Zichronos book cover Zichronos is in print! Order your copy on Amazon
WOMEN'S ISSUES

Taharas Hamishpachah (Hashkafah)

From the kares-level halacha of niddah to the Kabbalistic meaning behind mikveh immersion, plus a wide-ranging Q&A on chatzitzah and mikveh construction.

Part of Women's Issues · 1:20:01

Explores why taharas hamishpachah carries the weight of an issur kares and how the kedusha of the marital bond, rooted in the words of kiddushin, serves as the true foundation of a lasting Jewish home. The Kabbalistic background of niddah is traced to the sin of Eitz Hadaas and the diminishing of the moon, with mikveh immersion explained as paralleling the teshuvah process of the Aseres Yemei Teshuvah. A lengthy Q&A follows, covering the halachos of harchakos, dental work as a possible chatzitzah, and the construction of a kosher mikveh including the Rashab's takanah of mikveh al gabei mikveh.

Audio Transcript
The Halachic Weight of Taharas Hamishpachah and the Foundation of Kedusha in Marriage

The discussion today as was set up is concerning the inyan of 讟讛专转 讛诪砖驻讞讛, and I think I will not really go into, maybe a little later some halachot, even though everyone is familiar with the halachot of 讟讛专转 讛诪砖驻讞讛, nevertheless it's worthwhile to refresh the main points of the halachot. They say that, forgot about which one of the 讙讚讜诇讬 讬砖专讗诇, one of the big rebbes that he used to review all of 讛诇讻讜转 谞讚讛 every month because it's so important. So it is kedai, it's worthwhile to review it and to refresh your mind, but the main discussion I think will be on the hashkafah aspect of 讟讛专转 讛诪砖驻讞讛. We know that it's a very, very important part of halachah. It is connected to a 讗讬住讜专 讻专转. We know that when we want to grade, so to speak, the levels of what's important and what's less important, more important, so the way in halachah we grade it is by looking at what punishment would be given. The truth is it doesn't mean that we have to weigh the mitzvot and do some more with more feeling than others. It says 讗诇 转讛讬 讬讜砖讘 讜砖讜拽诇 讘诪爪讜转讬讛 砖诇 转讜专讛, it says do not sit and weigh the mitzvot of the Torah. 拽诇讛 砖讘拽诇讜转 讻讞诪讜专讛 砖讘讞诪讜专讜转, the most lenient ones has to be as important as the most strict ones. So we can't weigh them. On the other hand, the fact that we do mention 拽诇讛 砖讘拽诇讜转, 讞诪讜专讛 砖讘讞诪讜专讜转, that we have to look at the lenient ones as much as at the strict ones, shows that there are lenient ones and there are strict ones. So as far as keeping them, we have to keep them the same way, but nevertheless we have to know certain things are more chamur than others. Now, those things which are connected to a 讗讬住讜专 讻专转, that the punishment for not keeping is 讻专转, those are from the most important ones. We always in halachah we say oh this we have to be very careful. If there's a safek you should be machmir or whatever, because it's a 讗讬住讜专 讻专转, because it's something that you get 讻专转 for. And in this din, inyan of a 谞讚讛, there is a 讗讬住讜专 讻专转. So therefore it is a very, very important halachah to keep. So there is the halachah aspect of it, and it's very important to keep with all the details, especially that by the inyan of 谞讚讛 we find that even a little bit, as we will see later, even a small drop, as small as it is, is also asur, which reminds us right away of Pesach with chametz where a mashehu, a little drop is asur, and that's why it's strict. But then we have the hashkafah aspect of it, what we find in sefarim concerning the meaning, the spiritual meaning behind the inyan of 谞讚讛. Now, at first glance, and fact it's mentioned actually in the Gemara that one of the reasons why Hashem gave us the mitzvah of 讟讛专转 讛诪砖驻讞讛 is that every month the ahavah, the love between the two should be renewed, and the expression is it should be as it is the day of the chuppah. Just like when they just get married, then it's new. When something is new, then the feeling is much stronger. We know that when you get used to something, then you lose feeling. There's an expression 转注谞讜讙 转诪讬讚讬 讗讬谞讜 转注谞讜讙. If you have a constant pleasure, then you don't really have pleasure from it. Something that you like to eat, if you eat too much of it, then you lose the geshmak, then you don't have the taste anymore. So the same thing here. In order for the feeling between the two should continue, and it should be as strong, always renewed, so the Torah gave us a certain amount of time when you are not allowed, you have to abstain, you have to separate. 讜诪诪讬诇讗 when it comes back, so then it's renewed with a new chayut, so then it's mamash like the 诇砖讜谉 is 讻讬讜诐 砖谞讻谞住讛 诇讞讜驻讛, it's the same as the day that she came to the chuppah. But obviously this is not the real reason why we keep the mitzvah of 讟讛专转 讛诪砖驻讞讛. Why we keep it is because it's a mitzvah like all other mitzvot. But we don't keep the mitzvot because of the medical reasons, we don't keep mitzvot because of whatever other reason is, we just keep it because Hashem told us to. Just like we think about kashrut, and there are so many reasons given by kashrut, health reasons, there are even reasons given in the 诪驻专砖讬诐 that we shouldn't eat meat of animals that are wild animals because the Ramban says, because that will give into the person the same 转讻讜谞讜转, the same characteristics as the animal that the meat is from, and therefore Hashem told us not to eat it. But nevertheless after we give all the reasons, this is not the reason why we keep kashrut. And the same thing here, the reason why we keep 讟讛专转 讛诪砖驻讞讛 is not for these reasons, even though they are side benefits, but it is because Hashem told us in the Torah that we should keep it. But even though we're not looking to explain Explain the mitzvah, but at least what we could take out of it. Now, this mitzvah of 讟讛专转 讛诪砖驻讞讛 is a continuation to the marriage. They get married, and then the mitzvah that's connected to their marriage is the mitzvah of 讟讛专转 讛诪砖驻讞讛. So we have to look into the whole 注谞讬谉 of marriage. In order to understand what is the purpose of marriage, we look into what is said, the words that are used at the moment when the marriage is done. And that is 讛专讬 讗转 诪拽讜讚砖转 诇讬 讘讟讘注转 讝讜 讻讚转 诪砖讛 讜讬砖专讗诇. He says, \"You are mekudash to me with this ring like the laws of 诪砖讛 and and 讬砖专讗诇, meaning the laws of the Torah.\" We use the word mekudeshet. And a simple translation of the word mekudeshet means set aside, you are specifically mine. From that moment on, after he gives her the kiddushin, she is 讗住讜专讛 诇讻讜诇讬 注诇诪讗, the Gemara says. She is now forbidden for the whole world. She is 诪讬讜讞讚转 诇讜, she is set aside specifically for him. But the Gemara says that the word 诪拽讜讚砖转 also comes from the word hekdesh, which means holy, from the word kedushah. She becomes to him like hekdesh, that's what the Gemara says, like hekdesh, which is holy. In other words, the marriage is a holy connection between the two people. It's kedushah that is supposed to have, that is supposed to be between the man and the wife, and the wife and the husband. So this is a form, an 注谞讬谉 of kedushah. It's not like lehavdil the 讙讜讬诐, in their religions they look at this 注谞讬谉 of marriage and everything that comes along with it, they look at it as something that you have to do, but it's, but it's definitely not holy. But according to the Torah, this is, it's holy. And they're both equal. In other words, it's a holiness that combines from one to the other, and not one more than the other. You know, it's not like he is more holy than her, or she is more holy than him. It is a connection that the unit, it becomes one unit, together, this is a unit of kedushah. That's why there's some sefarim say the reason why Chavah was created, was taken from Adam Harishon's side, she wasn't taken from his foot, and wasn't taken from his head. Had she been taken from his foot, you might think that she's under him, she's like his slave, his maid. Had she been taken from his head, you think she is in control, she is his head. She was taken from his side. What? She is taken from his side to show that she is equal. They are both equal. They just have different functions. Yesterday, when I spoke to the women, I explained the different function of the man and the woman, and then what is... The Yud and the Hei. The Yud and the Hei, right, right. Oh, your wives told you? At least I know... So, but the truth is that they're both equal, and this is a union that brings about kedushah. And if the union is based on kedushah, then we know that this is going to be an everlasting union. Why? Because if it's based on other things, you could always have differences. And when you have differences, what happens later? And it's normal, only natural and normal to have differences, because every human being is different. The Gemara says that there are so many millions of people, 讚讗讬谉 讚注讜转讬讛诐 砖讜讜转, there are no two people who their minds work alike. So there are differences. And if there are differences, so then what could happen? One person wants one thing, the other person wants something else, and it doesn't last. The only thing that keeps it together is the kedushah aspect of it. Because when it comes to the kedushah part of it, then there are no differences. This is part of the reason why we see that the rate of divorce amongst frum yidden are much less, much, much less than among non-frum yidden, or lehavdil amongst 讙讜讬诐. It used to be 诪诪砖 讻诪注讟 like nothing. Now, unfortunately, it's rising, but still, in proportion to what goes on in the world, it's completely, ve'ein aruch, there's no comparison at all. Why? Because the reason why there is a divorce, let's say, or separation is because I want this, you want this, and we can't come to an understanding, and then we have to separate. But that is if there is nothing in common that no matter what, they both look at it in the same way. In other words, there are no values that both of them look that this is very important, and then there are no differences. When there is no kedushah there, when there is no ruchniyut, no spirituality in the marriage, so then all it is is gashmiyut, the physical part. part, and so the physical part could start with a narishkeit, with a small thing. He wants the wall painted white, and she wants it pink, and then they fight over it and then and since it is an important matter, and the whole life is only based on such 注谞讬谞讬诐, such things, so then what happens? And they split. But even but if it's based on kedushah, so then even if there are differences of opinion in these matters, but they know in their mind that these matters are side things. That is not the most important part of their life. They both know that the most important part of their life is Torah and mitzvot, the ruchniyut part. And in the ruchniyut part, there are no differences. Because it's the same Shabbos for both, the same kashrut for both, there could be differences, fine, just small things, but they know that the most important part, the essential part of their life is is the same in both, which is ruchniyut, which is Torah u-mitzvot. And therefore, this is the only way that we could be guaranteed, as much as we are able to be guaranteed, that the marriage is going to stay. That's why if the 诇砖讜谉 we say, \"讛专讬 讗转 诪拽讜讚砖转 诇讬,\" which shows that the whole marriage should be based on kedushah. And then we go on, \"讻讚转 诪砖讛 讜讬砖专讗诇,\" which means according to the Torah, because what is the kedushah of the home? That is the Torah. So if they both follow the Torah, which is 转讜专讛 讗讞转, one Torah, so they both follow the same thing, and the most important part of their union is the same for both sides, and therefore they will stay together. Out of the 注谞讬谞讬诐 of Torah u'mitzvot that we say that keeps the marriage or keeps the union together and keeps them together always always being happy, so those things which are important or are part of the home are more important than the others. In other words, that Torah u'mitzvot, putting on tefillin is part of Torah u'mitzvot. But that's something that the person, the man, as an individual, has to do. But then there are certain mitzvot which are connected to the home as a whole. Those mitzvot definitely are the mitzvot that keep them together, because they're done 诪爪讚 the unit of a home. And that itself is divided into two parts. You have the revealed part, things that people see, people are aware of, it's something that's in the open, and then you have the part that's private. Now the revealed part is kashrut. Kashrut, I mean, everyone has to eat, and you always have to keep kasher whether you're married or not, but nevertheless this is a mitzvah that has to do with the home, the wife's cooking, and then other mitzvot that have to do with the home. The mezuzah, for instance, just give an example, the mezuzah on the door that has to do with the home, when they're married, and they move into a house, there is a mezuzah. So these are mitzvot that have to do with the home, and that is more important than the 讙砖诪讬讜转, the kashrut of the mezuzah is more important to them than the color of the walls, and therefore since on the mezuzah there is no fight, so then even if they disagree, they disagree on the other things, on what car to buy, but they they agree on the most important, on the mezuzah and on the kashrut. But those are things that are open to the public, so to speak. But then there are the private parts, the private part of Torah u'mitzvot which is 谞讜讙注 to the marriage. That is even more important in order for keeping together. And since they both agree and know to know that this is important part of their life, so therefore this is what keeps them together. So, the kedushah of the mitzvah of 讟讛专转 讛诪砖驻讞讛, that is what keeps the family together. And I know from personal experience with families that what kept them together was 讟讛专转 讛诪砖驻讞讛. I know that there were non-religious people who couples who very often they came to me, they had problems in the marriage, so I told them that they should start keeping 讟讛专转 讛诪砖驻讞讛. Usually, the way it works, that 讟讛专转 讛诪砖驻讞讛 is the last mitzvah that they accept, it's the hardest of all. People will accept kashrut, people will accept even Shabbat, Shabbat is pretty hard because after all, you have to give up a day of work, going out. But to to give up the to accept the mitzvah of 讟讛专转 讛诪砖驻讞讛, which 诪爪讚 the nature of the person, and we would call it the ta'avah of the person, this is the greatest ta'avah that a person has, to give that up, that is hard. But still, I told them, \"You know what? If takeh the harder usually that's accepted as the last, take it as the first.\" And that and that worked, because when the their their private life was based on the way the Torah tells us, and they knew that this is something beyond their understanding and it's beyond their agr- agreement or disagreement, this brought them together, and based on that, they built a home, and then the home continued, and the children became frum, and they had a happy life. But it's all started with taharat hamishpachah because that keeps it together. So this is a very general concept that taharat hamishpachah, being that it's a mitzvah, and being that it's a mitzvah that's between them in their married life, this is the foundation in a successful marriage because this keeps it together.

