Zichronos book cover Zichronos is in print! Order your copy on Amazon
LIKKUTEI SICHOS: VOLUME 10

Sicha Background and Hagahos: Toldos, Chelek 10

Correcting Which Parsha a Famous Sicha Actually Belongs To

Part of Likkutei Sichos: Volume 10 · 9:37

A short piece clarifying that a well-known sicha was misattributed from Parshas Chayei Sarah to Parshas Toldos, including the custom of reciting psalms by age and a note distinguishing the Maggid from the Baal Shem Tov.

Audio Transcript
Misattributed Shicha: From Parashat Chayei Sarah to Parashat Toldot

Concerning the 砖讬讞讛 that we're learning this week in the project 诇讬拽讜讟讬 砖讬讞讜转, the first 砖讬讞讛 of 驻专砖转 转讜诇讚讜转, I would like to give a little bit background. Two points. Number one, if you look at the end of the 砖讬讞讛, it says, "诪砖讬讞转 砖讘转 驻专砖转 讞讬讬 砖专讛 转砖"诇." At the end of every 砖讬讞讛, it says when the 专讘讬 said the 砖讬讞讛. So, people asked me, it's probably a mistake, because it's a 砖讬讞讛 on 驻专砖转 转讜诇讚讜转, so here it says, "诪砖讬讞转 砖讘转 驻专砖转 讞讬讬 砖专讛 转砖"诇," 诪住转诪讗 it's from 驻专砖转 转讜诇讚讜转 and it's a mistake. That's one thing I want to discuss, and also you see after the 砖讬讞讛, there is a 讛讜住驻讛, and that came from 砖讬讞转 砖讘转 驻专砖转 转讜诇讚讜转 转砖诇"讚. What does that mean? So, I just want to explain what happened. Number one, concerning the first thing, this is actually a 砖讬讞讛 from 驻专砖转 讞讬讬 砖专讛 转砖"诇, not from 驻专砖转 转讜诇讚讜转. In the 驻讗专讘专注谞讙注谉 of 驻专砖转 讞讬讬 砖专讛 转砖"诇, the 专讘讬 spoke the 专砖"讬 of 驻专砖转 转讜诇讚讜转, this 专砖"讬. And the 专讘讬 connected this 专砖"讬 to 拽讗驻讬讟诇 驻"讗 in 转讛诇讬诐. And the 专讘讬 even mentioned by 驻讗专讘专注谞讙注谉 that this is in honor of somebody who became, whose birthday is going to be that week, his 80th birthday. And I looked it up in the 讛谞讞讛 to see if I remember correctly. It doesn't say that the 专讘讬 said it, but the way I remember that the 专讘讬 said by 驻讗专讘专注谞讙注谉 that this is in honor of 讬讚讬讚谞讜, used to refer to 砖讝"专 as 讬讚讬讚谞讜, and that week is going to be 砖讝"专's 80th birthday. So, in honor of his birthday, the 专讘讬 in the 驻讗专讘专注谞讙注谉 before his birthday, the 专讘讬 explained a 专砖"讬 of that week of 驻专砖转 转讜诇讚讜转. In the 驻专砖转 讞讬讬 砖专讛, he spoke a 专砖"讬 on 驻专砖转 转讜诇讚讜转, and in that 专砖"讬, the 专讘讬 connected it to 拽讗驻讬讟诇 驻"讗, which is the 拽讗驻讬讟诇 that you start saying when you become 80 years old. So, that's why it's from 驻专砖转 讞讬讬 砖专讛, but it's a 砖讬讞讛 in 驻专砖转 转讜诇讚讜转. And as the 专讘讬 said, this was is in honor of the birthday of 砖讝"专. That's 讘谞讜讙注 讚注诐 注谞讬谉. Then, the fact that there is a 讛讜住驻讛 here, which is something very seldom, we do find in another place where there is a little this is a very seldom thing, what happened here is like this. I'll start from the beginning. I heard once from somebody who heard from a person who went into 讬讞讬讚讜转, and the 专讘讬 told him an interesting 讜讜讗指专讟. And he told me that the 专讘讬 told that person, he heard it correctly from him, the 专讘讬 told him an interesting

