Parshat Parah: Part 1
Why the ashes of the Parah Adumah, the least explicable mitzvah in the Torah, are called 'the chok of the Torah' itself.
Part of Days on the Jewish Calendar: Adar · 18:28
Traces why Parshat Parah is read before Parshat Hachodesh despite the chronological order of events at the Mishkan's dedication, then examines the category of chukim, mitzvot with no discernible reason, and why Parah Adumah stands out as the one even Shlomo Hamelech, the wisest of men, could not fathom. Develops the Alter Rebbe's teaching in Likkutei Torah that this chok represents the entire Torah in miniature: since Torah is Hashem's unlimited chochmah, it can never truly fit into a limited human mind, and every reason we grasp for a mitzvah is only the surface of something infinitely deeper. Concludes that a person must still labor to understand Torah's reasons while remembering that the Torah of the present is only a fraction of what will be revealed in the days of Moshiach.
Audio Transcript
On the 砖讘转 before we read 驻专砖转 讛讞讜讚砖, in which we read about the 拽专讘谉 驻住讞, we read the 驻专砖讛 of 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛. And the reason for that is, because in order to be able to bring the 拽专讘谉 驻住讞, you have to be 讟讛讜专. And in order for a person who became 讟诪讗 诪转, became 讟诪讗 by touching a dead body, in order for him to become 讟讛讜专, he has to be sprinkled with the 诪讬 讞讟讗转, with the water that had in it the ashes of the 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛. And therefore, we read first the 驻专砖讛 of 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛. As it says in 讬专讜砖诇诪讬, 诪讙讬诇讛, 驻专拽 讙 讛诇讻讛 讛, and it's brought down in 专砖''讬, 诪住讻转 诪讙讬诇讛 讚祝 讻讟 注诪讜讚 讗, and the 专讬''祝 brings it there, etc. And there it says that the 讚讬谉 讛讜讗 砖转拽讚讬诐 讛讞讜讚砖 诇驻专讛. Really, we should have read first 驻专砖转 讛讞讜讚砖, and then 驻专砖转 驻专讛. Why? 砖讘讗讞讚 讘谞讬住谉 讛讜拽诐 讛诪砖讻谉, because the 诪砖讻谉 was put up on the first day of 谞讬住谉, 讜讘砖谞讬 谞砖专驻讛 讛驻专讛, and on the second day of 谞讬住谉, that's when they burned and made the 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛. So the 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛 comes after 驻专砖转 讛讞讜讚砖. 讜诇诪讛 驻专讛 拽讜讚诪转? Why is the 驻专讛 first? 砖讛讬讗 讟讛专转谉 砖诇 讻诇 讬砖专讗诇, because in 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛 you have the 讟讛专讛 of all the 讗讬讚谉. Which means that we read first 驻专砖转 驻专讛. As 专砖''讬 says the 诇砖讜谉 in the 讙诪专讗 there, 诇讛讝讛讬专 讗转 讬砖专讗诇 诇讬讟讛专, to warn, to prepare the 讗讬讚谉 that they should purify themselves, 砖讬注砖讜 驻住讞讬讛谉 讘讟讛专讛, so they should be able to make their 拽专讘谉 驻住讞 讘讟讛专讛, and then we read 驻专砖转 讛讞讜讚砖, 砖砖诐 驻专砖转 讛驻住讞, because in 驻专砖转 讛讞讜讚砖 you have the 驻专砖讛 of the 驻住讞. So first we read the 驻专砖转 驻专讛, and then we read the 驻专砖转 讛讞讜讚砖, which deals with the 拽专讘谉 驻住讞. The 驻专砖讛 we read is the 驻专砖讛 of the 转讜专讛 in 驻专砖转 讞讜拽转, where the 转讜专讛 starts with saying 讝讗转 讞讜拽转 讛转讜专讛, this is the 讞讜拽讛 of the 转讜专讛, and it continues with all the 讚讬谞讬诐 of the 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛.
