜驻专拽讬 讗讘讜转, and 驻专拽讬 讗讘讜转, etc., etc. So he's basically trying to say here that the time of the Beis Hamikdash, and basically this is in the time of the first Beis Hamikdash, we did not need all these extra laws that the Chachamim added. Later on, in the time at the beginning of the second Beis Hamikdash and certainly later, the Chachamim added more and more. Why? Because we now, and from then on, are not as strong as they used to be in ruchaniyut, spiritually, and in order for us to be the way we're supposed to, we have to have extra laws. And I think I will elaborate a little bit on this. We know that in the Torah we have 613 mitzvot. There are certain mitzvot which are 注砖讛 讟讜讘, positive mitzvot, and certain mitzvot are negative mitzvot, things we're not allowed to do. And that's it. Came the Chachamim, the rabbis later, and they added a lot of laws. In every halacha that we have, we have extra dinim that we do now because the chachamim added. Shabbos, in in Pesach, everything, so many things, hundreds upon hundreds upon hundreds of laws that we keep now are all what we call mid'rabbanan. They're all only mid'rabbanan, or sometimes they're called 诪讚讘专讬 住讜驻专讬诐. The chachamim are called 住讜驻专讬诐, and 讚讘专讬 住讜驻专讬诐, and they're added to the Torah. Now, before we even get to what it says here, I just want to explain: first of all, what right did the chachamim have to do it? Who gave the chachamim the authority to come to Klal Yisrael and say, \"Well, we want you to do extra dinim. We want you to be more careful. From the Torah you're you're not allowed to eat meat and milk, but with chicken you're allowed.\" Came the rabbanan and said, \"No, you can't eat meat with chicken.\" In the Torah it's only if it's cooked together, but if it would be cold together, just put together, you would be allowed. Came the chachamim and said not. Every law that we have, the chachamim added and added. What right did they have? Well, truth is they do have a right, because the pasuk says 诪砖诪专转... 讜砖诪专转诐 讗转 诪砖诪专转讬, \"You shall watch my watching\", and that means that you have to make fences to make sure that you will be watched, you will be careful that you will not transgress. Most of the time, most of what the chachamim said was because they were afraid that if they will leave it the way the Torah said, people will eventually transgress what the Torah said. So they felt that they have to add laws that will be like a fence around that you wouldn't come to it. There are a few things that the chachamim did not do as a fence, but they did because they established a new law. And

Origin of the Seven Rabbinic Mitzvot

basically that's where we get the number seven. We know that there are seven 诪爪讜讜转 讚专讘谞谉. We know there are 613 mitzvot of the Torah, there are seven 诪爪讜讜转 诪讚专讘谞谉. In truth, things that we do mid'rabbanan, like I said, you have 500, I don't know, 800, 1,000, I mean, they're very, very many. Where did the cheshbon seven come? Why do we have seven? Because most of the things that the rabbanan said are all like fences to the Torah. Shabbos, you can't move muktzeh, because chachamim were afraid if you move muktzeh you might come to do a melacha, you might come to do work. So it's all because of something. There are seven things which the chachamim established on their own as seven separate mitzvot. In order to remember it, there's a very easy siman to remember. There are two words that is an abbreviation of the seven, and the two words together don't make much sense, but it's just a way to remember. I think I mentioned it once before, the two words are: 谞注 讘砖诪讞讛. 谞注, 谞讜谉 注讬谉 means to move, 诇讛谞讬注, 谞注, 讘砖诪讞讛, you shall move with joy. It's just a word to That's how I remember it. Now,

