A Woman's Vow, and the Danger of Breaking One
A Woman's Vow, and the Danger of Breaking One
Part of Halacha, Hashkafa and Parenting · 13:45
Covers the Shaar Hakollel's special vidui prayers, the halachic foundations of terumah and maaser, and a case study of a sick woman seeking release from a vow she can't fulfill.
Audio Transcript
Hashem never said this guy, and each individual who made the Yidden work chose. If he wouldn't choose, there would be another way. The Eibershter would make it happen, but you chose, that's what. Anyways, zogt di Gemara vayter, 转谞讜 专讘谞谉, the 专讘谞谉 taught like this: 诪讬 砖讞诇讛 讜谞讟讛 诇诪讜转, if someone is sick, God forbid, and he is dying, 讗讜诪专讬诐 诇讜, we say to him, 讛转讜讚讛, say vidui. 砖讻诇 讛诪讜诪转讬谉 诪转讜讚讬谉, because in the 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖, not in the time of the 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖, when 讘讬转 讚讬谉 would kill, before they would kill a person, when he deserves to be killed, they would tell him, \"Say vidui, confess.\" So from there we see that a person before he dies should confess, and this is unfortunately many times people at that stage already not conscious, and they don't know what it's good, but if they are. Actually, you saw in on COL, this bachur who died, a bachur from from Morristown, a twenty-eight-year-old bachur, yeah, yeah, two days ago. I think Shavuos night, actually, Friday night. A talmid of my son, a nice guy. So Friday after No, he was sick already for a for a while, and anyway, so my son was with him Friday, and he said vidui. He wanted to say vidui. He was With your son? Who's with Chaim in Morristown. So the rabbi says it? Well, yeah, I guess he told him what to say, and he said. What
What do they say? Well, shama there's a whole in the siddur, in Shaar Hakollel Siddur, there he has. Is it the one we say, the long one from at night? No, no, it's different. It's a different lashon, it's a completely different lashon. Because it says in 拽讘诇讛 住驻专讬诐 that right before a person dies the yetzer hara or the Satan or whatever name we'll give the guy comes to the person, he says now throws in 诪讞砖讘讜转 now of 讻驻讬专讛, denying Hashem. The last minute, he wants at least the last minute denying Hashem. So that's why you have to be very strong at that time. So by saying vidui, part of the vidui, I think, says against the yetzer hara. In which siddur? It's not in our regular siddur? Not in regular siddur, but in the Shaar Hakollel Siddur, the the Torah Or Siddur. Torah Or Siddur, which is And the big siddurim might have it? No, only the only the only the Torah Torah Or Siddur. The 讘讬转 讚讬谉 would urge people to to say vidui? Not urge, force them. Force them? How can you force someone on their deathbed, how can you force them? Force them. What, they're not on their deathbed, they're they're not sick. 讘讬转 讚讬谉 is killing them. Oh. You hear him right. You said that if a person, if there are no witnesses at a Still has to go, but nobody's going to send him there, why should he run? But he still has to go. He has to go, but he's not going to do it. Who wants to go to an 注讬专 诪拽诇讟 to stay there? So if you have to, you're afraid that the 讙讜讗诇 讛讚诐 or the guy, then you go, but no one saw, no one knows, so that was that. Yeah, but this is a very small one. Yeah, in this siddur they have vidui. A very small thing, theirs is much longer. Here also they have vidui. It's a different nusach. 讜讬讚讜讬 砖诇 砖讻讬讘 诪专注. Confession on the deathbed. Confession of No, this is not Lubavitch. Ashkenaz. Ashkenaz. But in Lubavitch, in Torah Or Siddur, there you have a whole thing from the Alter Rebbe. 转谞讜 专讘谞谉, the 专讘谞谉 taught like this: 诪讬 砖讞诇讛 讜谞讟讛 No, we're through that. 讗讚诐 讬讜爪讗 诇砖讜拽, a person, you should know an example, a person goes out into the street. Now,