The Age鈥態ased Psalms 拽讗驻讬讟诇 Custom Explained

point. We're talking about the 诪谞讛讙 that's 诪拽讜讘诇 from the 讘注诇 砖诐 讟讜讘 that you should say the 拽讗驻讬讟诇 转讛诇讬诐 of your age. 诇诪砖诇, if you're 13, you say 拽讗驻讬讟诇 讬"讚, if you're 14, you say 讟"讜, etc., etc. So, the 专讘讬 told him an interest interesting 专诪讝. The 专诪讝 is that 拽讗驻讬讟诇 注"讘 finishes with 讻诇讜 转驻诇讜转 讚讜讚 讘谉 讬砖讬, that the 转驻诇讜转 of 讚讜讚 were finished. Now, 拽讗驻讬讟诇 注"讘 is 讘讗诪转 拽讗驻讬讟诇 注"讗, because the 讙诪专讗 says that the first two 拽讗驻讬讟诇注讱 are really one 拽讗驻讬讟诇. 诪诪讬诇讗, according to that, 拽讗驻讬讟诇 注"讘 is 拽讗驻讬讟诇 注"讗, and it says that that's when 讚讜讚 finished his his his 转驻诇讜转. So, it means that when he was 70 years old when he passed away, he was saying 拽讗驻讬讟诇 注"讘, which is really really 拽讗驻讬讟诇 注"讗. So, from here, we see a 专诪讝 to say the 拽讗驻讬讟诇 of the next one according to your age. So, this person told this to me. When I heard it, I heard it's a 讜讜讗指专讟 the 专讘讬 never said it by 驻讗专讘专注谞讙注谉, and never heard it anything, and the 专讘讬 said it to this person. It's a 讜讜讗指专讟, we've got to write it down someplace it should be, and the 专讘讬 should be 诪讙讬讛 to see how it's exact. So, I