Mnemonic 谞注 讘砖诪讞讛 Explained

谞注 讘砖诪讞讛, if you look at the letters, that is the way to remember: 谞讜谉, 注讬谉, 讘讬转, 砖讬谉, 诪诐, 讞讬转, 讛. Seven letters. And that's what it is: 谞讜谉 is 谞讟讬诇转 讬讚讬诐. Before we eat bread, we wash our hands. The 注讬谉 is 注讬专讜讘讬谉, to make an eruv, whether it's an eruv to carry on Shabbos, whether it's an 注讬专讜讘 转讘砖讬诇讬谉, certain 讬诪讬诐 讟讜讘讬诐, when it comes out on Friday, you have to make an 注讬专讜讘 转讘砖讬诇讬谉 to be able to cook, or an 注讬专讜讘 转讞讜诪讬谉, when you want to walk out out of the city and you can't walk more than 2,000 讗诪讜转, you have to make an eruv, but that's 注讬专讜讘讬谉. So it's again: 谞讟讬诇转 讬讚讬诐 and 注讬专讜讘讬谉. And by the way, you know who of the 讞讻诪讬诐 established these two? Shlomo Hamelech. This goes back so far, but that was the few that started very early. Then 讘砖诪讞讛: 讘讬转 is 讘专讻讜转. The fact that we make a berachah before we eat, and that we make a berachah after we eat, that's 诪讚专讘谞谉. 讚讗讜专讬讬转讗, you do have to bentch. After you eat bread, you have to bentch, but to make a berachah before you eat, or other things not bentching, or also even by bread if you're not full, in the Torah, you wouldn't have to do it. The 驻住讜拽 says: 讜讗讻诇转 讜砖讘注转 讜讘专讻转 讗转 讛' 讗诇拽讬讱. You will eat, and be full, satisfied, then you bentch. 讜讘专讻转, you will bless 讛'. But if you're not 讜砖讘注转, in the Torah you wouldn't have to, the 专讘谞谉 said you do. So we have the 讘讬转 is 讘专讻讜转, the 砖讬谉 is Shabbos, now it doesn't mean Shabbos, it means the Shabbos candles for the woman, 诪诐 is Megillah, that's Purim, 讞讬转 is Chanukah, and the 讛 is Hallel. At certain times we say Hallel. Now these are mitzvot that the chachamim established. And they had a right because it was given to the The right was given to them in the Torah. As a matter of fact, we look at it, we see that we make a bracha even when we do a 诪爪讜讛 诪讚专讘谞谉. For instance, when we light the Chanukah candles, before we light the Chanukah candles, we make a bracha. What is the bracha? 讘专讜讱 讗转讛 讛' 讗诇拽讬谞讜 诪诇讱 讛注讜诇诐. Let's translate: Blessed are you, 讛', our God, King of the universe, 讗砖专 拽讚砖谞讜 讘诪爪讜转讬讜, who made us holy with His mitzvot, 讛' made us holy with His mitzvot, 讜爪讜谞讜, and He commanded us, 诇讛讚诇讬拽 谞专 讞谞讜讻讛, to light the candles of Chanukah. Where did 讛' command us to light the candles of Chanukah? Let's open a chumash. We won't find anywhere in chumash that we have to light the Chanukah candles. Or Purim, when we read the megillah, we make a bracha, and we say the same words. We say: 讘专讜讱 讗转讛 讛', we thank 讛' for commanding us to read the megillah. The answer is that 讛' gave the chachamim the authority to establish it. So when we do a 诪爪讜讛 诪讚专讘谞谉, we're not doing it because Rabbi so-and-so from the Gemara said it. We do it because 讛' wants us to do it, but it's an indirect thing. Tefillin, 讛' directly told us to do. Here, 讛' said to the chachamim: You have a right to do what you feel is right to establish mitzvot. And they established, so we do it because they established it based on the commandment of the chachamim. So it's the chachamim that we listen to. So that's why the chachamim have the right. Now

Authority of the Chachamim

most, like I said, most of the mitzvot that the chachamim gave us are not added mitzvot. And by the way, even what the 讞讻诪讬诐 did add, it wasn't chas v'shalom that they add. You're not allowed to add. Pasuk says: 诇讗 转讙专注 讜诇讗 转讜住祝. You're not allowed to take off of the mitzvot and you're not allowed to add. But it's not like You're not allowed to add a mitzvah, no one could come and say that there is a new mitzvah, there's not 613 mitzvot, there's 614. To come and say that there's a new mitzvah from the Torah, you're not allowed. But the 讞讻诪讬诐 didn't come and say that that's from the Torah. They said that we are adding it based on the right given to us, that's okay. But anyway, like I said, most of the mitzvot were given were of the 讞讻诪讬诐 were actually, we call it, seigim. Seig means a fence, to make a fence that we should not come to transgress. In truth, it would be better if we wouldn't have it. And like we learned here, the reason we have it is because we are in such a level that we need it. And when when you're in a level that you need it, you have to have it. But if you wouldn't need it, we'd be in a higher level, like it was originally, the Jews were originally in the time of the first 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖, we wouldn't need all these seigim. And I would like to a little explain a little bit concerning the inyan of seigim of adding. Here's a Is it good to add restrictions, or is it better not to? So let's start the beginning of the creation. We know that the