Now, the reason that it's introduced with the term 讞讜拽讛, so we all know that because a 讞讜拽讛 is a 诪爪讜讛 that has no reason. We know that there are three categories in the 转讜专讛: 讞讜拽讬诐, 注讚讜转, and 诪砖驻讟讬诐. 诪砖驻讟讬诐 are those 诪爪讜讜转 that the 砖讻诇 is 诪讞讬讬讘, that the 砖讻诇 itself, the logic of a person, tells a person that these are the 诪爪讜讜转 you have to keep, which means that if the 转讜专讛 讞住 讜砖诇讜诐 wouldn't have been given, we would have understood ourselves that these are the 诪爪讜讜转 you have to keep. As the 讙诪专讗 says in 注讬专讜讘讬谉: 讗讬诇诪诇讬 诇讗 谞讬转谞讛 转讜专讛, if the 转讜专讛 wouldn't have been given 讞住 讜砖诇讜诐, 讛讬讬谞讜 诇诪讚讬诐 讙讝诇 诪谞诪诇讛 讜爪谞讬注讜转 诪讞转讜诇, we would have learned out not to steal from an ant and to be 爪谞讜注讚讬拽 from a cat, which means that the 砖讻诇 itself would tell a person that these are 诪爪讜讜转 you have to keep. These are 诪爪讜讜转 of 诪砖驻讟讬诐. The 诪爪讜讜转 of 注讚讜转 are those 诪爪讜讜转 that have a reason, but if the 转讜专讛 wouldn't have been given, we wouldn't have kept it. After the 转讜专讛 told us to keep these 诪爪讜讜转, we know why we have to keep them, and most of them are 诪爪讜讜转 which are an 注讚讜转, like a testimony for certain things, like 驻住讞 is an 注讚讜转 for 讬爪讬讗转 诪爪专讬诐, etc. 讞讜拽讬诐 are those 诪爪讜讜转 that have no reason at all. And as the 诇砖讜谉 in 讞讝''诇 is that 讛砖诐 says that these 诪爪讜讜转 you have to keep because 讞讜拽讛 讞拽拽转讬, 讙讝讬专讛 讙讝专转讬, I made the 讞讜拽讛, I made the law, I made the decree, 讜讗讬谉 诇讱 专砖讜转 诇讛专讛专 讗讞专讬讛, you have no permission to even think about it, to look into it. Now, the truth is that most 诪爪讜讜转 in the 转讜专讛 are not 讞讜拽讬诐. Most of them are or 诪砖驻讟讬诐 or 注讚讜转. Nevertheless, there are some which are 讞讜拽讬诐. As the 诪讚专砖 says in 讘诪讚讘专 专讘讛, in 驻专砖转 讞讜拽转, 驻专砖讛 讬讟 讗讜转 讛, and also in 转谞讞讜诪讗 there, that 讗专讘注讛 讚讘专讬诐 讬爪专 讛专注 诪砖讬讘 注诇讬讛诐, there are four things which the 讬爪专 讛专注 asks about, 讚讻转讬讘 讘讛谉 讞讜拽讛, because the 驻住讜拽 says 讞讜拽讛 there: 讗砖转 讗讞, 讻诇讗讬诐, 砖注讬专 讛诪砖转诇讞, and 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛. In the 讙诪专讗 in 讬讜诪讗 讚祝 住讝 注诪讜讚 讘, there it says, 讗转 讞讜拽讜转讬 转砖诪讜专讜, so it says these are 讚讘专讬诐 砖讛砖讟谉 诪砖讬讘 注诇讬讛诐, these are things which the 砖讟谉, the 讬爪专 讛专注, they ask about, 讜讗诇讜 讛谉, these are these 诪爪讜讜转, and it mentions 讗讻讬诇转 讞讝讬专, eating 讞讝讬专, 诇讘讬砖转 砖注讟谞讝, wearing 砖注讟谞讝, 讞诇讬爪转 讬讘诪讛, giving 讞诇讬爪讛 to a 讬讘诪讛, 讟讛专转 诪爪讜专注, 砖注讬专 讛诪砖转诇讞, etc. So we see that there are quite a few 诪爪讜讜转 which are in the category of 讞讜拽讬诐. Nevertheless, out of all the 诪爪讜讜转 which are in the category of 讞讜拽讬诐, the 诪爪讜讛 of 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛 is the greatest 讞讜拽讛. As we find in the 诪讚专砖 that 砖诇诪讛 讛诪诇讱 says: 注诇 讻诇 讗诇讛 注诪讚转讬, on all these, meaning all the other 讞讜拽讬诐 I was able to understand, 讜驻专砖讛 砖诇 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛, 讞拽专转讬 讜砖讗诇转讬 讜驻砖驻砖转讬, concerning 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛, I investigated, I asked, I looked into it, and then he quotes the 驻住讜拽 in 拽讛诇转 讝, 讻讙: 讗诪专转讬 讗讞讻诪讛 讜讛讬讗 专讞讜拽讛 诪诪谞讬. I said I will be smart, I will try to understand this, but nevertheless 讜讛讬讗 专讞讜拽讛 诪诪谞讬, it is far from me. So we see that even though 砖诇诪讛 讛诪诇讱 was able to understand the reasons to all other 讞讜拽讬诐, to the 诪爪讜讛 of 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛 he could not understand the reason. So that shows that the real 讞讜拽讛, the real 诪爪讜讛 which is completely beyond understanding is the 诪爪讜讛 of 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛.