The Kabbalistic Roots of Niddah: The Sin of Eitz Hadaas and the Waters of Torah

But now let's get a little bit into the deeper meaning of what taharat hamishpachah stands for 讘专讜讞谞讬讜转, there's an 注谞讬谉, the 注谞讬谉 讘专讜讞谞讬讜转. We find a Chassidus that talks about it, we find in the 砖讬讞讜转, as a matter of fact, in the last 专砖讬诪讜转 of the Rebbe, that they're giving out now the 专砖讬诪讜转 that they found, the pamphlets that the Rebbe wrote for himself many years starting from 50, 60 years ago, and it was never printed, the Rebbe never gave it to print, but now after the 讛住转诇拽讜转, when they looked into the room, they found it, so now they started to print it, we get from time to time different parts of it. So the last one, which is the 12th pamphlet, so there the Rebbe discusses this whole thing of the 专讜讞谞讬讜转'讚讬拽注 explanation behind the 注谞讬谉 of 谞讚讛 and 讝讘讛, as I will explain, kind of the whole 注谞讬谉 of taharat hamishpachah. But generally speaking, the general approach to this 注谞讬谉 is like this: this whole thing of 谞讚讛, of 讚诐 谞讚讛, of a woman menstruating, started, the Gemara tells us, started with the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转. If not for the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转, if not for the first sin of 讗讚诐 讛专讗砖讜谉, this would have never been. So the Gemara says that 讘砖注转 she ate from the tree and Hashem cursed her, it says that Hashem gave the 拽诇诇讛 to 讗讚诐, to 讞讜讛, so that brought about the 注谞讬谉 of 讚诐 谞讚讛. And Chassidus explains it like this: the Gemara says that from the time of the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转, 讬专讚讛 讝讜讛诪讛 诇注讜诇诐, a certain 讟讜诪讗讛, 讝讜讛诪讛 means a 讟讜诪讗讛, a certain impurity came into the world. Not only into the world as a whole, but specifically it came into the person, and there is a tumah that we have to get rid of. That tumah expressed itself in this 讚诐 谞讚讛. That's why even medically, this blood is something that the body throws out because it's not healthy to keep in. So that's why every once in a while, every month, it has to come out because if it would stay in, it would contaminate the body, it's no good. Unless when she's pregnant and different things, but otherwise. So 讘专讜讞谞讬讜转 it says this is an expression of the tumah that came into the world. Now, why it was given to the woman? Because after all, Chavah was the one that started the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转. But really it's not only hers, the man also. So physically it came to Chavah, but this is a symbol of the tumah that came into the human being after the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转. Being that this is an expression of the chet, and a Jewish body is holy, not only a Jewish neshamah is holy, a Jewish body is holy, so what happens? Every month the body, so to speak, throws out this blood which represents the tumah that came from the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转. It's a natural thing, but it's a natural thing that came as a result of the 专讜讞谞讬讜转, because by Yidden, nature, even nature coincides, fits with the ways 讘专讜讞谞讬讜转. So in truth, this whole inyan of 讚诐 谞讚讛 should only be by a Jew. There was no reason for a goyishe woman actually to have this menstruation and the blood should come out according to this explanation. The reason it's there by a goy also, because imagine if it would only be by a Jew, it would be obvious that there's a difference between a Yid and a goy, there would be no bechirah. There's no free choice. Similar to something else. It says in Chassidus that the reason why a human being is set up the way he is, because it represents 砖诐 讛讜讬讛, that we represent Hashem's name. The head is like a 讬讜\"讚, and then you have the two hands, each one has five fingers, is the two 讛's, and then you have the 讜讗\"讜 in the middle. The body is like a 讜讗\"讜. So you have 讬讜\"讚, 讛\"讗, 讜讗\"讜, 讛\"讗. That's why the person is like he is. That's why he stands straight, because that's the 住讚专: 讬讜\"讚, and then the 讛\"讗 and the 讛\"讗 and the 讜讗\"讜 in the middle. But animals, they walk on four because they don't represent the 讬-拽-讜-拽. So then Chassidus asks, so how come goyim also walk like human beings if it's only because of the neshamah, because of the 讬-拽-讜-拽 that we have? The answer is, imagine if the goyim would walk on four and we walk like this, there is no free choice. Everyone sees right away that this is godly, this is not, so then there is no free choice. The same thing with this. With many things it says that those that have spiritual explanations is only by Yidden, and the goyim are all because there is 讻诇讬 讛讞讜砖讬诐. But anyway, so the idea of having 讚诐 谞讚讛 is because the Jewish body is holy, and it got, it absorbed the tumah from the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转, and therefore, once a month it has to come out, it has to get it out. Since it was in the Jewish body, and this represents the tumah, the body becomes tamei. Because it did hold, it contained the blood that represents the tumah, so the body becomes tamei. What happens? Because of that, the din is that you have to go to the mikveh. What's the inyan of going to the mikveh? Going to the mikveh the Rambam says in the end of Hilchos Mikvaos. The Rambam says that you should know that when a person becomes tamei, it's not the the the body, the dead body for instance that you touch that makes you tamei, and it's not the water that makes you tahor. It's a chok, it's a gezeirah, the Eibershter said. But nevertheless, he says even though it's a gezeirah, it's a decree of Hashem beyond understanding, but 专诪讝 讬砖 讘讚讘专. There is a remez, there is a hint that we take out from the mikveh. The hint of the mikveh is, he says, that just like when you immerse yourself in the mikveh, in the water, till you're completely covered, so too a person has to immerse himself in the 诪讬 讛讚注转 讛讟讛讜专, in the waters of knowledge, the pure, clean water of knowledge, which means the waters of Torah. So going to the mikveh represents the inyan of a person immersing himself in the waters of Torah. We always know that water represents Torah. It says 讗讬谉 诪讬诐 讗诇讗 转讜专讛, the Gemara says, water is Torah. The Gemara learns it out from a pasuk. There's a pasuk that says 讛讜讬 讻诇 爪诪讗 诇讻讜 诇诪讬诐. Anybody who is thirsty, go to water. The Gemara says, what does that mean? If anybody is thirsty to learn, learn Torah. How does the Gemara know it? So the mefarshim explain, because if it would mean simply whoever is thirsty go to water, we don't need a pasuk for that. Every person understands that if you're thirsty, you drink water. So obviously the Gemara the pasuk means something else, and the Gemara tells it means that if you feel a thirst to Godliness, you have to drink water, which is Torah. So 诪讬诐 represents Torah. We find an expression 诪讬 讛转诇诪讜讚, even 诇讙讘讬 Gemara we find, a person who learns a lot of Gemara, we call him he is swimming in the sea of Talmud, the sea of the Gemara, because water represents wisdom, and if we're talking in a holy way, it represents the wisdom of the Torah. When a person goes to the mikveh, that's supposed to represent that he immerses himself completely in the waters of the Torah. And that washes everything off, because when a person learns a lot of Torah, it washes off any stain, any impure stain that might come, the Torah washes off. That's the quality of the Torah that has, it washes off. Just like, and that's one of the reasons why Torah is compared to water. There are many reasons, but one of the reasons is because Torah has this quality of washing off things, because by learning, it's an 讗专讬讘注专讚讜专讱, so to speak. By immersing yourself in the water, it means you're covered completely till over your head. I remember once on yechidus, I went into the Rebbe in yechidus, so the Rebbe told me different things, and one of the things the Rebbe told me was: 讚讜 讝讗诇住讟 讝讬讬谉, 讝讬讬谉 讗专讬讬谞讙注讟讗谉 讗讬谉 诇注专谞注谉, 讗专讬讬谞讙注讟讜谞拽注谉 讗讬谉 诇注专谞注谉, 讘讬讝 讗讬讘注专谉 拽讗驻. You should be involved in learning, be immersed in learning till over your head. And he explained, so that's the expression he used, which I imagine he took it that