Eve鈥檚 Added Restriction and the Fall

cause for the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转, the cause for Chava sinning with 注抓 讛讚注转 was because she added a restriction that she wasn't supposed to. She added. What happened? Hashem said, \"Don't eat from the 注抓 讛讚注转.\" The nachash, the snake saw her and said to her, \"What about the tree? Did Hashem say anything?\" She said, \"Yes, Hashem said not to touch it.\" So the snake said, \"Oh, and what'll happen if you touch it?\" \"Well, Hashem said if we don't listen to Him, we're going to die.\" So what he did was, he pushed her against the tree. And she touched it. And he said, \"Ha, you see? You said Hashem says if you don't listen, you'll die. You just touched it, you told me he said don't touch it, you just touched it, and you didn't die. So in that case, you don't have to worry about it.\" So he convinced her to eat from it, too. So the reason she ate from the 注抓 讛讚注转 against the will of God was not because she didn't have a fence that would protect her from doing the sin, just opposite, because she made a fence. Had she not said, \"Hashem said don't touch it,\" which was an added restriction, nothing would have happened, she wouldn't have eaten. Could be. Yeah, I'm not blaming her. It doesn't say in It doesn't say in Chumash who said it. Could be 讗讚诐 讛专讗砖讜谉 told it to her. But the idea we see from here that it's because of the extra restriction that people took upon themselves, that they actually transgressed. So on one hand, it seems that it would have been better she wouldn't have done it. And from here we see that it's better not to have restrictions. Let's go a step further. There is a concept of nedarim. A neder, when a person takes a vow. Now the vows that we learn about in the Gemara and in Rambam, it's usually when a person wants to be sure that he will not do something wrong, so you make a vow that, \"I will not do this, I will not eat this,\" to make sure that you are holy, or you stay away from these physical things. Just like the general concept of a nazir. What's a nazir? A nazir is a person that takes a vow not to drink wine. And it says, why would a person do it? Because when you drink wine, you get drunk, you never know what could happen. So in order to be sure that you won't do anything wrong, this nazir would take upon himself a neder, it's a neder, it's called a vow, not to drink wine at all. You shouldn't drink wine and do anything which you shouldn't. That's That's forbidden. But just to drink wine is not forbidden. This is a person who takes an extra seig. He wants to make sure that he shouldn't transgress, he shouldn't stumble over the real thing, so he makes a neder not to drink wine. Now on

Nazir Vows: Benefit or Burden?