This explains why the 转讜专讛 uses the 诇砖讜谉 in the beginning of the 驻专砖讛 of 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛, 讝讗转 讞拽转 讛转讜专讛, this is the 讞讜拽讛 of the 转讜专讛. 诇讻讗讜专讛 it shouldn't have said 讝讗转 讞拽转 讛转讜专讛, this is the 讞讜拽讛 of the 转讜专讛, as if this is the only 讞讜拽讛 of the 转讜专讛. There are other 讞讜拽讬诐 in the 转讜专讛 as we said before. But according to what we just said, that this is the main 讞讜拽讛, that out of all the 讞讜拽讬诐 themselves, the real 讞讜拽讛, the 诪爪讜讛 that has no reason at all is the 诪爪讜讛 of 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛, this is why the 驻住讜拽 says 讝讗转 讞拽转 讛转讜专讛, this is the 讞讜拽讛 of the 转讜专讛, this is as if it's the only 讞讜拽讛 of the 转讜专讛 because the real 讞讜拽讛 of the 转讜专讛, which is in the category of 讞讜拽讛 讞拽拽转讬, 讙讝讬专讛 讙讝专转讬, and there is no reason at all, this is the 诪爪讜讛 of 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛. But we still have to understand the expression of the 驻住讜拽. What we just said that the reason the 转讜专讛 says 讝讗转 讞拽转 讛转讜专讛, even though there are more 讞讜拽讬诐 than 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛, is because this is the main 讞讜拽讛, this only explains how it is possible to write 讝讗转 讞拽转 讛转讜专讛. But still, it would have 诇讻讗讜专讛 been better if the 转讜专讛 would have not mentioned the word 转讜专讛 at all. The 转讜专讛 should have said 讝讗转 讞拽转 讛驻专讛, this is the 讞讜拽讛 of the 驻专讛. Now that the 转讜专讛 writes 讝讗转 讞拽转 讛转讜专讛 we say it's no contradiction to the fact that there are more 讞讜拽讬诐, because this is the main 讞讜拽讛. But it still doesn't explain why is it important for the 转讜专讛 to tell us that this is the main 讞讜拽讛 of all the 讞讜拽讬诐. It would have been simpler if the 转讜专讛 would have just written 讝讗转 讞拽转 讛驻专讛, this is the 讞讜拽讛 of the 驻专讛, just like the 转讜专讛 says 讝讗转 讞拽转 讛驻住讞, in 驻专砖转 讘讗, 驻专拽 讬\"讘, 驻住讜拽 诪\"讙, this is the 讞讜拽讛 of the 驻住讞, this is the introduction to the 驻专砖讛 of the 拽专讘谉 驻住讞. So the 转讜专讛 could have written here 讝讗转 讞拽转 讛驻专讛, this is the law, the 讞讜拽讛 of 驻专讛. Why does the 转讜专讛 not write that? The 转讜专讛 writes 讝讗转 讞拽转 讛转讜专讛 in order to tell us that this is the main 讞讜拽讛 of the 转讜专讛. Why is it important to know that this is the main 讞讜拽讛 of the 转讜专讛?