this is a 诇砖讜谉 of the Rambam, that if you're over your head, it means that there is nothing left that's not involved in learning. Because if you're only swimming up till here, and it shows that part of you is not connected to the Torah, but you have to connect yourself to the Torah completely. So in order to wash away that stain that you, a person gets, in this physical case it's the woman, but it really means that the human, the Yid gets, because he had the tumah from the 注抓 讛讚注转 that was there that expressed itself in this 讚诐, so you have to learn Torah, and over your head. There's another thing here. The word tevilah, which means to immerse, is made up of the same letters as ha-bitul, which is juggle the letters around, ha-bitul, the bitul, self-nullification. That also means that in order to get rid of any impure stains, you have to be mevatel yourself, you have to be mevatel yourself to Hashem through being involved in Torah. And that's why the din by a mikveh is that it has to be completely. As long as you have your own metziut, as long as even you stick a finger out, you're not complete, you're still, there's still part of you that's not part of the water, the mikveh is no good, your tevilah is no good. You have to be mevatel yourself completely. It doesn't mean that you become, as we call in Yiddish, 讗 讬砖 诪爪讬讗讜转, another being. You're still there, but your being is covered through the water. When there's something immersed in water, it's there. It doesn't get lost, you just can't see it, because all you see is the water that covers it. So the same thing here, you have to be mevatel yourself in a way that you're batal to Hashem, and mimela then you get rid of all the stains that are there. In which form do you show your bitul is through learning Torah, as the Rambam, the 诪讬 讛讚注转, is through learning Torah. So when you learn Torah, that, and if you learn it in a way that you're mevatel yourself, that is you learn in the proper way in the form of bitul, you learn it not like some people would learn 砖诇讗 诇砖诪讛, you learn because I want to gain knowledge and you learn because I want to become something special, but you learn because Hashem said you should learn, that's learning through bitul. So then that wipes away the stain of the of the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转. That's another reason why 讘讻诇诇, Torah is compared to water. We find Torah compared to many things. Torah is compared to honey, it's compared to milk, it's all kinds, it's compared to water also. So it says in Chasidut that it's not just we pick different words, different things to compare the Torah to. Each comparison represents another aspect of Torah. What is the aspect of Torah that is represented in the 注谞讬谉 of water? So this is again a Gemara. The Gemara says, why is Torah compared to water? 诪讛 诪讬诐 讬讜专讚讬诐 诪诪拽讜诐 讙讘讜讛 诇诪拽讜诐 谞诪讜讱, just like the water flows from a high place to a low place, same thing with Torah, that Torah comes down to those that hold themselves low. In other words, water represents the bitul that you're supposed to have when you learn Torah. You shouldn't be a 讘注诇 讙讗讜讛. When you learn Torah you should be batel, you should be, shouldn't keep, hold yourself as a 诪爪讬讗讜转, you shouldn't, you know, have your own your own ego. That's what the water is. And that's the same idea as a bitul, when we say that when you immerse yourself, tevilah is a is a bitul, that takes care of the stain that comes through the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转. But then we have another thing here, that in certain cases, the 讚讬谉 is that you can't just go to the mikveh, but you have to have 砖讘注讛 谞拽讬讬诐, seven clean days. The 讛诇讻讛 is that nowadays, it's in all cases. But originally it was only by a 讝讘讛, not by a 谞讚讛. And maybe I should just go into that just for a moment to explain the difference between a 讝讘讛 and a 谞讚讛. When a woman sees 讚诐, sees blood for the first time, the way it's from the Torah, 诪讚讗讜专讬讬转讗, for seven days she is 讟诪讗讛. Whether she sees 讚诐 for all seven days, or she saw 讚诐 just for one second, she is 讟诪讗讛 for seven days. When the seven days are up, if she had stopped seeing by the end of the seven days, she's allowed to go to the 诪拽讜讛. So a 谞讚讛 is only for seven days. If she didn't stop, then you have to wait for her to stop, but you don't have to have any clean days before she goes to the 诪拽讜讛. A 讝讘讛 means, after those seven days there is a period of eleven days. Why eleven? That's how the Torah said, is a period of eleven days. And within those eleven days, if she sees 讚诐 within those eleven days, then she has a different 讚讬谉, different status, she has a 讚讬谉 of a 讝讘讛. And the 讚讬谉 by a 讝讘讛 is that she also has to go to the 诪拽讜讛, but she can't go to the 诪拽讜讛 unless first you have 砖讘注讛 谞拽讬讬诐, you have first seven clean days that pass. And they have to be seven consecutive clean days, then she's able to go to the 诪拽讜讛. Because of the complications in the calculations that people might confuse it, so the 专讘谞谉 said that from a certain time, no more difference between a 谞讚讛 and a 讝讘讛, that even a regular 谞讚讛 has to go, could only go to the 诪拽讜讛 after seven clean days. And that's the 讛诇讻讛 now. Anytime a person, a woman becomes a 谞讚讛, she has to wait seven clean days, and then goes to the 诪拽讜讛. In order to be sure that you have seven clean days, first she has to have 讛驻住拽 讟讛专讛, that means she has to make that special 讘讚讬拽讛, and keep the cloth in, in order to be sure that the 讚诐 stopped. And then from then on you have seven clean days. After the seven clean days, then she's able to go to the 诪拽讜讛. What is the idea of the seven clean days? Why must there be a 讞砖讘讜谉, why is there a 讞砖讘讜谉 of seven? So again, the real reason we don't know, this is something is beyond our understanding, Hashem said so and that's it. But still, as we're saying, there is a 专诪讝 in this whole 注谞讬谉 of 讛诇讻讜转 谞讚讛. So the Rebbe explains, and he explains in Likkutei Sichos, explains it here in the Reshimos also. The idea of the seven clean days is because the 讟讜诪讗讛 by a 讝讘讛 is much stronger than a 讟讜诪讗讛 by a 谞讚讛. Why? By a 谞讚讛 is natural. Normal, normally a woman sees 讚诐 every month and she becomes a 谞讚讛. The Chinuch says that 讝讘讛, 讝讬讘讛, is an unnatural thing. It's something that happens extra. To see 讚诐 within those eleven days is not natural. Normally she only has a cycle of close to about a month, and every time you see over, but after the seven days from when she saw is up, and then you have another eleven days, and those eleven days to see is not a normal thing. So if she does see, that means that he calls it, I think the Chinuch calls it a 讞讜诇讬. It's a sickness. It's something that it's sick, it's not natural, it's something wrong. But 专讜讞谞讬讜转, what does that mean? That as much as normally 谞讚讛 represents the connection to the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转, 讝讘讛 represents a stronger connection. There is more 讚诐, 讚诐 that should not have come normally, and nevertheless it's there. So that shows that her connection is more than a regular case. The Rambam says that whenever a person goes too much to one extreme, the only way you could come back to the middle is if you go to the other extreme, that's the famous Rambam in Hilchot De'ot. So the same thing here. When there is a natural occurrence that she becomes a 谞讚讛, there is a certain process that you have to go through and you become 讟讛讜专. Happens again every month, why? Even 讘专讜讞谞讬讜转, because you go to the mikveh, you 诪讘讟诇 yourself and you're clean, you're finished with the stain, but after all we're normal human beings, as time passes it wears off. And what happens? The 注抓 讛讚注转 starts coming up again. And therefore, again there is a 讚诐 谞讚讛. But that's a normal thing, Hashem put it into the world, 注诐 讛讟讘注, so that's normal. So in order to get rid of that normal natural occurrence of this expression of the 讟讜诪讗讛 that comes from the 注抓 讛讚注转, all you need is going to the mikveh, and with that you get you don't have to do something that will be in the other extreme. But a 讝讘讛, being that that represents a person