one hand, it seems to be good. Says that a person who sees some things happen which are no good, take a nezirut upon yourself. Nevertheless, we find that after the person has finished with the time of his nezirut, he has to bring a korban. So it says, if a person takes upon himself to be a nazir for 30 days, whatever the amount of time, so during those time he can't drink wine, he can't cut his hair, restrictions. When he's finished, he has to bring a korban, and a whole procedure what he does. One of the korbanot he brings a chatat. Now we know a korban chatat, the sacrifice of a chatat came, you would have to bring if you sinned. Why would he have to bring a korban chatat? You know what it says? This person sinned. What's his sin? He didn't drink wine. He vowed not to drink wine. What do you mean, he vowed not to Hashem said you're allowed to drink wine. Why in the world does this guy make not to drink wine? It's a chet. It's a sin. He has to bring a korban for a kaparah, to be forgiven. Generally concerning nedarim, it says in 驻专拽讬 讗讘讜转, 住讬讬讙, 谞讚专讬诐 住讬讬讙 诇驻专讬砖讜转. Nedarim, if you make a neder not to do certain things, you restrict yourself, so then it's a seyag, it's a it's a fence 诇驻专讬砖讜转, to be separated from evil. Then you're sure that you won't do anything wrong. A person is afraid he's going to eat non-kosher meat, so a person would make a neder, \"I'm not going to eat any meat at all.\" And he knows that since he made a neder, and he vowed, he won't eat any meat, so he certainly won't eat treifah meat. So it says in Pirkei Avot that's a good idea. Says in other places, in Yerushalmi it says, this is the expression: 诇讗 讚讬讬讱 诪讛 砖讗住专讛 转讜专讛? What, it's not enough what the Torah forbid you? 砖讗转讛 讗讜住专 讚讘专讬诐 讗讞专讬诐, 讚讘专讬诐 讛诪讜转专讬诐? And you're going to add more? Who Why in the world would do it? The Torah said you're allowed, so why you you're smarter than the Torah, and you're going to make it asur? So the Yerushalmi, which is part of the Gemara, says it's not a good idea to make a neder. So is it good, or isn't it good? Is it good to be a nazir, or is it not good to be a nazir? We see two things: we see it is, and we see it isn't. It says in Yerushalmi, it says like this, and don't take this out of context, what I'm going to say now, it says when a person will come in heaven, after 120, he will be judged for every physical food or thing he could have had benefit from, could have had pleasure from, why didn't you? Imagine, you could have eaten this geshmacke tasty steak, you didn't? You'll be judged for it. Now, why why would that be? So, is it or isn't it? Which one is the right thing to do? The answer is, it depends on what level you are. Essentially, in truth, originally, the way it should be, whatever is wrong, the Torah forbid us already, we know that's wrong. Whatever the Torah permitted, is permitted, because the Torah felt it's okay. And if the Torah permitted and put it here, and said you're allowed to use it, you're allowed to eat it, obviously, it's for a purpose. The Torah wants us to eat it, and wants us to use it. As a matter of fact, when we eat food鈥擨'm using food as the best example of of indulging in something鈥攁nd you eat food, and if a person is at a level the way he should be, he elevates the food. Where we learned last week about the concept of 谞讬爪讜爪讜转 讛拽讚讜砖讛, there are holy sparks found in the whole world, and every little aspect of the world has these holy sparks, and what we're waiting for, what Hashem wants is that we should elevate these sparks, and the only way we could elevate it is by getting involved with it. If you

Elevating Everyday Sparks Through Intent

eat food, and you eat lishmah shamayim, with a you eat with the proper intentions, you eat so that you should be healthy, so you should be able to learn, be able to do mitzvot, serve Hashem. You work, you get involved in physical things, so you should make money, to be able to give tzedakah, to be able to give your children a good Jewish education, to buy a very nice pair of tefillin, to buy the most 诪讛讜讚专讚讬拽注 讗转专讜讙, if you have that in mind. When you eat, in addition to having all this in mind, you make a bracha, you bench, you do everything properly, what happens? The 谞讬爪讜爪讜转 讛拽讚讜砖讛, the holy sparks that are found there, are elevated. So, you're really doing a favor to the food. Hashem wants you to do it, Hashem wants you to eat the food, because He wants you to elevate. If it's put here, you elevate, and if you don't eat it, what happens is, that holy spark that's found there is pushed away, and it's not good, it's not what Hashem wants. That's why it says in the Gemara an interesting thing, says in the Gemara that 爪讚讬拽讬诐, 诪诪讜谞诐 讞讘讬讘 注诇讬讛诐 讬讜转专 诪讙讜驻诐, 爪讚讬拽讬诐, their money is more precious to them than their body. Tzadikim care about money? Because their property has 谞讬爪讜爪讜转 讛拽讚讜砖讛, by them using it, they elevate it. For instance, it says that Yaakov Avinu, when he had that big fight with the 诪诇讗讱, he was left all alone. Why was he left all alone? It's very obvious, he took over his family to one side of the river, and he took over all his things, and he went back, when everything was over, he happened to forget a few small jars, 驻讻讬诐 拽讟谞讬诐, and he went back for it. Yaakov, why did he go back for a small, Jacob was very rich, I mean, we learned in Chumash he was very rich, why did he care about a little jar to come back all alone in a place when it's dark at night and it's a danger, I mean, what? Because everything that belongs to a Yid, 讘讻诇诇 everything has 谞讬爪讜爪讜转 讛拽讚讜砖讛, just to waste it means wasting the 谞讬爪讜爪讜转. Why is there a issur, a prohibition called bal tashchit? You're not allowed to waste. Not holy things. You're not allowed to waste bread, you're not allowed to waste food, anything that's useful you're not allowed to break. It's an aveirah, it's a lav, bal tashchit. Why? What does Hashem care, so you'll take a bread and break it? Because if it's there, it has some purpose, and the purpose is to use it for kedusha, and if you don't use it, you're not accomplishing what you're supposed to accomplish. Mimela, if a person would do everything properly, then a person has to eat anything that comes his way, which he is able to eat and able have make use from and is able to have pleasure, and do it in the right way, that's what you should do, and not make your own prohibitions. Don't restrict yourself, because by restricting, you're not gaining, you're losing. But that is only if a person is at a level that he is able to elevate everything that comes his way. But people who are on a lower level, what happens then? Then, instead of elevating the food that you eat, if you don't have the 100% proper kavanot, and you don't have the proper feeling, then instead of elevating that holy 谞讬爪讜抓, you lower it even more than before. Because now you ate it, and you ate it in a way that you lowered it down, and I don't want to go into the details of 注诇 驻讬 讞住讬讚讜转, 拽讘诇讛, like this, it's only 拽诇讬驻转 谞讜讙讛, it goes down to 砖诇讜砖 拽诇讬驻讜转 讛讟诪讗讜转, but