Consulting R' Yoel About Recording the Rabbi's Word

went over to 专' 讬讜讗诇, and I told 专' 讬讜讗诇 this 讜讜讗指专讟, and I said, "If ever comes out that there's a 砖讬讞讛 which mentions in the 诇讬拽讜讟 that you're going to write that mentions the 注谞讬谉 of saying the 拽讗驻讬讟诇 转讛诇讬诐 according to your age, put this in as the 专讘讬's 讜讜讗指专讟, if not, it's going to get lost." And 专' 讬讜讗诇, and it 讟讗拽注 came once that that happened, and he 专' 讬讜讗诇 told me he's not going to do it, because if he's going to put that in, it'll be 诪注讜专专, the 专讘讬 will write him, "How could you write that just the way it is? 讘砖注转 we follow that 拽讗驻讬讟诇 讗' and 讘' are two 拽讗驻讬讟诇注讱, so it's not 注"讗, it's 注"讘. It's meant a 讙讗谞爪注 砖拽诇讗 讜讟专讬讗 and I'm going I can have what to answer to the 专讘讬, I can't do it." So, 诇驻讜注诇, 专' 讬讜讗诇 didn't do it. When it came to this 砖讬讞讛 in 转砖诇"讚, when this 诇讬拽讜讟 came out of this 砖讬讞讛, which is the 砖讬讞讛 from 转砖"诇 that the 专讘讬 said on 驻专砖转 转讜诇讚讜转, where he talks about 驻"讗 being the 拽讗驻讬讟诇 for 80 years old, so then here, I had a chance, and I wrote the 砖讬讞讛, so I wrote, "Put in this 讛注专讛, because it's a 讜讜讗指专讟 of the 专讘讬 which we wanted to save, so put in this 讛注专讛." And the 专讘讬 was 诪讙讬讛 for the 诇讬拽讜讟, and the 专讘讬 added, the 讛注专讛 just said this 讜讜讗指专讟 that we see a 专诪讝 from the 拽讗驻讬讟诇 注"讘, 讻诇讜 转驻诇讜转 讚讜讚 讘谉 讬砖讬, because it's really 拽讗驻讬讟诇 注"讗. The 专讘讬 added a lot to it, as you see the 讛注专讛 became very big, he added a whole bunch of things to it. Then, 砖讘转 by 驻讗专讘专注谞讙注谉, I actually wasn't there, I was already in Miami, but 砖讘转 by 驻讗专讘专注谞讙注谉, the 专讘讬 spoke about it, and happened exactly what 专' 讬讜讗诇 was afraid of. The 专讘讬 said that you're saying here and even though it says here 诇讞讬讚讜讚讗, "But how could you say that this is 拽讗驻讬讟诇 注"讘 注"讗 when really it's 注"讘?" The 专讘讬 asked the 砖讗诇讛, and the 专讘讬 went into a whole 讗专讬讻讜转 to explain why it's well according to one 讞砖讘讜谉 注''讘, which means 讗诇祝 and 讘讬转 are one, or the other 讞砖讘讜谉 it's not. And the 专讘讬 went to explain it. And after 砖讘转 the 专讘讬 asked that this 砖讬讞讛 that he said concerning this piece, should be given into the 专讘讬. And the 专讘讬 was 诪讙讬讛 it. And the 专讘讬 said that in the next 诇讬拽讜讟 they should add it as a 讛讜住驻讛 to the 诇讬拽讜讟 of 驻专砖转 转讜诇讚讜转. So in the next 诇讬拽讜讟 this was printed and that's a 讛讜住驻讛 to 驻专砖转 转讜诇讚讜转. It happens sometimes that the 专讘讬 within the next week's 诇讬拽讜讟 add something that has that's a 讛讜住驻讛 to the previous 诇讬拽讜讟. So when it went to the 住驻专 when it became these 诇讬拽讜讟讬诐 became 住驻专讬诐, it put was put into its proper place. So therefore after the 砖讬讞讛 this we have this a 讛讜住驻讛 to 注诪讜讚 75 诇讛注专讛 讘' 讘讛注专讛 31. This a 讛讜住驻讛 to the 砖讜诇讬 讛讙诇讬讜谉, which the 专讘讬 would call 讛注专讛 讘' means like a second 讛注专讛 to the 讛注专讛 31, which is 砖讜诇讬 讛讙诇讬讜谉, and that was put in because the 专讘讬 was 诪讙讬讛 it after that 砖讘转. And if you see in the end of this extra piece, a 讛讜住驻讛, it says 诪砖讬讞转 砖讘转 驻专砖转 转讜诇讚讜转 转砖''诇-讚, that's the year when these 诇讬拽讜讟讬诐 came out. So that was from that 砖讘转. The 专讘讬 spoke about it, and it was 诪讜讙讛 and went into the 住驻专 later on. But what I saw from here is that 专' 讬讜讗诇 had the real understanding. He knew exactly the style of the 专讘讬, whatever we could call style, that if you just write it, it's not going to pass. The 专讘讬 has to have everything 诪讚讜讬拽, so you had to have a 讘讬讗讜专. So, and that's what the 专讘讬 did. The 专讘讬 actually added a 讘讬讗讜专. In