that is more 讟诪讗, has more of the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转, more of the 拽诇讬驻讛 that's there than normal, so in order to get rid of that, you have to go to another extreme. What's the other extreme? The other extreme is that you have to have seven clean days before you're even able to go to the mikveh. Seven clean days means seven days when you are completely away from any connection to this 讟讜诪讗讛 of the 注抓 讛讚注转. And what's the 讞砖讘讜谉 of seven? Because seven is a complete cycle. You know, the number seven is a complete cycle. Chazal says a lot of things are divided into seven. It's seven days in a week. Even though Shabbos is the holiest day, but it's still part of the cycle. We have seven heavens, we have seven years of 砖诪讬讟讛, but Chazal says that seven is part of the cycle. Eight, it says, usually is something that's higher. It says, 讗讝 讬砖讬专 诪砖讛, so we have 讗讝, 讗诇祝 讝讬谉, you have the 讗诇祝 and the 讝讬谉, the one and the seven, so it says 讗诇祝 专讜讻讘 注诇 讛讝讬谉, that's the eight, which is beyond the seven, that's a higher 诪讚专讙讛. That's why it says 讜讬讛讬 讘讬讜诐 讛砖诪讬谞讬, the eighth day, that's when the day the 砖讻讬谞讛 came down to the 诪砖讻谉. But seven is a cycle. You find by a brit, it says, why is a brit on the eighth day? 讻讚讬 砖讬注讘讜专 注诇讬讜 砖讘转 讗讞转, so one Shabbos should pass, in order that it happens no matter which day of the week the child was born, you have seven days pass and you definitely have a Shabbos. But Chassidus says that means more than that. It means 讬注讘讜专 注诇讬讜 砖讘转 讗讞转, that the level of 讘专讬转 诪讬诇讛 is higher than the level of Shabbos, because it's the level of eight, higher than seven. But seven is a complete cycle. So we have to go through a complete cycle of 谞拽讬讬诐, a complete cycle of cleanliness, not being connected in any way to the 拽诇讬驻讛 of 注抓 讛讚注转 in order to be able to cleanse ourselves from this special extreme type of 讟讜诪讗讛. And then there's another thing: we find it says in in the HaAri zal writes that there are seven days between Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur. 注砖专转 讬诪讬 转砖讜讘讛. 注砖专转 讬诪讬 转砖讜讘讛 are ten days, but this includes the two days of Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur, but there are seven days in between. So the HaAri zal says an interesting peshat, he says, why are the seven days? He says, no matter which day it comes out, when you have seven days, you have seven days of the week, every day of the week, and therefore, you're able to do teshuvah for every day of the week. The Sunday of 注砖专转 讬诪讬 转砖讜讘讛 is the teshuvah that you have to do for all Sundays of the year, the Monday of 注砖专转 讬诪讬 转砖讜讘讛 all Mondays of the year, and if you pass all seven days, automatically you have done teshuvah for all the days of the week of the past year, and automatically it's the preparation for all the days of the week of the coming year. Same thing here also. The woman who became a 讝讘讛, that means that this person who has too much 讟讜诪讗讛 within him has to go to the other extreme, has to go through the extreme of 讟讛专讛, of 谞拽讬讜转, of being clean through a whole cycle plus that it should include all days of the week. So really it comes out like this, that the 砖讘注讛 谞拽讬讬诐 of the 讝讘讛 is mamash similar to the seven days of 注砖专转 讬诪讬 转砖讜讘讛. This is the preparation for her going to the mikveh, becoming clean. Now nowadays, there is no difference between 谞讚讛 and 讝讘讛, so nowadays every woman every month after she becomes a 谞讚讛 has to go through the seven days. And part of the reason is, not looking at the halachic reason why now every woman that there are because of the calculations, but because of the 专讜讞谞讬讜转讚讬拽注 reason, the reason is because now we're in such a low 诪讚专讙讛, that even under normal circumstances, the only way we are able to cleanse ourselves from the 讟讜诪讗讛 of the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转 is if we go to an extreme and we do it much stronger, that means we go through the seven days, and to cleanse yourself, not, you prepare yourself, then you're able to go to the mikveh and become clean. In other words, if you want to look at it this way, we could say like this: that going to the mikveh, to a certain degree, for the woman, and like I said before, physically it's the woman, but it really is for the woman and the man, it's like a Yom Kippur. Going to the mikveh is the end of the 砖讘注讛 谞拽讬讬诐. The seven days are the seven days of preparation, of getting cleansed and clean from the 注讘讬专讜转 of 注抓 讛讚注转, the 讞讟讗 注抓, the 拽诇讬驻讛 of 注抓 讛讚注转, and then when you go to the mikveh, that is the final cleansing, and then she comes out clean. So really, going to the mikveh is a very, very 专讜讞谞讬讜转讚讬拽 experience. And it's an experience that they're, for both. And this is to be able to prepare them that when after going to the mikveh and there is the union between them, the union should be a union 砖诇 拽讚讜砖讛. The union between the husband and the wife is a 拽讚讜砖讛讚讬拽 thing, is a, is a holy thing. In Kabbalah it says that when you have the relations between the husband and the wife, it's mamesh similar to the relations that we find between 讝状讗 诪诇讻讜转. In 讗爪讬诇讜转 we have 注砖专 住驻讬专讜转, the ten 住驻讬专讜转. We have three of the intellect, 讞讻诪讛 讘讬谞讛 讚注转, and then you have the seven 诪讚讜转. But the seven 诪讚讜转 themselves are divided into two: the six 诪讚讜转, 讞住讚 讙讘讜专讛 转驻讗专转 谞爪讞 讛讜讚 讬住讜讚, and then 诪诇讻讜转. And Kabbalah refers to the six as 讝讻专, and 诪诇讻讜转 as 谞拽讘讛, 诪砖驻讬注, 诪拽讘诇. I'm not going to go into this, but it's all, and that's why. And it says that when there is the connection down here, this brings about the connection of 讝状讗 诪诇讻讜转 诇诪注诇讛. Just like in the beginning of davenen, like for 讘专讜讱 砖讗诪专, it says we say, some people say before every mitzvah, Lubavitch only say it here: 诇砖诐 讬讞讜讚 拽讜讚砖讗 讘专讬讱 讛讜讗 讜砖讻讬谞转讬讛. The 讬讞讜讚, that that we're saying for 讘专讜讱 砖讗诪专, for the sake, 诇砖诐 讬讞讜讚 means for the sake of the 讬讞讜讚, of the union between 拽讜讚砖讗 讘专讬讱 讛讜讗 and his 砖讻讬谞讛. Who's 拽讜讚砖讗 讘专讬讱 讛讜讗 and his 砖讻讬谞讛? Isn't it the same thing? 拽讜讚砖讗 讘专讬讱 讛讜讗, that's Hakadosh Baruch Hu. His 砖讻讬谞讛, who's the 砖讻讬谞讛? It's Hashem. Ask somebody who never touched a sefer of Chassidus, he won't understand. And takeh those people don't say it. What do you mean, what's 拽讜讚砖讗 讘专讬讱 讛讜讗, what's 砖讻讬谞转讬讛? There's only one Hashem, we know 讛砖诐 讗讞讚. But if you learn Chassidus and Kabbalah, we learned that there is a 诪讚专讙讛 called 拽讜讚砖讗 讘专讬讱 讛讜讗, there's a 诪讚专讙讛 called Shechinah. So what's that Shechinah? It's 住驻讬专转 讛诪诇讻讜转. 拽讜讚砖讗 讘专讬讱 讛讜讗, that is the other six sefirot. And by saying this, we're 诪讬讬讞讚, we bring a union between 拽讜讚砖讗 讘专讬讱 讛讜讗 讜砖讻讬谞转讬讛. By every mitzvah we do it. So many people say it before every mitzvah. We only say it here not because we are against connecting it to a mitzvah, but that's because we say it once a day, and that's for the whole day. And the difference is because if you say before every mitzvah, that means that when you do a mitzvah you're doing a mitzvah. We feel that the whole day is a mitzvah. Everything that we do, there's no such thing as a mitzvah, well we're going to take some water now, that's also an avodat Hashem! 讘讻诇 讚专讻讬讱 讚注讛讜. I heard a story, there was once a chasid of the Tzemach Tzedek who was also very close to the Kotzker Rebbe, and then later he was very close to the Chidushei Harim. His name was Simcha Bunim? Anyway, and he used to travel, come from one to another, and they used to get regards from one another. So once they say he came into the Chidushei Harim, the Chidushei Harim was walking back and forth, he says to him, \"You learn Chabad Chassidus, don't you?\" He said, \"Yeah.\" He says, \"Can you tell me, what is the reason why in Chabad you only say l'shem yichud before Baruch She'amar? Why don't you say it the whole day, by all the mitzvot?\" So he told him, \"Because 讘讻诇 讚专讻讬讱 讚注讛讜, everything that we do all day we have to know Hashem. 讻诇 诪注砖讬讱 诇砖诐 砖诪讬诐, whatever you do has to be 诇砖诐 砖诪讬诐. So everything is avodat Hashem. So whatever you have 讬讞讜讚 拽讜讚砖讗 讘专讬讱 讛讜讗 讜砖讻讬谞转讬讛, every moment of the day you're able to have it. So what we do is we say it once a day, and that goes for the whole day.