Half鈥慍up Story and Its Spiritual Meaning

that's the idea, it goes down. I think I mentioned the story once in the class before, that once by a meeting where the Frierdiker Rebbe was sitting, there was a few people there, they served tea, and this one person drank the tea and he only drank half a cup, so someone said to him, 'Why didn't you finish the cup? Don't you know that this half a cup is jealous of the other half?' So the Frierdiker Rebbe turned around and said, 'I wonder which half is jealous of which half, because if he didn't drink it lishmah Shamayim, then the one that he did drink is jealous of the one that he didn't drink, \"Why did you drink me and lowered me lower than I was before?\"' But so it depends. So this explains everything. When a person is at a level that he feels that in order to do the right thing he has to put restrictions upon him, this person has to do it. He should do it. We encourage him to be a nazir, and don't drink wine, because you're at a level that you can't. But to say that it was ultimately the right thing, it's a sin, because you So the fact is you didn't elevate that wine that you could have, so you have to bring a korban chatat. But nevertheless, it was right of you to do it. It says, 住讬讬讙 诇... 谞讚专讬诐 住讬讬讙 诇驻专讬砖讜转, 谞讚专讬诐 is good and it's a fence to stay away from aveirot, true. For who? For people who have to do it. On the other hand, it says in Yerushalmi: Why is it not enough for you the restrictions of the Torah? You have to add more? Because in truth, you don't have to add more.

Adam and Eve: No Need for Extra Fences

Adam Harishon and Chava were at such a level that they didn't need restrictions. They were at such a high level at that time. They were 讬爪讬专 讻驻讬讜 砖诇 讛拽讚讜砖 讘专讜讱 讛讜讗, imagine, created by the hands of Hashem? Who's created by the hands of Hashem? We're not created by the hands, we're all here because of Hashem, but physically we came from a father and a mother. They were the only human beings created by Hashem. They were at the highest level, it says the great levels of 注诇 驻讬 拽讘诇讛 of Adam Harishon. They didn't need restrictions. They made restrictions. For them it was wrong. And that's why that was the cause of the aveirah. Normally, you don't need restrictions. But it's only if you are at a level that you are able to elevate what you everything that you gonna come in contact with. But if you're not, then you have to have the restriction. That's why it says, as a general idea, we don't find in the Torah encouragement for vegetarians. Doesn't say it's forbidden. A person could be a vegetarian if he wants. Only sheilah on Shabbos, Yom Tov, not to eat meat, that's a question. But there's nothing wrong with it. But, on one hand, you would think, why wouldn't the Torah encourage it? What's the reason for those people, some of the people? How could you take a living thing and kill it, and eat it? Torah, we know, is 转讜专转 讞住讚. Torah is Torah of kindness. Wouldn't it make sense that the kind Torah would say, would encourage it, and say, no, it's right, and if a person could do that, it would be a very good idea. Tzaar baalei chayim, you know, why don't we find it? The answer is, because in truth, by eating an animal, you're doing the animal a favor, if you do it properly. If you eat properly, that means you eat it, you shecht it properly, and the berachah when you shecht it, and then you salt the meat, and then you cook it, and you eat it with the proper kavanot, what happens? You elevate the 谞讬爪讜抓. So the 讘讛诪讛 is the animal, the 讘讛诪讛, the cow, the meat is not meat anymore. It's a higher level. So you help it. But,