Clarifying 诪讙讬讚 vs 讘注诇 砖诐 讟讜讘 in the Annotation

诇讬拽讜讟讬 砖讬讞讜转 讞诇拽 讬' page 81, 讛注专讛 9, at the end, the 专讘讬 mentions what it says in the 讙诪专讗 讘专讻讜转, 诇讜讜 注诇讬 讜讗谞讬 驻讜专注, which means that if a person doesn't have money to buy special food for 砖讘转, he should borrow, 注诇讬, the 讗讜讬讘注专砖讟注专 says on my 讞砖讘讜谉, and I will pay. And then the 专讘讬 says 讜专讗讛 讗讜专 转讜专讛 诇讛专讘 讛诪讙讬讚 讘住讜驻讜, and look up the 住驻专 讗讜专 转讜专讛 written by the 转讜专讛 of the 诪讙讬讚 of 诪注讝专讬讟砖 at the end. And then it says in brackets these words, 讜讻谉 爪专讬讱 诇讛讬讜转 讘讛注专讛 讚讛转讜讜注讚讜转 砖讘转 驻专砖转 讘专讗砖讬转 转砖诇''讙, so to that's how it's supposed to say in the 专砖讬诪转 讚讘专讬诐, which means in the 讛谞讞讛 of the 驻讗专讘专注谞讙注谉 of 砖讘转 驻专砖转 讘专讗砖讬转 转砖诇''讙, 砖讝讛讜 转讜专转 讛专讘 讛诪讙讬讚, that this is 转讜专讛 of the 诪讙讬讚, and then it says in parentheses, 讜诇讗 诇讛讘注诇 砖诐, it's not the 讘注诇 砖诐 讟讜讘. So people ask, what is the meaning of this 讛注专讛? So I want to say that by the 驻讗专讘专注谞讙注谉 of 砖讘转 讘专讗砖讬转 that year, 转砖诇''讙, that's the year that this 砖讬讞讛 that is printed in 诇讬拽讜讟讬 砖讬讞讜转 here 讞诇拽 讬' for 驻专砖转 转讜诇讚讜转, that's the year the 砖讬讞讛 came out. But that year 砖讘转 驻专砖转 讘专讗砖讬转, the 专讘讬 mentioned this 转讜专讛 concerning the 驻住讜拽 诇讜讜 注诇讬, but the 专讘讬 said that this is a 转讜专讛 of the 讘注诇 砖诐 讟讜讘. So, when the 专讘讬 was 诪讙讬讛 this 砖讬讞讛 for 驻专砖转 转讜诇讚讜转, and he mentioned this 讜讜讗专讟, which is of the 诪讙讬讚, so the 专讘讬 added that you this is how it's supposed to say also in the 讛谞讞讛 from the 驻讗专讘专注谞讙注谉 of 砖讘转 驻专砖转 讘专讗砖讬转 转砖诇''讙, that it's a 转讜专讛 of the 诪讙讬讚, and he underlined the word 讛专讘 讛诪讙讬讚 and not the 讘注诇 砖诐 讟讜讘. Because the way he said it, it said it was from the 讘注诇 砖诐 讟讜讘. So he said that it's supposed to supposed to fix it over there, and it's supposed to say that this is a 转讜专讛 of the 诪讙讬讚. So the 专讘讬 used the opportunity here in this 讛谞讞讛, in this 砖讬讞讛 that the 专讘讬 was 诪讙讬讛 for 砖讘转 驻专砖转 转讜诇讚讜转 转砖诇''讙, the 诇讬拽讜讟 for that week took the opportunity to mention that what it's he said in the 驻讗专讘专注谞讙注谉 of 砖讘转 驻专砖转 讘专讗砖讬转, a few weeks before, it's supposed to be that this is a 转讜专讛 of the 诪讙讬讚, not of the 讘注诇 砖诐 讟讜讘. 诇诪注砖讛 that 讛谞讞讛 of that 驻讗专讘专注谞讙注谉 hadn't come out yet when this 专讘讬 was 诪讙讬讛 the 砖讬讞讛, this 诇讬拽讜讟 for 驻专砖转 转讜诇讚讜转. So when it came to give out that 讛谞讞讛, there was a 砖讗诇讛, how should we write it there? Should we write over there 诇讻转讞讬诇讛 this is a 转讜专讛 of the 诪讙讬讚, but then no one will understand this 讛注专讛 here. No one will understand. What does it mean 讜讻谉 爪专讬讱 诇讛讬讜转 over there that this is a 转讜专讛 of the 诪讙讬讚? Should we write that this is a 转讜专讛 of the 讘注诇 砖诐 讟讜讘 and then on the bottom of the 讛注专讛 write that the 专讘讬 later said that this is really a 转讜专讛, write 讘注诇 砖诐 讟讜讘 and write on the bottom it's a 转讜专讛 of the 诪讙讬讚. We didn't know if that's what the 专讘讬 wanted. The bottom line, we decided that we're going to write 诇讻转讞讬诇讛 this is a 转讜专讛 of the 诪讙讬讚, as the 专讘讬 says here to fix. 讗讬讬, people will not understand exactly what the 专讘讬 means here, so I'm explaining it 讟讗拽注 now, that this was written because by the 驻讗专讘专注谞讙注谉, the 专讘讬 said it's a 转讜专讛 of the 讘注诇 砖诐 讟讜讘, so the 专讘讬 wrote here that that has to be in that 讛谞讞讛 it's supposed to say that this is a 转讜专讛 of the 诪讙讬讚.

NOW PLAYING Choose a shiur to begin Rabbi Yehuda Leib Schapiro
0:00
0:00