\" He stopped, he smiled, he looked at him and he said, \"Ah, how right they are.\" He didn't change his nusach, though. Maybe he personally did, because they say the Gerer Rebbes all davened of our, davened, and they still daven out of our siddurim, maybe they do, so I don't know. But 诇驻讜注诇, he understood, because this is... So, the whole idea is the 诇砖诐 讬讞讜讚 拽讜讚砖讗 讘专讬讱 讛讜讗 讜砖讻讬谞转讬讛. And it says that when you do a 诪爪讜讛 讘讙砖诪讬讜转 that is more symbolic, fits more, more coincides with the spiritual explanation, has a closer connection. That's why, for instance, it says that those mitzvot that are connected to light have more of the light of the mitzvah. It says every mitzvah is like a fire, 讻讬 谞专 诪爪讜讛 讜转讜专讛 讗讜专. A mitzvah is like a candle. Those mitzvot that are connected to candles have more of the mitzvah, because there, the spiritual aspect of the light actually turns into a physical light, while by other mitzvot, we don't see the light that's there. We put on tefillin, there is light there, but we don't see light. By lighting Shabbos candles, we see physical light which represents 谞专 诪爪讜讛 讜转讜专讛 讗讜专, or Chanukah candles. Like it says, that's why these mitzvot are more important. The same with everything else. Same thing here: when we do this mitzvah, the union, that is actually the 讬讞讜讚 拽讜讚砖讗 讘专讬讱 讛讜讗 讜砖讻讬谞转讬讛 that happens 诇诪注诇讛. So, you can imagine what kind of holy thing takes place at that time. That's 讛专讬 讗转 诪拽讜讚砖转, which we know that the reason for the kiddushin is 住讜祝 讻诇 住讜祝 for this. That's the real kedushah. In order to prepare ourselves, if we look at it this way, the kedushah is mamash like the kedushah the holiness, like the kedushah like Yom Kippur. You can't just jump into Yom Kippur, you have to have Rosh Hashanah, you have to have 注砖专转 讬诪讬 转砖讜讘讛, you have to have 讛讻谞讜转 to this ruchniyusdike thing. That's what this 注谞讬谉 is. That's why the Eibershter made it so that there should be, once a month, this going through the seven days of 谞拽讬讬诐. And when it's during those that period there is an, you know, there is a separation between the husband and the wife, which gives them 讘讻诇诇 time to be able to think and prepare themselves. Because after all, we're normal natural human beings and when we get too involved, we could forget and the ruchniyusdike aspect that is involved here. So the Eibershter said like this: for these days, stay away, each one themselves, you know, meditate and think and prepare themselves. And you go through the seven clean days which represents the seven, like 注砖专转 讬诪讬, like the 砖讘注, seven days between Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur. Then you go through the mikveh which is 讜讬讟讘讜诇 讘诪讬 讛讚注转 讛讟讛讜专, going through the waters and represents the bitul that you have. Then, you're able to reach the climax, which is the Yom Kippur and reach up to the 注谞讬谉 of the 诇砖诐 讬讞讜讚 拽讜讚砖讗 讘专讬讱 讛讜讗 讜砖讻讬谞转讬讛. So this is what Chassidus says and the Rebbe in the Reshimos explains it, not exactly in the words that I'm using, but explains this 注谞讬谉 of what is the ruchniyusdike explanation behind the mitzvah of 讟讛专转 讛诪砖驻讞讛. A man is, as well, I mean there's there's a connection with a man with the 注抓 讛讚注转, also, isn't there? Yeah, sure, sure, but that didn't become a nature. What's the difference? By a man, we don't find that naturally it happens, so obviously it's not the natural expression of the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转. By a woman, it says that because of the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转, it became a nature that every month, she produces a blood and it has to come out. So that is a direct, you know, result of 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转. So that represents 注抓 讛讚注转. The other thing, any tumah represents, any aveirah represents 注抓 讛讚注转, but here we see a direct representation because this is what the Torah, the Gemara says that if not for the 注抓 讛讚注转 it wouldn't be. It says in the in Midrash: to Mashiach will come, there will be no more 讟讜诪讗转 谞讚讛. It's an interesting thing. It says certain things will change, so it says there will be no 讟讜诪讗转 谞讚讛 anymore. Ai we know the Torah doesn't change, we have... So it doesn't mean that there won't the 讛诇讻讜转 of 谞讚讛 won't exist. The physical part won't be, the woman won't menstruate, so there won't be a 讟讜诪讗转 谞讚讛. But why will it be like that? Because the whole reason it's there is because of the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转. When we will be cleansed from the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转, because when Mashiach will come there will be the revelation of godliness and whatever was there before the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转 will come back and even in a higher level, there will be no need for this 讟讜诪讗转 谞讚讛, so there won't be. But now that we have it, so every month we have to get rid of it and then we prepare ourselves to cleanse ourselves, and we come to the level of Yom Kippur and then we have this 诪讚专讙讛 of kedushah that comes at the union that takes place at that time. This is a Yom Kippur that you have every month under normal circumstances. Ein hachi nami, this is even stronger. It's Yom Kippur, that's a Yom Kippur that you have every month. The reason that happens every month, so it says, because the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转 is connected to the 诪讬注讜讟 讛讬专讞. It says in the Gemara that this the moon became small. Chumash it says, first the Eibershter, Hashem created 砖谞讬 讛诪讗讜专讜转 讛讙讚讜诇讬诐, the two big lighters or lanterns. Then later, it refers to 讛诪讗讜专 讛讙讚讜诇, the big one and the small one. So the Gemara says, what happened? So the Gemara tells what happened. First Hashem created the sun and the moon equal. Came the moon and the moon complained: 讗讬 讗驻砖专 诇砖谞讬 诪诇讻讬诐 砖讬砖转诪砖讜 讘讻转专 讗讞讚, can you have two kings wear one crown? How can we both be equal? So Hashem said to the 诇讘谞讛, you know what, you're right. 讜诇讻讬 讜诪注讟讬 讗转 注爪诪讱, go and make yourself smaller. Says the moon complained, 讜讻讬 讜讻讬 讘砖讘讬诇 砖讗诪专转讬 讚讘专 讛讙讜谉? I said, I gave a good idea, so I should be the one to do it? So Hashem started appeasing it. He says, well, because of that, since you'll be the katan, the Yidden will be called katan, and Dovid HaMelech will be called Dovid HaKatan, and Yaakov HaKatan. Wasn't appeased. So finally the Eibershter said, you know what? Every Rosh Chodesh I'm going to bring a korban. One of the korbanot we find at Rosh Chodesh is a korban chatat. A korban chatat you bring for an aveirah. What aveirah was done here that we need a korban chatat? So he says, who brings the chatat? Hashem. It's a chatat for him for what he did to the moon. So it says that the fact that there was 诪讬注讜讟 讛讬专讞, that the moon became smaller, that was the reason, the the cause that later on there was 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转. It says there's a whole cycle this this. In Kabbalah it says 诪讬注讜讟 讛讬专讞 came from 砖讘讬专转 讛讻诇讬诐 of tohu and came from tzimtzum, whatever, I'm not going into that. So it's connected to the moon. So since the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转 is connected to the moon, so therefore it works by the moon cycle, not by the cycle of the sun every year. So that's why it's once a month. Plus, we know that the man and the woman, the man is compared to the sun, and the woman is compared to the moon, because the man is the mashpia, the giver, the woman is the mekabel. The sun gives the light. The moon doesn't have its own light, it's only mekabel, the sun is mashpia, that's mekabel. So the women are connected to the moon. So therefore, since Chavah was the one that started the 讞讟讗 注抓 讛讚注转, so that's why it was put into her, and it's connected again to the cycle of the moon because the women represent the moon. So that's why it's not once a year, it's every month. But the idea is that this is the way we're supposed to look at this whole thing. It's tumah, but a tumah that brings us to cleansing in a way that we are able to have the kedushah. So this is the the the hashkafah, the not hashkafah, the explanation behind 注谞讬谉 讟讛专转 讛诪砖驻讞讛.