Vegetarian Thoughts and the Purpose of Eating Meat

it's only if you do l'shem shamayim. That's why the Gemara says, 注诐 讛讗专抓 讗住讜专 诇讗讻讜诇 讘砖专. An am ha'aretz, person not not a scholar, should not eat meat. Why? Because it says to eat meat, you got to work hard to elevate that meat that that 谞讬爪讜抓, because it's much harder to to work on it. Coarse, the coarser it is, the more 讙砖诪讬 and 讞讜诪专讬 it is, the lower it is, you got to work harder to elevate it. It says, I mean, it's hard to understand really, but it says that to elevate the 谞讬爪讜爪讜转 讛拽讚讜砖讛 of fish is easier than from meat. It's a lighter type of food. It's not so coarse, so it's easier to elevate. That's why it says in Rambam that when a person eats fish and meat in one meal, he should first eat fish and then meat. And the Rambam gives a very simple reason: because it's easier to digest fish, so you should first start your digestive system working, and when it's working already and you're in it, then you should eat meat. So Chassidut says the Rambam has a deeper meaning here, too. When we talk about digesting here, that doesn't mean physically digesting. You have to digest the food spiritually. And it's easier to digest fish, it's a lighter type of food, meaning it's not so grob, so you don't have to work hard against the yetzer hara to elevate the fish. But to elevate the meat is harder, so you got to start, we call it min hakal el hakaved, first from the lower, from the easier stuff, then you go higher. Because it's the whole idea is to elevate it, yes? Well, I'm sure a little bit you could eat. Doesn't mean you have to eat a lot. Eat a little bit, everything with a limit. You

Following Doctors: Health Within Torah Law

have to go according to the what the what doctors say. That's part of the Torah, too. You have to listen to the doctors. But it's not The Torah didn't say it's forbidden, the Torah just said that you have to do everything that not you shouldn't do things which are dangerous, whether it's doing or eating or things, and you have to listen to the doctor. Then there's, then you're not allowed to. Then it's like you're not allowed to. Depends how much, yeah. You can't rely on miracles even on Shabbos and on Yom Tov, and even at a simchah. Let me just finish this, and then I'll get to that. So what comes out of all this? What comes out that to make these chumrot, these extra things, is only if you have to, if you're not at such a high level. That's concerning a person making his own chumrot, like in Torah person should take upon himself a neder and restrict himself more. So it depends: if you're on a lower level, good, if not, better not to. The same applies to the general idea of the chumrot that the chachamim made. Generations upon generations there were no such chumrot. The Torah was given and that's how they they they lived.

Early Temple Era: Minimal Rabbinic Decrees

Throughout most of the the dinim stayed the same way throughout the first 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖. It all started basically after the churban of the first 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖, during the time of 讙诇讜转 讘讘诇, the 70 years between, and then more even, in the beginning of the second 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖. And the reason, it says, is because the Jews were not at the same level before. In simple peshat, it means that before, they didn't need restrictions. They were careful enough that nothing would happen. They didn't need an extra fence to say, well, make sure not to do an aveirah, you have to restrict yourself more, or we have to restrict you. Later on, with people not so careful anymore, so they had to add. That's the simple. But according to Chassidut it means that they were on a higher level, they were able to get involved into everything to the actual end, and they were able to elevate all these 谞讬爪讜爪讜转, and it wouldn't have a bad influence on them. But when people are not at such a high level, then we are afraid that if they get too much involved in gashmiyut, they will not be able to elevate it. So then we have to have all these restrictions. So the chachamim came and they added many, many of these restrictions during that time. And throughout the 讙诇讜转 time, we find later times that they added even more, and as