So the 讗诇讟专 专讘讬, the 讘注诇 讛转谞讬讗 in his 住驻专 诇拽讜讟讬 转讜专讛 on 驻专砖转 讞拽转 explains that the 转讜专讛 wants to tell us that this 讞讜拽讛 of 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛 is not just the main 讞讜拽讛 of the 转讜专讛, but this is really 讻诇诇讜转 讻诇 讛转讜专讛. This 诪爪讜讛 of 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛 is the general concept of what the whole whole 转讜专讛 is. Meaning, being that 驻专讛 讗讚讜诪讛 is the main 讞讜拽讛 which has no reason and 砖讻诇 whatsoever, this expresses the depth of what really the 转讜专讛 is. Because in truth we know that the 转讜专讛 is 讞讻诪转讜 砖诇 讛拽讚讜砖 讘专讜讱 讛讜讗, the 转讜专讛 is the 讞讻诪讛 of 讛砖诐, the wisdom of 讛砖诐. Now we have to understand that if it is the wisdom of 讛砖诐, it is impossible for a 谞讘专讗, for a creature, how great he should be, that he should grasp the wisdom of 讛砖诐. Being that 讛砖诐 is the 讘讜专讗, is the Creator, so any 谞讘专讗 that was created by the Creator, there is no 注专讱, there is no comparison between the creature, so to speak, the 谞讘专讗 and the 讘讜专讗. And therefore it's self-understood that it is impossible for the 谞讘专讗 to grasp what goes on by the 讘讜专讗. Especially as the 专诪讘状诐 puts it, that concerning 讛砖诐 we say that 讛讜讗 讜讞讻诪转讜 讗讞讚, He and His wisdom are one, not like by a human being, that you have the person and the person has wisdom within him, so there are two things, the person and the wisdom, but by 讛砖诐, 讛讜讗 讜讞讻诪转讜 讗讞讚, He and His wisdom are one. And even though it is impossible for us to understand how it is possible for Him and His wisdom to be one, nevertheless the 专诪讘状诐 quotes the 驻住讜拽, 讻讬 诇讗 诪讞砖讘讜转讬 诪讞砖讘讜转讬讻诐, my 诪讞砖讘讛 is not like your 诪讞砖讘讛, 讛砖诐's 诪讞砖讘讛 and 讛砖诐's 讞讻诪讛 is not like ours. 讛讞拽专 讗诇讜-讛 转诪爪讗, if you look into 讛砖诐 will you find, 讛砖诐's wisdom is not at all in the category of our wisdom, and it is impossible with our 砖讻诇 to understand how His wisdom is. But the fact is that He and His wisdom are one. So it's self-understood that just like it's impossible for the 砖讻诇 of a 谞讘专讗 to grasp the 讘讜专讗, the Creator, 讛砖诐 Himself, so too is it impossible for the 砖讻诇 of a 谞讘专讗 to grasp the 砖讻诇 of 讛砖诐, the 讞讻诪讛 of 讛砖诐. And it's self-understood that being of 讛砖诐 is 讘诇讬 讙讘讜诇, infinite, unlimited, so the 讞讻诪讛 that He has, or better said, the 讞讻诪讛 which is really one with Him, is also unlimited, is 讘诇讬 讙讘讜诇. So how is it possible for an unlimited 砖讻诇 to enter into the 砖讻诇 of a 谞讘专讗, which is 讘讛讙讘诇讛, which is limited? It is impossible for an unlimited thing to enter the limited thing. Just like the 讙诪专讗 says, it is impossible for 驻讬诇讗 讚拽讜驻讗 讚诪讞讟讗, it's impossible to put an elephant through the hole of a needle. And the reason is because the elephant is big and the hole of the needle is small, so it's impossible for something that is big to enter into something that's small. But the truth is, even the elephant, which is big, it's still 诪讜讙讘诇, it is still limited, and it is only with a certain amount of times bigger than the hole of the needle. Nevertheless, being that this is bigger and the hole of the needle is small, you can't push the elephant through the hole of the needle. Certainly, you cannot push something that's unlimited through something that's limited, or into something that's limited. So how is it possible for the 砖讻诇 of 讛砖诐, 讞讻诪转讜 砖诇 讛拽讚讜砖 讘专讜讱 讛讜讗, which is the 转讜专讛, to enter into the 砖讻诇 of a person? And therefore, in