Side Benefits: Renewed Ahavah and the Halachos of Harchakos

Then there are more things that, you know, we tell people, especially, you know, when you're mekarev people, to to tell them that there are a lot of side benefits, like I said before, that the Gemara says that this brings back the ahavah, the love, like it was in the beginning. Plus, one of the things that we find in the 讛诇讻讜转 谞讚讛 is the inyan of the harchakot, that during that period there are certain things that that they have to stay away. They can't touch each other, they can't hand things to each other, and then they can't even, you know, put down a plate, you got to make a change, a shinui. You have to have a heker, you have to have something on the table when you're sitting, all kinds of different halachot. Now on one hand, this makes it very hard. The simple reason for the halacha is because since it is forbidden for the husband and the wife to be together, usually we know there's a 讗讬住讜专 讬讞讜讚. Whenever there is a woman that is forbidden to a man, you're not allowed to be privately in a room. That's where 讗讬住讜专 讬讞讜讚 comes from. You can't, not even with a a single woman, you're not allowed to be, that's halacha of 讬讞讜讚. You have to leave the door open, you have to leave the window, whatever, all the halachot of 讬讞讜讚. So really they should have made a 讗讬住讜专 讬讞讜讚 by a husband and a wife also, since during that period they're not allowed to be together, and the Chachamim felt if you're in one room who knows what can happen, so they should have made a 讗讬住讜专 讬讞讜讚. They didn't make a 讗讬住讜专 讬讞讜讚. Why? Because they felt that the Yidden are so careful with this 讗讬住讜专 谞讚讛 because it's so strict that nothing will happen. But nevertheless, they said, no, even though we're we're confident that nothing's going to happen, we rely on them, but they gave certain restrictions in order to keep them apart. So that's the simple halacha reason. But the 讘驻讜注诇 what comes out from here, that certain ways of behavior which have no meaning at all turn into something special. Since for two weeks, I'm just giving a very practical thing here, since for two weeks he couldn't hand anything to her, after the two weeks, when he hands something to her, that has a special meaning, because it's something special. If this wouldn't happen, if we wouldn't have these 讛专讞拽讜转, then the only expression of feeling that one would have to the other is when it's actually an expression of feeling. But normal behavior wouldn't have any special expression. By doing this, small things, just putting down a cup in front of him, also shows some kind of feeling there, which is a side benefit that we get here, and many other side benefits we get, so that's another thing that we are able to look at. But the base of everything is that this is a halacha of the Torah, and it's a 讙讝讬专转 讛讻转讜讘. This is what the Eibershter wants us to do. I don't know if we should go to some halachot, but we'll see, maybe you'll have some questions. I want to say one thing, that I'm here as a guest. One thing is, any halacha question, or any other questions that are that come up in this aspect, or any she'eilah that comes up has to be asked by the rav, and it's 注砖讛 诇讱 专讘. This is also part of halacha that you have to go along according to the rav of your community. So I don't want to get involved here, I'm saying what, you know, in any halachot or anything, because it's up to the rav here, and that's where you should direct all your questions just So, but we have to know that in this area, a lot of people are not so familiar that questions have to be asked, and I'll tell you why. A lot of questions come up in kashrut, come up in kashrut. But kashrut is something that's done in the open that people say, \"Well, this and this case, yeah, I know, I saw it happen in this and this guy's house, and I heard this, and I saw that, and my mother, I remember, my father this.\" So so many things that we are, even if a person didn't learn so much, but there are certain things which are seen. This is something that's private. No one could say, \"Well, I saw it happen here, I saw-\" No one knows. That's why a lot of times when there are she'elot, or say, \"What's our minhag?\" Some people ask me, \"What's minhag Chabad?\" or \"What's our minhag?\" So certain things it says clearly, 诪谞讛讙讬谞讜, so we know it. But there are certain things where it doesn't say. So the truth is, I don't I don't know what our minhag is. In kashrut, you could still know what our minhag is. How do we have a minhag? Or what it says, or we see what most of the people in this community, most of Ashkenazim do, most Sefardim do, right? So you could That's how a minhag becomes. In here, there's no such thing as to say most, but who knows what most people do privately, how they keep this halacha? No one knows, it's hard to say. So therefore here, it's even more important to ask a shaila because, first of all, people are not familiar, and there is nothing that's handed down just by seeing the way it happens. So here, it's very important to ask a shaila. Plus, a lot of times, these are things that people are embarrassed to ask. So that's why you need more chizuk. I know women sometimes are embarrassed to come, you know, come with a mar'eh, come with a cloth, you know. In some plurals, come with underwear. I mean, who's going to come come to a rabbi with But they have to know, just like when you come to a doctor, there is nothing to be embarrassed, and that's his job. And you have to know that the Rav is, if he's a Rav then he's going to be confidential, no one's going to know, and it's private, and he doesn't tell anybody. But this is something that we have to stress always, that we have to always ask shailos, and a lot of shailos come up, whether it is in the 讛诇讻讜转 谞讚讛 itself or in the mikveh part. The mikveh part, a lot of times shailos. I mean, it was a chatzitzah, it wasn't a chatzitzah, that's where we'll get to your part. Is this called a chatzitzah? Is this not? Because when you go to the mikveh, you have to have you're not allowed to be any separation, interruption between the person, the body, and the water. So sometimes you come and I found nail polish, people come show, \"Was that is it a chatzitzah or not?\" and other things, or in the case if it's clear about with the teeth, because even though the water doesn't have to come in, but it has to be fit to come in, so all these shailos, so you have to ask. And this is one of the most important things that we teach people: to know that do not rely on yourself, do not hesitate from asking shailos. But before I'm going to let you say concerning the Steve wanted to ask something here. Yes, two quick questions.