Generational Decline and Growing Rabbinic Safeguards

time passed, they added even more, because we're going down, down, down on a hill, because the people are not as good as they used to be, and as generations go, we get worse and worse, so therefore the restrictions are more and more. So this is basically the whole approach we have to the 讚讬谞讬诐 讚专讘谞谉. Nevertheless, there is something good about these chumrot of the 专讘谞谉. What we're learning here is just to show how the 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖 time was better than now. This is going to show the opposite, that's why I didn't want to stress it so much. But on the other hand, there is something special. If we do something that the Torah did not restrict, Torah did not say it's forbidden, and we, meaning Jewish people on their own, based on what the chachamim said, do it because we want to satisfy Hashem, that's basically why we do it, we're afraid we might do something wrong, we want to satisfy Hashem, and we do it even beyond what we were told, that shows that we are connected to Hashem very strongly. And, and this I

Beyond Basics: Child vs. Servant Analogy

think is connected to what I explained last week or once before. When we do exactly what we're told, it's fine. But nevertheless, what does it show? That what we're told is like a burden, and we have to do it, nebech, and that's what we do. If someone does something without being told, knowing that this is going to satisfy... Well, I think I explained you the difference between a ben and an eved. And a ben, an eved is a servant or a slave who does what he's told. What he's not told, he's not going to do. He'd rather not do anything, but he has no choice. And a child does whatever his parents want, not only what they want, what they tell him to do, what he knows they would like, because he loves them and he wants to show them his closeness. So if he feels that if I do this, my father will be happy, he'll do it. So which thing shows more his connection? When he does what he's supposed to, the basics, or the extra? On one hand, you look, well, the basics are basic, this is just extra things. But the extra is what shows his, we call it in Yiddish, ibergebenkayt, his closeness. And the same thing here: when we do what Hashem commanded us to do without anything more, then that shows, good, that's, we're doing what Hashem wants, fine. But when we do extra, then we show that we are closer to Hashem. And I mentioned last, that's the whole idea of lifnim mishurat hadin, to do more than the law requires. And I mentioned, that's one of the reasons it says the 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖 was destroyed. Says the Gemara, why was the 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖 destroyed? Because 砖讛注诪讬讚讜 讚讬谞讬讛诐 注诇 讚讬谉 转讜专讛, they did everything according to the Torah. And the Gemara could not understand: they did everything according to the Torah, so why was it destroyed? So it was good! They did everything only according to the Torah, but 诇讗 注讘讚讜 诇驻谞讬诐 诪砖讜专转 讛讚讬谉, they didn't do any more. And the idea of the chachamim adding these things also is the same idea, that we do more than we're told. That's why the Gemara says that Hashem says, 讞讘讬讘讬诐 注诇讬 讚讘专讬 住讜驻专讬诐 讬讜转专 诪讬讬谞讛 砖诇 转讜专讛, I love what the Chachamim said more than I love the Torah. In another place it says, 讞诪讜专讬诐 注诇讬 讚讘专讬 住讜驻专讬诐, I feel more strict with what the Chachamim said than with what the Torah says. But that's from a different angle. That's because when you do what the Chachamim said, that means that this is something that came from within Klal Yisrael, not that Hashem commanded us, that's a higher level. And a lot of things similar to that we'll find, that things which were not commanded represent a higher level. But generally speaking, the reason we have all these chumrot is because we are in a lower level. And this is what we learned here now, that the time of the first Beis Hamikdash, we did not need all these chumrot because we were in a higher level. Now, 讘讝诪谉 讛讙诇讜转, even in the second Beis Hamikdash, certainly later in the time of 讙诇讜转, we need these chumrot. What does this all lead us to? That when Mashiach will come. Now,

Future Vision: Mashiach and the End of Chumrot

I'm not saying that then we will not have all the 讚讬谞讬诐 讚专讘谞谉, I don't know exactly in that aspect what's going to be. But one thing is clear, when Mashiach will come, we'll be in the same level as we were in the time of the Beis Hamikdash, that we will not need all these extra restrictions 讚专讘谞谉 in order to protect us from not going too low and not doing anything wrong. If they will stay, it'll be for other reasons. But that

NOW PLAYING Choose a shiur to begin Rabbi Yehuda Leib Schapiro
0:00
0:00