when you're outside there in the world, you don't know what's going to happen to you. 讞住 讜砖诇讜诐, you cross the street, a car flashes here, you find people, people can start up with you, I mean, God forbid. So 讬讛讬 讚讜诪讛 讘注讬谞讬讜, you have to imagine, 讻诪讬 砖谞诪住专 诇住专讚讬讜讟, that you are now at the point as if you're going to, let's call it a goyishe court, you're being given over to a goyishe officer to be judged, and you don't know what the outcome is going to be. So you have to be nervous. And what do you do then if this would happen? You daven, Eibershter, please protect me. So you've got to do that when you cross the street. In simply, in our words, if you cross the street, you have to look at it as if you're being given over to this judge. Don't go outside. Go outside and daven. 讞砖 讘专讗砖讜, if it took a little step further, not only you might, something might happen, you have a headache, something is happening to you, something not normal is happening to you, 讬讛讬 讚讜诪讛 讘注讬谞讬讜 讻诪讬 砖谞转谞讜讛讜 讘拽讜诇专. That should be already this is already a step further. Step further when you're already being put into a cell or in chains. 注诇讛 诇诪讟讛 讜谞驻诇, you went onto the bed and you fell, in other words something worse than a headache happened, 讬讛讬 讚讜诪讛 讘注讬谞讬讜 讻诪讬 砖注诇讜讛讜 诇讙专讚讜诐. You have to imagine as if they're taking you to be hanged. You're already there. And what do you do then? Then you really daven to the Eibershter, \"Please help me.\" So here also, 砖注诇讜讛讜 诇讙专讚讜诐 诇讬讚讜谉. It's not you're going to be hanged, you're going, getting to this last stage of the case. 砖讻诇 讛注讜诇讬诐 诇讙专讚讜诐 诇讬讚讜谉, anybody who's taken to that stage to be judged, so here you're a very slight chance to come out innocent. 讗诐 讬砖 诇讜 驻专拽诇讬讟讬谉 讙讚讜诇讬诐, only if you have a lot of great lawyers, not lawyers, lawyers, a defense, that sort of a defense, 谞讬爪讜诇, and You'll be saved. 讗诐 诇讗讜, if you don't have a lot, 住转诐 讗讝 讗讬谞讜 谞讬爪讜诇, so you have to feel that way. So what are the defenses of a person? 讗诇讜 讛谉 驻专拽诇讬讟讬谉, these are the defenses 砖诇 讗讚诐, of a 讗讬讚, 转砖讜讘讛, 诪注砖讬诐 讟讜讘讬诐. If you do that, you're protected. Have a lot of good friends to pray for you. Huh? That also? Yeah. Yeah, praying. Yeah, praying, other people's prayers. But your own yourself, what should you do? You know, you should daven. In a certain situation you can't even think, you're delirious or everything else like that. Yeah, that's what other people are for, yeah. Because if you
do 转砖讜讘讛, 诪注砖讬诐 讟讜讘讬诐, then what will happen is like this, 讗驻讬诇讜 转转拽爪状讟 诪诇诪讚讬诐 注诇讬讜 讞讜讘讛, if you have 999 诪诇讗讻讬诐 who are prosecuting you, speaking against you, 讜讗讞讚 诪诇诪讚 注诇讬讜 讝讻讜转, and you have only one 诪诇讗讱 out of a thousand that will find a 讝讻讜转, if you did 转砖讜讘讛, 诪注砖讬诐 讟讜讘讬诐, they'll accept that one. If no 诪诇讗讱 even says, then there's no no no defense. But if you have, you do 转砖讜讘讛, 诪注砖讬诐 讟讜讘讬诐, then Hashem will overlook the 999 诪诇讗讻讬诐 who are prosecuting and will take the one that's that's 砖谞讗诪专, he quotes the 驻住讜拽, as we say there, 讗诐 讬砖 注诇讬讜 诪诇讗讱 诪诇讬抓 讗讞讚 诪谞讬 讗诇祝, if you have a malach, that's a melitz, means a defender, one out of a thousand, 诇讛讙讬讚 诇讗讚诐 讬砖专讜, 讜讬讞谞谞讜, that to tell the person that you're right. 