essence, it really is impossible to grasp the 砖讻诇 of the 转讜专讛. And as the 驻住讜拽 puts it in very simple words in 讗讬讜讘, in 讗讬讜讘 讻\"讞, 驻住讜拽 讻\"讗, 讜谞注诇诪讛 诪注讬谞讬 讻诇 讞讬, that the 转讜专讛 is hidden from the eyes of any living creature, because the 转讜专讛 is the 讞讻诪讛 of 讛砖诐, so therefore then any living thing, any creature cannot grasp the 讞讻诪讛 of 讛砖诐. Nevertheless, we are able to learn 转讜专讛 and able to understand 转讜专讛 as much as it is possible. This itself is a 讞住讚 of 讛砖诐, the kindness of 讛砖诐, that He made that we should be able to grasp 注谞讬谞讬诐 of 转讜专讛. He, so to speak, lowered the 转讜专讛 to such a 诪讚专讙讛, such a way that we should be able to grasp it. And this itself only came because 讛砖诐 is 讻诇 讬讻讜诇, 讛砖诐 could do anything, and there is no such thing as a contradiction or an impossibility by 讛砖诐, and therefore 讛砖诐 was able to take His unlimited wisdom and put it in such a way that we, with our limited minds, should be able to take it. And that is the reason we are able to understand certain things of 转讜专讛. And when we do a 诪爪讜讛, which is the 专爪讜谉 of 讛砖诐, the will of 讛砖诐, we are able to understand to a certain degree the 砖讻诇, the meaning, the logic behind these 诪爪讜讜转. But the truth is, in essence, as much as we understand, this is like nothing compared to the real 砖讻诇 which is in the 转讜专讛, and the real 砖讻诇 of 讛砖诐 which is behind every 诪爪讜讛. But because 讛砖诐 did us this favor and let us understand a little bit in most 诪爪讜讜转, it is possible for a person to make a mistake and think that really these are the complete reasons for these 诪爪讜讜转, and not realize that in essence the real reasons for the 诪爪讜讜转 and the real 注谞讬谞讬诐 that are in the 转讜专讛 are really much deeper and much higher in such a way that it is impossible for us to grasp. They are really 讘诇讬 讙讘讜诇, and they are so high that it's completely out of the realm of the 砖讻诇 of a 谞讘专讗. And therefore, 讛砖诐 made it that we should have certain 诪爪讜讜转, even if there are a few, but certain 诪爪讜讜转 in the 转讜专讛 that have no reason for them. So when we do these 诪爪讜讜转 that have no reason, we understand that 讘讗诪转 there is a great reason for it, the reasons are so deep that we cannot grasp. And when we do some 诪爪讜讜转 that have no reason, this brings us to understand that in essence the whole 转讜专讛 is like that. That even those 诪爪讜讜转 that do have a reason, and even those words of 转讜专讛 that we do understand, what we understand is not the real understanding of what it really is, this is just the tip of what the 砖讻诇 of 转讜专讛 is and the 砖讻诇 behind the 诪爪讜讜转 are, and really it is much higher and much deeper. But even amongst those 讞讜拽讬诐, being that 住讜祝 讻诇 住讜祝 there is some reason, and at least 砖诇诪讛 讛诪诇讱 was able to understand, so after all, we could think that even though we don't understand it, but it is not because the 砖讻诇 itself is beyond the comprehension of a human being. 讜讛专讗讬讛, 砖诇诪讛 讛诪诇讱, which was also a human being, and nevertheless, he was able to understand. Therefore, 讛砖诐 gave us at least one 诪爪讜讛 that even 砖诇诪讛 讛诪诇讱 wasn't even able to understand, even though he was the 讞讻诐 诪讻诇 讗讚诐, he was the smartest person out of all people. And if he wasn't able to understand, and he said, 讗诪专转讬 讗讞讻诪讛 讜讛讬讗 专讞讜拽讛 诪诪谞讬, \"I tried to understand this, and I see it's too far from me.