Q&A: Divorce, Nursing, and Dental Work as a Chatzitzah Concern

Number one, how do you understand when people get divorced who are keeping family purity with this holiness connection to their divorce? Because after everything, there is still free choice. I mean, it's still it's possible. This is just the formula that's going to make it work. Now it could be that even though they have the halachos, and still they're the exception. As long as it's an exception, we know we're going in the right direction. Now, even that period, there's an exception. You have sometimes even tzadikim who followed the right path and turned away. Yochanan Kohen Gadol, and you have Elisha ben Avuya. It's possible that doing the right thing and it doesn't work, because there is still free choice. And Hashem said that you have a choice to divorce, so a person has a choice to do it. A person has a choice to get angry over stupid things, even though he knows that those are side things, not important, and it's not worthwhile to get involved, but it still could happen. I mean, it's not But we do see that the rate is completely different. Why is it that a woman doesn't go to the mikveh usually when she's nursing or when she's pregnant? Why doesn't the sin take effect on her then? Because the zechut, according to the 专讜讞谞讬讜转 the explanation, the zechut of carrying a child, bringing a child to the world is so strong that it doesn't allow the effect of the 注抓 讛讚注转 to take place. That's what it is. And also by a nursing woman, if she is raising a child in a way that just in this mamash physically raising it and nursing it, so then that zechut itself doesn't allow the tumah of the 注抓 讛讚注转 to stay in the person. This is such a holy thing. We're talking about chatzitzah, and maybe after you finish, I just want to add a few points 讘谞讜讙注 the mikveh itself because you tell me if you're if if you're interested in the difference between the 诪注诇讛 of a 诪拽讜讛 注诇 讙讘讬 诪拽讜讛 where Lubavitch has, because some people just hear about it and they want to know, so I thought maybe So you you say just take your time as long as you Concerning dental work and appliances in the mouth, generally, if an appliance or something is placed in the mouth, if it's intended to be removed, usually that would dentist would explain to the person this has to be removed, you have to clean it, take it out. Usually things of that nature are dentures, removable partial dentures, appliances that are designed to accomplish some kind of therapy, such as move teeth or stabilize teeth. These things are generally removable, and they should, the person who has them knows that they should be removed. Those involve no, nothing unusual other than to take them out of the mouth, and and then the the mouth is in a natural state. There are things in dentistry which are placed into the mouth which are intended to stay there. Typically a a filling is something that becomes part of the tooth and it it is meant to stay in the tooth. It cannot be removed unless by drilling or destroying the tooth. For instance, a crown is placed on a tooth and it's meant to stay there for as long as a person keeps the tooth. That that's something which is not removable. There there are things which are placed in the mouth for a period of time and meant to be replaced, such as a temporary filling. Here too, the intent is for the filling to stay in the tooth until such time as the dentist chooses to remove it, but it's not a filling that the patient can remove by himself. For instance, a patient might be having a crown made, and during that period of time, a temporary crown could be made for the tooth, and a person could have a crown on the a plastic crown on the tooth which eventually will be replaced, but during the time the patient is wearing it, that is meant to be on the tooth, and What's the difference between temporary and permanent filling? What makes it temporary? Okay, a temporary filling would be generally a material which is used for an interim period of time. A temporary filling would be typically a a type of dental cement or medication which is placed in the tooth to accomplish something. In other words, if the tooth is very sensitive and and the nerve is irritated, this type of filling would be placed in the tooth to medicate the tooth to achieve relief of pain. And then after a period of time, generally six weeks, that would be replaced, or part of it would be replaced with a more permanent filling which would either be a silver filling, or what we have are composite resins which look more like a tooth, or even a crown. But during the period of time when a person has temporary in their tooth, that would be very difficult to to remove, even though we call it a temporary, for the period of time that it's in the tooth, it should be there without removal, from the dentist's point of view. I think we'll hear maybe some comments on on the halachic point of view. Temporary, you mean, in terms of your intent, but the bond is no less strong than the permanent bond? Less strong, no? No, mechanically mechanically the bond is as strong. The material is not as strong. But to take it off, you just give it a flip with something and it comes off. There are those, yeah. Yeah, there are cements which are soft that can be just flipped down. And then there are harder cements. I should remember from my own teeth. Yeah. I had a temporary crown and it just came I could just It flips out, and then Well, the intent of a temporary crown is that it can be removed, and yes, it it can be removed sometimes just by using a slight amount of pressure on the crown. For a person to take that out though, he'd have to be prepared, a patient himself. For a person to take that out himself, he'd have to be prepared to put it back. So if that were contemplated, let's say, if you considered that something which needs to be removed prior to mikveh, then you'd have to be prepared to either put it back on yourself or visit your dentist to have it put back on, because that that that would create problems for the person's dentistry later on not to have it on. There are things such as braces where a bracket is a metal bracket or ceramic bracket is cemented to a tooth, which really is permanent until that is removed, and it's a it's a very strong bond. It's not something you can just take off and flip that. It has to be actually broken off or drill or or you drilled drilled off the tooth. However, that bracket the intent of that bracket is to hold a wire. That wire can be removed because it's just held in place by elastics which can be removed. Those are not not, from a dentist's point of view, a permanent type of fixture in the mouth. They are meant to be changed. Now you have today you have things like implants, which are placed into the bone. Bone heals and holds this metal post in the bone. becomes part of the body. It's not in a tooth, it's in the bone. And that, of course, would be a permanent fixture in in the mouth. However, there would things which are placed onto that implant in some circumstances can be removed, in others not, depending on the type of replacement that is that is selected for that particular case. In certain cases, I would say the rule of thumb for a patient would be if the dentist tells you, \"This should be removed to be cleaned,\" then you know it's removable. It should be removed before mikveh. If if the dentist tells you this is going in permanently, I'm cementing it in, you cannot take it out without damaging the tooth, then that would that would be a very difficult thing to remove prior to mikveh. I tried to give just a dental perspective on these, maybe you can I'm going to just refine the halachah, just say the halachic ramifications. The din is, specifically concerning the mouth, water doesn't have to come into the mouth. It doesn't say open your mouth and let the water come in. So, we would imagine that there is no problem with chatzitzah in the mouth, because chatzitzah means that there should be nothing in between the body and the water. If the water doesn't even come in anyway, so what is the difference? Nevertheless, the Gemara says it has to be 专讗讜讬 诇讘讬讗转 诪讬诐. Every place has to be fit that if the water would have to would have had to come in, it would have been fit. So, the mouth has to be clean, and you know, that's why she has to brush her teeth, make sure there's nothing in between the teeth. That's why there's even a halachah that a woman, the day she goes to the mikvah, should not eat meat. Shabbos is an exception, but not to eat meat. Why? Because usually pieces are left between the teeth, and it's hard to get out. I would like to add on my own not to eat corn, because that's even worse. I know when you eat corn, days you could have piece stuck between your teeth. Even with floss. Anyway, in Shulchan Aruch it says, it says you're not allowed to. So, on Shabbos is different, and on Yom Tov, and other she'eilot. But but, so the idea is you have to have it clean. Now, if you have something in the tooth that's a foreign matter, that's chatzitzah. What makes it foreign? So, if you put it in in a permanent way, so then it's not foreign anymore, it becomes part of the body. So, then there is no she'eilah if you have a permanent filling or a permanent crown, I mean, then that's definitely part of the body, and that's it. The question is on these temporary things. Since it's temporary, so it's still called foreign. So, I'm just going to tell you the different opinions. Some say that if, not some, this is a clear din, that if it's going to stay in there for thirty days at least, that's called already that it's not foreign. That's called kviut. If the plan is that it'll stay in for thirty days. In that itself, there are two opinions. Some say it means thirty days from when it was put in. Now, this could be a could be she's going to the mikvah three days before she's going to have it removed, but it's going to be there already, it's already there for twenty-seven days, that's one thing. The other opinion is it has to be in for thirty days from the day she goes to the mikvah. There is even an opinion, which some rabbanim, I'm not paskening anything here, against, it's not my territory, some rabbanim would rely on it b'shaat hadchak, that even if it's in for seven days, it's already considered in there that it's part of the body, kavua. There's even an eitzah, some say like this: that the doctor will tell the woman that, \"I'm going to keep it in for thirty days,\" and then she goes to the mikvah because it's in there, and then a week later he calls her up and says, \"You know, I think you should take it out,\" and he's allowed to do it. It's not called cheating because at that it it depends on what is the status of it at that time. If at that time it was kavua, it's like a person has a tooth and then after the mikvah it breaks. I mean, at that time it was kavua. But if she knows that chachmah beforehand, it doesn't count. I mean, then she knows it's going to be taken out. But if she doesn't know, then that's some people will tell you to do that. But this is the whole idea that what is considered foreign and what is considered not foreign. And always case like a a anything that could be taken out definitely should be taken out, there is no question about it. Some people who would wanna not want to rely on all these heterim, by a temporary, let's say, crown or filling, they would go to the dentist the day of the mikvah, have him take it off, go to the mikvah, and come back the next day, if it's possible. I'm not saying the dentist will tell you if it's possible or not. But have things like that, because definitely better without it. But if you can't take it out, then there are these different approaches that rabbanim would have. Is it assur to be mochel? Is there such a thing as mechilah? On what? In other words... On going to the mikvah? Yeah. That she should be or not he? Both, if they both agree. It says by mechilah, her mechilah helps. It means like this: the whole inyan of her going to the mikvah for the sake of having relations is like a chov, it's like an obligation he has to her. A husband has three obligations: 砖讗专讛, 讻住讜转讛 讜注讜谞转讛. He has to feed her, has to give her clothes and he has to give her the onah. So it's an obligation. Just like if someone owes somebody money, the person could be mochel, says, \"I don't he could don't,\" same thing she could be mochel. So al pi halachah, if there is a case where it's a big she'eilah and it would mean a big kula in order, so then if she's mochel she's mochel. Now it's not I wouldn't say it's it's it's encouraged. We don't encourage these things. Aderabah, rabbanim in these cases don't look for chumrot, look for kulot because you want the family life to continue the normal natural way. But if you're asking in theory, there is such a thing as mechilah. She could be mochel. Even by an 注讜谞讛 讚讗讜专讬讬转讗, see there are two types of onah. Onah means a time. What's the time a person has to give to his wife? So there are different depends what your job is, but the night of the mikveh that's called an 注讜谞讛 讚讗讜专讬讬转讗. So concerning the other times, then certainly she could be mochel. But even by this 注讜谞讛 讚讗讜专讬讬转讗 when there's but because it's an obligation on his side to her, she could be mochel for her obligation, his obligation to her. Still need a good reason in general, though. Whether you both need a good reason to Yeah, yeah. You don't just like that, you don't push it off. Bichlal you don't push push off going to the mikveh is a different problem, you don't push off. And even for this you need a good reason. You need a good reason. It just doesn't A safek is a safek whether checking within the five days? Even after the five days. In the five days? You mean after the five days. Yeah well, it could be anything, so you mean Even before, like when she sees, it's like for four days, could be in No, for five days. But those five days there's nothing to check because she can't start her counting anyway. Oh, on the fifth day? Okay. So, there is a safek there. So, to be could be machmir and say, \"Give it another day\"? Yeah, sure, sure, sure, sure. But it's not kedai to be machmir. You know you don't just be machmir on your own, go to a rav to ask. Sometimes the rav will tell you, \"This is a safek, it's very you know, sometimes you have a borderline case that he says, 'It's kedai to be machmir'.\" But it's not to say, \"Well, I'll be machmir on my\" that's not kedai. You shouldn't say, \"I don't want to trouble the rav, just...\" No, no. No, no. You do trouble the rav. And you should you know you shouldn't you shouldn't be machmir on yourself. Like this just reminds me of a joke, that there was this guy who lived in a little village and whenever he had a she'eilah on his food, on his meat, he would come to the rav to ask in the city. For a long time he didn't come. Then finally he came, so the rav asked him, \"What happened?\" So he says like this, says, \"Someone told me, why ask the rav? It says in Chumash that any meat that's treifah, throw it to the dog.\" So he said, \"hakarat hatov, so anytime you have a she'eilah, just throw it to the dog. You'll see, if he'll eat it, you know it's treifah, if he won't eat it, it's not treifah. So, that's why I stopped coming.\" So then he asked him, \"So why did you start again?\" \"The rav is a The dog is a big machmir.\" So somebody a person himself you can't just be a big machmir, it doesn't work that way. Sometimes you know the rav could tell you, \"Yeah, this is something\" Even sometimes the rav might tell you, \"You could have a heter here, but it's taking a little too far, even though if you want you could\" There you could say, \"Well, I could be machmir.\" But just stam on my own, \"I don't want to bother the rav, I'll be machmir,\" that's not that's... Well, what when the rav tells you to come back the next day? Why does he tell you? Like with a mar'eh, let's say. No, no, why does he tell you to come back the next day? Because of I mean passing of time? Doesn't matter. The colors change? No, that's just because the piece of The air so it goes darker? No, it says that the 专讘 驻住拽谞'住 according to the way he sees it. Right. Not to say it looked different, that's They purposely postpone it so that the next day it was a little darker? Purpose? Sometimes you make it worse. Purpose, you don't know if you're gaining. Sometimes when the what stays longer it looks worse. Sometimes it looks better. No, it just he does he looks at it when he can and that's it.