讜讬讗诪专 驻讚注讛讜 诪专讚转 砖讞转, and the malach says, save him from going down to Gehinnom, the Eibershter will listen. One out of a thousand. 专讘讬 讗诇注讝专 讘谞讜 砖诇 专讘讬 讬讜住讬 讛讙诇讬诇讬 讗讜诪专, 专讘讬 讗诇注讝专 讘谞讜 砖诇 专讘讬 讬讜住讬 讛讙诇讬诇讬 says, not only 999 malachim against one 诪诇讗讱, 讗驻讬诇讜 转砖注 诪讗讜转 讜转砖注讬诐 讜转砖注讛 讘讗讜转讜 诪诇讗讱 诇讞讜讘讛 讜讗讞讚 诇讝讻讜转. The malach himself, the rest, all of them say against him. Even the malach, the good malach, has 999 reasons why he's guilty, but he has one reason himself why he is innocent, so natzol, he will be saved if you do teshuvah, maasim tovim. Shenemar, it says, 诪诇讬抓 讗讞讚 诪谞讬 讗诇祝, there's one, not one malach, one melitz, meaning one good word, one good defense against a thousand, against nine, 909, one out of a thousand, even in the same person will save him. So it pays to do teshuvah, I guess, maasim tovim. Looks like it's worth it. Huh? That's what they say. Well, this is confirming you confirming it. Now it's confirmed. Zogt di
讙诪专讗 vayter, 转谞讬讗, it says in a beraisa, 专讘谉 砖诪注讜谉 讘谉 讙诪诇讬讗诇 讗讜诪专, 专讘谉 砖诪注讜谉 讘谉 讙诪诇讬讗诇 says, 讛诇讻讜转 讛拽讚砖, 转专讜诪讜转 讜诪注砖专讜转, 讛谉 讛谉 讙讜驻讬 转讜专讛. The halachos of 讛拽讚砖, when you're 诪拽讚讬砖 something, you make it holy for the 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖, for the 讘讚拽 讛讘讬转, for the fund of the upkeep of the 讘讬转 讛诪拽讚砖, and terumah, taking of terumah, taking of maaser, these are such major halachos of Torah. You take a 拽专讘谉 讛拽讚砖 before you you make Yeah, that's that's one type of 讛拽讚砖, yeah. You have to say something. You can't just bring it inside. True, true, yeah. But we're talking bichlal, if a person takes an object and says, let this be 讛拽讚砖. So this becomes 讛拽讚砖, and all kinds of dinim. And there are so in so many details to know these 讚讬谞讬诐, 讜谞诪住专讜 诇注诪讬 讛讗专抓, that was given over even to 注诪讬 讛讗专爪讬诐. Every yid has to take off terumah umaaser. Every yid has is able to make 讛拽讚砖. So it's given over to people who don't know. It's a shame, he says, that so many people don't know when it's such a major inyan in Torah. Tanya, it says in another 讘专讬讬转讗, 专讘 谞转谉
讗讜诪专, Rav Natan says, 讘注讜谉 谞讚专讬诐 诪转讛 讗砖转讜 砖诇 讗讚诐, for the sin of transgressing nedarim, not keeping your vows, chas veshalom, a person's wife will die. Wife? 砖谞讗诪专, it says, 讗诐 讗讬谉 诇讱 诇砖诇诐 诇诪讛 讬拽讞 诪砖讻讘讱 诪转讞转讬讱. Says, listen, if you don't want to pay, in other words, you make a a a neder to bring a korban or whatever, other kinds of neder, and you're not able to keep it, don't make the neder. Why do something that will cause that the Eibershter will take your your mishkav, your your your bed under you? So what does that refer to? The Eibershter will take your wife under your wife away from you. Why? Because you're not keeping your neder. So we see from here that for not keeping a neder. That's why 谞讚专讬诐 讘讻诇诇 by Yidden was known such a important not to make any nedarim. There are some people who constantly, you know, curse. When I say curse, I don't mean saying bad words, curse they make a neder. That the Hashem should hope, he says, or on himself he says, I'm telling you the truth, if I don't tell the truth, I should die. I mean people say that. Simply just making a promise that you don't keep, you know, like saying bli neder. Yeah, I'm saying always say bli neder. And there are some people who are not careful, who are not careful and they say it, and you've got to be very careful.