\" So then a 讗讬讚 will understand that this is a 诪爪讜讛 that the reason is completely completely beyond the comprehension of a human being. And this will instill in the person the feeling that just like this one 诪爪讜讛, even the way we have it, the way we fulfill it, we see in it that the truth is that this has such depth which is 讘诇讬 讙讘讜诇 and is the 讞讻诪讛 of 讛砖诐 beyond the comprehension of a human being, so too are all other 诪爪讜讜转. And that is the reason 讛砖诐 gave us this one special 诪爪讜讛, which has no reason whatsoever, that we should get the feeling that in truth this is the whole 转讜专讛. The whole 转讜专讛 really is beyond our understanding. The essence of the 转讜专讛 is the way it is the 讞讻诪转讜 砖诇 讛拽讚讜砖 讘专讜讱 讛讜讗. And what we have is only that 讛砖诐 lowered His 砖讻诇 in such a way to do us a 讞住讚 that we should be able to grasp a little bit of it. But in essence, all the 诪爪讜讜转 are really 讞讜拽讬诐, are really higher than understanding. And this is the reason the 转讜专讛 says, 讝讗转 讞拽转 讛转讜专讛, this is the 讞讜拽讛 of the 转讜专讛, and it doesn't say 讝讗转 讞拽转 讛驻专讛, this is the 讞讜拽讛 of the 驻专讛, to teach us that this 讞讜拽讛 is the whole 转讜专讛. In essence, what the whole 转讜专讛 is is expressed in this one 讞讜拽讛, being that this is the main 讞讜拽讛, as we said before, because this is a 诪爪讜讛 that has no reason whatsoever, even 砖诇诪讛 讛诪诇讱 couldn't understand it. So from that, we get to understand what the whole 转讜专讛 is. Because if we wouldn't even have one such 诪爪讜讛, then people would think that after all, the 转讜专讛 is a 砖讻诇 which is 讘讙讚专 the category of a human being to understand, and we wouldn't get the feeling that there is more to it. We would think that this is the essence of the whole 转讜专讛. But certain things we don't understand because our mind is not so great. A greater person, even though he has a limited mind, will be able to understand. But when we have one 诪爪讜讛 which is completely beyond understanding, that shows us that the depth of the 转讜专讛 is really completely beyond understanding.
Nevertheless, we have to work on understanding the 转讜专讛. We have to work on understanding the reason of the 诪爪讜讛. Why? Because this is what 讛砖诐 wants. He wants us to learn 转讜专讛 with our 砖讻诇. He wants us to do the 诪爪讜讜转 and try to understand the reason of the 诪爪讜讜转. But the reason why we should want to understand the 转讜专讛 is in itself because 讛砖诐 commanded us in the 转讜专讛 to learn 转讜专讛, to try to understand. But at the same time, we have to remember, as much as we understand, we shouldn't think that we have the whole 转讜专讛 and we understand everything the way it is, and this is as far as the depth of the 转讜专讛 goes. That is not so. This is only a 讞讬爪讜谞讬讜转 of the thing. It is a very superficial part of what the 转讜专讛 is. When 诪砖讬讞 will come, then we'll get to understand much deeper parts of the 转讜专讛. As the 诪讚专砖 says, that 转讜专讛 砖诇 注讜诇诐 讛讝讛 讻讛讘诇 诇讙讘讬 转讜专转讜 砖诇 诪砖讬讞. The 转讜专讛 we learn now is like 讛讘诇, like nothing compared to the 转讜专讛 of 诪砖讬讞. And the question is, what do we mean? 讞住 讜砖诇讜诐, this 转讜专讛 is not the 转讜专讛 of 讛砖诐? How can we say this is 讛讘诇 诇讙讘讬 what we're going to learn then? But what it means is that the way we understand the 转讜专讛 now is nothing compared to the way we will understand the same 转讜专讛 later, the depth of the 转讜专讛. Just like the 专诪讘状诐 says that when 诪砖讬讞 will come, we'll understand much more, even what 讛砖诐 is, so too will we understand much more in the 讞讻诪转讜 砖诇 讛拽讚讜砖 讘专讜讱 讛讜讗, the 转讜专讛.