Building a Kosher Mikveh: Mikveh Al Gabei Mikveh and the Rashab's Takanah

Should we get just into for a few moments into mikveh, hilchot mikveh, is it? I don't know to what time we need to Yeah, someone is about to close the 住讬诪谉 专\"讗 doesn't bite itself. Oh, okay. Yeah, but that's The 讟\"讝 and the 砖\"讱 is very dense. Yeah, I know. You have to learn that's No, I just want to say the general idea. The whole problem here is it's based on the idea of question of 谞转谞讛 住讗讛 讜谞讟诇讛 住讗讛. The din is Like this: In order to have a 讻砖专 诪拽讜讛, you have to have 40 住讗讛 of mei geshamim. You have to have 40 住讗讛, I don't know, let's say, let's say about 100 gallons of rain water. That makes the mikveh. After you have that 40 住讗讛, you could add thousands and thousands and thousands of 住讗讛, makes no difference, it's kasher. What happens if you have the 40 住讗讛 and you add more, so there's no problem, I mean that's definitely no problem, but then you take out some. Let's say you had 40 讻砖专 住讗讛, you added one 住讗讛 of of sink water, so now you have 41. Then you take out one 住讗讛. You're still left with the shiur of 40 住讗讛, it's a 讻砖专 诪拽讜讛. But you definitely don't you definitely don't have 40 住讗讛 rain water. Because when you took out one 住讗讛, you definitely took out some of the rain water. Since you had originally exactly 40 住讗讛 of rain water, so now you're missing. So the halachah is it's good. As long as it started with 40 住讗讛 and you added, then you could take out. There is one opinion, that's the Raavad, that says it's no good. So according to the Raavad, we have a problem with many of our mikvaot. Because when you, how do we make a mikveh normally? You have, like you said, a 讘讜专 where you gather this rain water, and then you have another place where you tovel, the actual mikveh where you tovel. That's sink water, that's not rain water. You don't tovel in the original rain water. And then you have a 讛砖拽讛, you have the hole between that connects the two, and when you connect the two, it becomes like one mikveh let's say. But what happens when you change this water every day? And the nature of water is that when you connect water, some comes here, some goes there, and they even out. If you have a lot of water here and a little bit here, but then it'll come out. So eventually, some of the rain water goes away and some of the sink water goes in. So after a while, you're not left with the original rain water. So you don't have the original 40 住讗讛 rain water, so what do we do? So usually, they didn't bother with it, because 注诇 驻讬 讚讬谉 it's kasher, what's the problem? But since we're dealing with mikveh, which is we can get to 讗讬住讜专 讻专转, plus yidden became more, I wouldn't say more yirei shamayim, adraba, maybe because we're so low, so we try to make everything better, because we need some, you know, something to hold on. People higher madrega, they could remain the way, and we always have to look for more. So they started being 讞讜砖砖 for this. So the 爪讗谞讝注专, the Divrei Chaim, came with an 注爪讛. The 注爪讛 was to make two 讘讜专讜转. Have two 讘讜专讜转. You have one 讘讜专 of rain water and another 讘讜专 of rain water. So even though this water, the sink water, will change with the rain water, but you have another 讘讜专 yet. But some people even question that. All you did, you just pushed it off for a little longer. I think somebody made a cheshbon that after 15 changes of the mikveh, you've lost your original water. I remember we had to ask, you know, people. So if you have two 讘讜专讜转, it's going to be 30, it would be 50, so the rain water isn't changed in 10 years, I don't know what happens. So that's where the Rabbi Rashab came with an 注爪讛. He said that you should make the rain water on the bottom. And what happens then, the further the the the least mixture of water is top and bottom because of the pressure of the water, especially if the top is warm and the bottom is cold, then they don't mix. I remember when they built the mikveh in Long Beach, California, the architect there, he didn't know, he just was talking to them, so he said from his point of view that the furthest way for mixing that you that's possible for us to make, is by having hot water on top and cool water on bottom. And since the top mikveh is usually warm, so that mixes the least. Mixes the least, so you're usually they are left with the bottom, and that's what this 转拽谞讛 was. Those that came and came on to say against, maybe because this... There's a 讚讬谉 that if there's a flow of water, it doesn't make a connection, so not 讛砖拽讛. They bring a Divrei Chaim, a 转砖讜讘讛 Divrei Chaim, which is not talking about this case at all, if you look at it. He's talking about two floors. You have a mikveh, the rain water on the bottom, and you have a mikveh on the second floor, and there's a pipe in between. That's a different case. That's where he says that you shouldn't do it. But we're talking about just being in the floor, the hole, the same hole like you had on the side, especially the way it's done is when you fill up the bottom hole, they let it overflow and then on top of it, so really it becomes one mikveh. This is the 诪注诇讛 of the 诪拽讜讛 注诇 讙讘讬 诪拽讜讛. And Rabbi Rashab said it, this is the best way to, and this is the way to do it. But some people want, so they have both. They have a mikveh under and then they have under they have on the side so you have both. And then you have a third, then you have a 讝专讬注讛. No, the location is not the problem. The problem is the 转砖讜讘讛 Divrei Chaim, where they claim according to him this is not called a connection. The they connect that The mixture is the least? Yeah, that's right. That's true. No, no, no, no, from 讙砖诪讬讜转, no, you're not Yeah, yeah. That's why the mikveh should be I guess the mikveh here is like that, so if you look into the mikveh you will see. Yeah, like this, if two holes on the sides for 讛砖拽讛. Why do you have two holes? If you have 讛砖拽讛 on the side you only have one, because you don't need two. But since it's on the floor you might cover it with your foot. And there is an opinion, even though it's not 讛诇讻讛, but there is an opinion that it there has to be 讛砖拽讛 during the time you're 讟讜讘诇. So that's why always it's open on the side. So here you might close it, so you have two, two far apart so that you can't stand with both feet. That's one thing. Then in the middle you have a big flap that you could pick up and you could crawl there. So if you ever have to clean it, so you pick it up, and you empty the water, and you crawl under there to clean it, and then you close it and you seal it up again. Yes. You could you could do it, I mean you could do it. I know there is there is a mikveh in Yerushalayim that they actually always 讟讜讘诇 in rainwater. In a big Yeah, they have it on the side of the building. They have a big thing probably four stories high, they keep and then it stores, and then whenever it rains they open it up, and then whenever I don't know, but It could, I mean, probably could be, I mean, you know, then you'd always have to wait for the rain, and it's it's not so 驻砖讜讟. There's a pipe, like you say. First of all, the pipe also is standing this way and not this way is different, so you got a pipe through, so to say. It's not so simple. I wouldn't dare to say it. The only advantage they have is because of this 转砖讜讘讛 that they claim of the Divrei Chaim and that's all. There's no other advantage. There's no We know once it's already you want because of being in the bottom, except if we're not 讞讜砖砖 for this problem, there's no advantage in the side. The next thing the Rambam tells us, we spoke about this the other day, you have to be careful with the way you eat. 诇注讜诇诐 诇讗 讬讗讻诇 讗讚诐 讗诇讗 讻砖讛讜讗 专注讘, a person should never eat unless he's hungry, 讜诇讗 讬砖转讛 讗诇讗 讻砖讛讜讗 爪诪讗, and a person shouldn't drink unless he's thirsty. And even when you eat, 诇讗 讬诪诇讗 讻专住讜, a person shouldn't fill his stomach completely, 讗诇讗 讬驻讞转 讻诪讜 专讘讬注 诪砖讘注讜, like 25% empty, so don't eat fully. And he shouldn't drink in the middle of eating. You drink before, you drink after. Even water, not to drink too much.

← PREVIOUS
Ladies First
NOW PLAYING Choose a shiur to begin Rabbi Yehuda Leib Schapiro
0:00
0:00