Whenever we learn this Gemara, I always tell you the story with this lady that came to me. I'll tell it again. Once a lady called me up from from airport, she's stopping from Argentina, she has to go into New York, but she stopped here for a few hours. She wants to come to my house to be 诪转讬专 谞讚专. So she came to the house and what was the story? So she said she lived downstairs, her in-laws lived upstairs, and she used to always go up and help her mother-in-law, and into a fight or something, and she made a neder not to go upstairs anymore. And she said, \"I make a neder that if I go up, I should become blind.\" So much so. After a while, she made up with her. And she didn't care about the neder, and then she started going up. And she says she's losing her eyesight. So she wants to be 诪转讬专 谞讚专. Before one rav you can be 诪转讬专 谞讚专? No. So I called in a few of my neighbors, and we were 诪转讬专 谞讚专 her. I don't know what happened to her, I never heard of her again, I don't know where she is. Lady, 住驻专讚讬砖注 lady. You see, you don't play around with nedarim. In Gemara, Caesarea, Jewish Caesarea, 2,000 villages it's like They're all destroyed. The people in those villages made nedarim and kept them. That's that's another deraga that you shouldn't make nedarim even if you keep them. You shouldn't make nedarim in the first place. Yeah. You shouldn't make nedarim. But not to keep? 驻讛 驻讛 That's 注诇 驻讬 拽讘诇讛 it says, look at the siddur, the whole reason why the 讚专讙 of neder doesn't apply now: 讜诇讻谉 讗讜诪专讬诐 注诇 讻诇 讚讘专 讘诇讬 谞讚专. That's why we have to say on everything bli neder.
What if a person makes a 谞讚专, but then he gets sick or something, he can't You have to be 诪转讬专 谞讚专. That's 诪转讬专 谞讚专. You have to That's that's how you How can he be 诪转讬专 谞讚专? 诪转讬专 谞讚专 is you find a 驻转讞 讞专讟讛, that means you find a reason, like saying, \"Had I known I'd be sick, I'd never make a 谞讚专.\" That's the reason to be 诪转讬专 谞讚专, but you have to be 诪转讬专 谞讚专. Same thing when you do something good three times, even if you didn't make it as a 谞讚专, it becomes like a 谞讚专. And if for some reason you have to change it, even if it was good you have to be 诪转讬专 谞讚专, you have to It's not with permission, it's 诪转讬专 谞讚专. You find a reason why that wasn't really part of that that didn't include wasn't included. What about the shul? They say 讛转讜专诐 诇爪讚拽讛, is a 谞讚专? So first of all, you should say bli neder, and they say and they say 讘诇讬 Even if you don't, it's known that it's bli neder. But best thing to do I think in this siddur No, in the other siddur they printed bli neder. This siddur I don't know. But in the other Israeli siddur, by the tapes of the they it's printed, it says bli neder. Oh, this one, it says for sure. This one I I didn't look up, but here I know they did that. I'll show you. Yeah. Yeah, here. 诪讬 砖讘专讱 讜讬专驻讗讛讜 讘注讘讜专 砖 this and this person 讬转谉 讘诇讬 谞讚专 诇爪讚拽讛 讘注讘讜专讜. Here also, 诪讬 砖讘专讱 诇讞讜诇讛, this 讬转谉 讘诇讬 谞讚专 诇爪讚拽讛. When a son, a child is born, 诪讬 砖讘专讱 注诇 讗砖讛 讬讜诇讚转 讜谞讜诇讚 诇讛 讜诇讚 讘注讘讜专 砖讘注诇讛 讜讗讘讬讜 讬转谉 讘诇讬 谞讚专 诇爪讚拽讛 讘注讚诐. And it says a mareh makom at the bottom, why should you say bli neder? 注诇 驻讬 讛讙讛讜转 爪诪讞 爪讚拽, from the Tzemach Tzedek. Is there is there an idea that you come back in the next gilgul to fulfill all the promises you didn't keep? In halacha that doesn't work. That has to do with kabbalah. What's the connection between 谞讚专 and the wife or your wife? Because biklal by a wife we find a din that a person could nullify her 谞讚专讬诐, so there is some some But 讘注诇 讛讘讬转 砖拽讬讘诇 注诇讬讜 A husband can A husband could nullify 谞讚专讬诐 of his wife. I know, so mimeila there is some connection in 谞讚专讬诐 between husband and wife, that's like a a bond that's between them. Remind me again and again about the shiur tonight. So what's the problem to come back in a